An Analysis of the Valuation of Convertible Bond Call Options in Korean Tax Tribunal Decisions : Focusing on Accounting Fair Value and Fair Market Value for Tax Purposes
THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION · 30.06.2026 · 43 (2) · 9-39
DOI: 10.35850/kjtr.43.2.01 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Junyong Shim.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This study examines a Korean Tax Tribunal decision concerning the application of the denial of wrongful calculation provision under Article 52 of the Corporate Tax Act to convertible bonds with a third-party designated call option issued by KMW Co., Ltd. In 2018, the company issued convertible bonds with a face value of KRW 25 billion, granting the issuer or a party designated by the issuer a call option to require bondholders to sell up to 35% of the bond principal. On July 25, 2019, the company designated its CEO and the CEO’s spouse as purchasers of the convertible bonds. They subsequently acquired the bonds and exercised the conversion rights. The tax authority treated this designation as a gratuitous transfer to related parties of the economic benefit of the call option held by the company and applied the denial of wrongful calculation provision. The Korean Tax Tribunal recognized the call option as an economically valuable right to require the sale of the convertible bonds and held that the purchaser designation transferred the economic benefit of that right to related parties. The Tribunal also found that the valuation method applied by an external bond valuation agency using a binomial model was not unlawful or unreasonable in this case. However, the Tribunal ordered a correction to exclude from the taxable amount the short-swing profit that the CEO had returned to the company under the Capital Markets Act and that the company had already recognized as taxable income. This study reconstructs the accounting treatment of the convertible bonds using the company’s public disclosures and audit report notes and links the results to the tax reasoning in the Tribunal decision. The analysis shows that the accounting amounts related to the convertible bonds were complex outputs involving the conversion option value, derivative liabilities, conversion adjustment, transaction costs, the effective interest method, and deferred tax effects. This accounting complexity does not negate the applicability of the denial of wrongful calculation provision itself. Rather, it provides supporting evidence that, when a valuation model is used to determine fair market value for tax purposes, careful consideration should be given to the valuation date, the scope of the right being valued, input variables, and sensitivity analysis. This study suggests that taxation of third-party designated call options requires an integrated consideration of asset recognition, fair market value measurement, the final attribution of economic benefits, and book-tax differences.
Zitieren
APA
Shim, J. (2026). An Analysis of the Valuation of Convertible Bond Call Options in Korean Tax Tribunal Decisions : Focusing on Accounting Fair Value and Fair Market Value for Tax Purposes. THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION, 43(2), 9-39. https://doi.org/10.35850/kjtr.43.2.01
Vancouver
Shim J. An Analysis of the Valuation of Convertible Bond Call Options in Korean Tax Tribunal Decisions : Focusing on Accounting Fair Value and Fair Market Value for Tax Purposes. THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION. 2026;43(2):9-39. doi:10.35850/kjtr.43.2.01
BibTeX
@article{Shim2026,
author = {Shim, Junyong},
title = {An Analysis of the Valuation of Convertible Bond Call Options in Korean Tax Tribunal Decisions : Focusing on Accounting Fair Value and Fair Market Value for Tax Purposes},
journal = {THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION},
year = {2026},
volume = {43},
number = {2},
pages = {9--39},
doi = {10.35850/kjtr.43.2.01}
}
EUVIMED