A (in)aplicabilidade do acordo de não persecução penal na Justiça Militar da União: uma análise do conflito entre o precedente 18 do STM e a jurisprudência do STF na perspectiva do direito processual penal militar.
Revista ft · 07.08.2026 · 30 (161) · 01-45
DOI: 10.69849/gyfwdg64 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Revista ft, online erschienen am 07.08.2026. Verfasst von Robson Rangel de Freitas. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The present work aims to analyze the (in)applicability of the NonProsecution Agreement (ANPP) in the Military Justice of the Union, focusing on the conflict between Precedent No. 18 of the Superior Military Court and the jurisprudence of the Federal Supreme Court. The research starts from the problem of verifying whether the absolute prohibition of the institute within the scope of the Military Justice of the Union finds sufficient constitutional basis or whether it should be reinterpreted in the light of the Constitution of the Republic of 1988, international human rights treaties and the evolution of consensual criminal justice in the Brazilian legal system. The general objective is to examine the compatibility of Precedent No. 18 of the STM with the constitutional principles of human dignity, equality, proportionality, due process, efficiency of criminal prosecution and reasonable duration of the process, as well as with the international commitments assumed by the Brazilian State. For this, the deductive method was used, through bibliographical, documentary, and jurisprudential research, with analysis of the Federal Constitution, the Military Criminal Code, the Code of Military Criminal Procedure, the Code of Criminal Procedure, Law No. 13,964/2019, the American Convention on Human Rights, the jurisprudence of the Federal Supreme Court, the Superior Military Court, and the Superior Court of Justice,in addition to the specialized doctrine in Military Criminal Law, Military Criminal Procedural Law, Constitutional Law and Human Rights. Initially, the historical evolution of consensual criminal justice and the incorporation of the Non-Prosecution Agreement into the Brazilian legal system are analyzed. Next, the constitutional particularities of the Military Justice of the Union, the foundations of Precedent No. 18 of the Superior Military Court and the evolution of the jurisprudence of the Federal Supreme Court on the ANPP are analyzed. Subsequently, a critical examination of the conflict between these orientations is developed, in the light of the control of constitutionality, the control of conventionality and the systematic interpretation of article 3 of the Code of Military Criminal Procedure. It is concluded that the specialty of the Military Justice of the Union constitutes a legitimate constitutional basis, but does not authorize, by itself, the absolute exclusion of consensual criminal justice mechanisms. The research argues that the most compatible solution with the Democratic Rule of Law lies in the harmonization between the protection of military hierarchy and discipline and the effectiveness of fundamental rights, through interpretation in accordance with the Constitution and case-by-case analysis of the compatibility of the Non-Prosecution Agreement with the nature of the military crime and with the legal assets effectively protected. simultaneously preserving the autonomy of the Military Justice and the advances of consensual criminal justice in the Brazilian legal system.
Zitieren
APA
Freitas, R. R. D. (2026). A (in)aplicabilidade do acordo de não persecução penal na Justiça Militar da União: uma análise do conflito entre o precedente 18 do STM e a jurisprudência do STF na perspectiva do direito processual penal militar. Revista ft, 30(161), 01-45. https://doi.org/10.69849/gyfwdg64
Vancouver
Freitas RRD. A (in)aplicabilidade do acordo de não persecução penal na Justiça Militar da União: uma análise do conflito entre o precedente 18 do STM e a jurisprudência do STF na perspectiva do direito processual penal militar. Revista ft. 2026;30(161):01-45. doi:10.69849/gyfwdg64
BibTeX
@article{Freitas2026,
author = {Freitas, Robson Rangel de},
title = {A (in)aplicabilidade do acordo de não persecução penal na Justiça Militar da União: uma análise do conflito entre o precedente 18 do STM e a jurisprudência do STF na perspectiva do direito processual penal militar},
journal = {Revista ft},
year = {2026},
volume = {30},
number = {161},
pages = {01--45},
doi = {10.69849/gyfwdg64}
}
EUVIMED