Achieving PFO closure with the NobleStitch Technique
Catheterization and Cardiovascular Interventions · 2023
DOI: 10.1002/ccd.30748 ↗At a glance
Leserbrief in Catheterization and Cardiovascular Interventions, 2023. Written by Bryan Kluck and 2 co-authors. Institution: Lehigh Valley Heart Institute, Lehigh Valley Health Network, Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA. Major MEDLINE topics: Foramen Ovale, Patent, Stroke, Septal Occluder Device. 8 references.
Abstract (original language)
To the Editor, We read with great interest the recent article “Anatomical Predictors for Suture Based Closure of Patent Foramen Ovale: A Multicenter Experience.” We would heartily agree that the suture‐based technology discussed has a unique role in patients that have tenuous bleeding status, greater potential for arrhythmias, and in whom preservation of an unobstructed intra‐atrial septum for future cardiac procedures is important. In addition, device embolization or erosion is obviated if suture‐based closure is utilized. We have utilized this technique as well in cases of patient or combined physician preference, documented hypercoagulability, and suspected Nickel Sensitivity. We have not, to date, utilized this procedure for migraine or decompression illness prevention, a significant portion of this trial population. The success rate of the NobleStitch procedures in this trial seems to be somewhat at odds with the elsewhere quoted success rates. The authors are to be congratulated on providing an additional set of measurements to aid in a successful outcome. Equally important would however be meticulous attention to suture and quiknot delivery, mandatory utilization of ICE, and adequate institutional patient volumes. In our experience, the NobleStitch requires training, precise execution, and successive cases to achieve mastery and maintenance of skills. In the initial days of Gortex‐based devices, the early device generations required a much more complicated delivery protocol. The satisfactory training and support for high‐level success fell on the shoulders of a clinical specialist force supplied by the manufacturer. In an analogous fashion, the NobleStich EL system has a learning curve before mastery and, optimally, a sufficient case volume to maintain skills to achieve reliable and effective closure. In this trial, there were relatively few procedures performed, multiple institutions, and a rather long period of case accrual. It has been our observation that optimal case volume to proficiency requires somewhere in the range of 10 cases at a short interval. This is substantiated by the manufacturer's recommendation of 10 cases before certification. The manuscript does not comment on operator certification, but the numbers cited raise a question as to where on the learning curve each operator stood. There has been a recent publication regarding the efficacy of virtual expert observation in acquiring NobleStitch proficiency. Given the low volumes and low cases per year noted, we wonder if that assistance was utilized to help get optimal outcomes. In addition, the timeframe of this study brings in the possibility that earlier generation devices were included. The utility of intracardiac echocardiography (ICE) has been invaluable to us. We have used ICE on all PFO closure cases for over a decade. The manuscript points to only one of the two institutions using this tool. As such, most procedures in this trial were not ICE guided. ICE provides several important advantages. It allows conscious sedation and thus near optimal patient cooperation when performing the necessary Valsalva maneuver, unlike TEE. Intraprocedural assessment of satisfactory closure is thus possible. ICE further allows the operator to assess the adequacy of tension on the suture ends while delivering the Quiknot (so called “Kluck sign”). Beyond this, the manuscript does not specify the number of sutures utilized to achieve the defined outcome of success. In our experience, the utilization of multiple sutures has occasionally been necessary. Early, we noted several episodes of suture noncapture or suture detachment during delivery. As experience grew, these happened less often. Nonetheless, intraprocedural ICE and contrast fluoroscopy sometimes demonstrated unacceptable residual “leak.” This was followed by a second suture delivery. In all cases, our patients left the catheterization laboratory with ≤grade 1 residual leak. This was followed up in all cases with a predischarge echocardiogram with color flow/agitated saline. In those stitch cases with grade 1 residual “leak” intraprocedurally, the “leak” did not persist on final predischarge studies. Small residual “leaks” do not appear to be associated with recurrent strokes. It has further been our experience that while tunnel length, septal mobility, and separation are notable factors, the procedural success rate is not entirely determined by this anatomy. Procedural success would however certainly be unfavorably affected if imaging was insufficient to determine the sufficiency of closure intraprocedurally. These features, as well as the measurements suggested in the current paper, are more likely to identify the need for multiple sutures required to achieve closure, not necessarily the overall procedural success. Finally, patients with unacceptable closure at 3 months returned for repeat procedure utilizing a device. The upfront decision to utilize suture rather than a device would be based on clinical circumstances favoring suture closure. Those clinical circumstances would likely persist and, as such consideration of repeat suture attempt rather than default device implant would certainly be a consideration.
Subjects
MeSH terms (MEDLINE)
Authors and institutions
- Lehigh Valley Heart Institute, Lehigh Valley Health Network, Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA.
ORCID profiles: Rahul Gupta
Cite
APA
Kluck, B., Ramic, D., & Gupta, R. (2023). Achieving PFO closure with the NobleStitch Technique. Catheterization and Cardiovascular Interventions. https://doi.org/10.1002/ccd.30748
Vancouver
Kluck B, Ramic D, Gupta R. Achieving PFO closure with the NobleStitch Technique. Catheterization and Cardiovascular Interventions. 2023. doi:10.1002/ccd.30748
BibTeX
@article{Kluck2023,
author = {Kluck, Bryan and Ramic, Dzanan and Gupta, Rahul},
title = {Achieving PFO closure with the NobleStitch Technique},
journal = {Catheterization and Cardiovascular Interventions},
year = {2023},
doi = {10.1002/ccd.30748}
}
EUVIMED