A Study on the Criteria for Determining Comprehensive Business Transfers under the Value-Added Tax Act : An Empirical Analysis of Tax Tribunal Decisions
KOREAN SOCIETY OF TAX LAW · 30.09.2026 · 11 (3) · 63-99
DOI: 10.37733/tkjt.2026.11.3.63 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift KOREAN SOCIETY OF TAX LAW, online erschienen am 30.09.2026. Verfasst von Kyung-In Lim.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The Value-Added Tax Act generally excludes qualifying transfers of a business from the scope of taxable supplies in order to facilitate business continuity and promote tax neutrality. However, while the Act and its Enforcement Decree require the comprehensive succession of rights and obligations relating to a business, they do not provide clear criteria or a structured framework for determining whether a transaction constitutes a comprehensive business transfer. Consequently, disputes continue to arise concerning business continuity, the succession of rights and obligations, changes in business activities, the transferee's acquisition purpose, and the scope of succession. This study aims to establish a systematic framework for determining comprehensive business transfers under the Value-Added Tax Act. To this end, it examines the relevant statutory provisions and Supreme Court precedents and conducts an empirical analysis of 73 decisions rendered by the Tax Tribunal from 2017 through April 8, 2026. To enable consistent comparative analysis, recurring legal issues were classified using Issue (I) Codes, while factual factors centrally considered in the Tax Tribunal's reasoning were categorized using Factor (F) Codes. The findings indicate that Supreme Court precedents require the existence of an independently recognizable business organization and assess whether the identity and continuity of the business are maintained through the substantive succession of relevant rights and obligations, taking the circumstances of the transaction as a whole into account. Likewise, the Tax Tribunal considers not only these core factors but also transaction form and tax treatment, the transferee's acquisition purpose, the scope of succession, and the existence of an independent business unit. The empirical analysis further reveals recurring co-occurrence patterns between legal issues and factual factors, confirming that determinations regarding comprehensive business transfers are based on an overall assessment of multiple factors rather than on any single criterion. Based on these findings, this study integrates the doctrinal principles established by Supreme Court precedents with the empirical findings derived from Tax Tribunal decisions and proposes a structured decision-making framework consisting of the following sequential steps: (1) the existence of an independent business unit; (2) the legal characterization of the transaction; (3) business continuity and identity; (4) the succession of rights and obligations; (5) transaction form and tax treatment; (6) an overall assessment of the transferee's objectively ascertainable acquisition purpose, the scope of succession, and post-transaction circumstances considered only to the extent that they help ascertain the substance of the business succession at the time of the transaction; and (7) the final determination of whether the transaction constitutes a comprehensive business transfer. This study contributes to the existing literature by combining doctrinal analysis with empirical research, introducing analytical frameworks based on Issue and Factor Codes, and presenting a systematic decision-making framework that enhances the consistency, predictability, and practical application of legal interpretation concerning comprehensive business transfers under the Value-Added Tax Act.
Zitieren
APA
Lim, K. (2026). A Study on the Criteria for Determining Comprehensive Business Transfers under the Value-Added Tax Act : An Empirical Analysis of Tax Tribunal Decisions. KOREAN SOCIETY OF TAX LAW, 11(3), 63-99. https://doi.org/10.37733/tkjt.2026.11.3.63
Vancouver
Lim K. A Study on the Criteria for Determining Comprehensive Business Transfers under the Value-Added Tax Act : An Empirical Analysis of Tax Tribunal Decisions. KOREAN SOCIETY OF TAX LAW. 2026;11(3):63-99. doi:10.37733/tkjt.2026.11.3.63
BibTeX
@article{Lim2026,
author = {Lim, Kyung-In},
title = {A Study on the Criteria for Determining Comprehensive Business Transfers under the Value-Added Tax Act : An Empirical Analysis of Tax Tribunal Decisions},
journal = {KOREAN SOCIETY OF TAX LAW},
year = {2026},
volume = {11},
number = {3},
pages = {63--99},
doi = {10.37733/tkjt.2026.11.3.63}
}
EUVIMED