EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

A Comprehensive Study on Real Estate Valuation for Tax Purposes under the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act: Focusing on Appraisal-Based Taxation by the National Tax Service

Sukyung Kim

THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION · 31.12.2024 · 41 (4) · 331-368

DOI: 10.35850/kjtr.41.4.11 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION, online erschienen am 31.12.2024. Verfasst von Sukyung Kim.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

As of the present time, four years have elapsed since the National Tax Service (NTS) conducted appraisals of non-residential real estate. Despite ongoing controversies in academic and practical circles regarding whether the NTS may lawfully conduct appraisals or retroactive appraisals for taxation purposes, lower court rulings issued since 2022 have consistently upheld the legality of retroactive appraisals-where the price determination date aligns with the appraisal reference date, excluding initially conducted appraisals. These rulings rely on the Supreme Court’s holding in Decision 2000Du5098 (rendered on August 21, 2001), which interpreted Article 49 of the Enforcement Decree of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act (hereinafter, the “Enforcement Decree”) as an illustrative provision. The NTS has further announced plans to expand the scope of retroactive appraisals to include residential real estate, which is anticipated to give rise to increased disputes. This study examines the legislative characteristics of Korea’s fair market value evaluation framework, the legislative history of recognizing appraised values as fair market value, judicial interpretations of retroactive appraisals and Article 49 of the Enforcement Decree, and the recent Supreme Court decision (2020Du54265, rendered on April 12, 2024). The analysis seeks to determine whether the interpretation that permits retroactive appraisals, premised on the illustrative nature of Article 49, remains a valid legal basis after the 2014 amendment to the Enforcement Decree explicitly prohibited retroactive appraisals. The Supreme Court has consistently acknowledged the normative authority of Article 49 of the Enforcement Decree by ruling that appraisal values derived through methods that contravene the Enforcement Decree do not constitute “fair market value” as defined under the Act. At the time of Decision 2000Du5098, Article 49 of the Enforcement Decree did not explicitly prohibit retroactive appraisals. Accordingly, the legal character of Article 49 and the permissibility of retroactive appraisals are not inherently linked. The interpretation of Article 49 as an “illustrative provision” merely signifies that methods of assessing fair market value, consistent with the principle of market value under Article 60 of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act, may be “added” to those prescribed in Article 49 of the Enforcement Decree. Therefore, following the 2014 amendment explicitly prohibiting retroactive appraisals under Article 49, the illustrative nature of the provision can no longer serve as a legal basis for permitting retroactive appraisals. This interpretation aligns with the recent Supreme Court ruling (2020Du54265), which reaffirmed that appraised values derived through methods violating the Enforcement Decree cannot qualify as fair market value, even when considering the illustrative nature of Article 49. The present legality of retroactive appraisals must be assessed in light of their compliance with the proviso to Article 49(1) of the Enforcement Decree. This study concludes that retroactive appraisals conducted by the NTS do not meet the conditions for fair market value under Article 49, based on both textual and systematic interpretations. The proviso unequivocally requires that the appraised value exist outside the appraisal period. Conducting retroactive appraisals, wherein the appraisal reference date and price determination date coincide, precludes any price fluctuation. This renders the proviso’s conditions of extraordinary price fluctuations and Appraisal Review Committee deliberations moot, thereby negating the legislative intent of limiting the appraisal period. Such an approach exceeds the permissible boundaries of textual interpretation.

Zitieren

APA

Kim, S. (2024). A Comprehensive Study on Real Estate Valuation for Tax Purposes under the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act: Focusing on Appraisal-Based Taxation by the National Tax Service. THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION, 41(4), 331-368. https://doi.org/10.35850/kjtr.41.4.11

Vancouver

Kim S. A Comprehensive Study on Real Estate Valuation for Tax Purposes under the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act: Focusing on Appraisal-Based Taxation by the National Tax Service. THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION. 2024;41(4):331-368. doi:10.35850/kjtr.41.4.11

BibTeX
@article{Kim2024,
  author = {Kim, Sukyung},
  title = {A Comprehensive Study on Real Estate Valuation for Tax Purposes under the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act: Focusing on Appraisal-Based Taxation by the National Tax Service},
  journal = {THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION},
  year = {2024},
  volume = {41},
  number = {4},
  pages = {331--368},
  doi = {10.35850/kjtr.41.4.11}
}
Kostenlos starten →