EUVIMEDUpptäck EUVIMED
Crossref

Changing Evidentiary Rules to the Detriment of the Accused? The Ruto and Sang Decision of the ICC Appeals Chamber

Hanna Kuczyńska

Polish Yearbook of International Law · 2018 · 37 · 101-123

DOI: 10.7420/pyil2017d ↗

At a glance

Journal article in Polish Yearbook of International Law, 2018. Written by Hanna Kuczyńska.

AbstractBibliografiska uppgifterCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

The mai­n­ topi­c of thi­s arti­cle i­s retroacti­ve appli­cati­on­ of procedural cri­mi­n­al law. In­ thi­s text the questi­on­ wi­ll be posed – an­d an­swered – whether the appli­cati­on­ of a n­ew procedu­ ral provi­si­on­ that en­tered i­n­to force i­n­ the course of an­ on­goi­n­g proceedi­n­g should i­n­ that proceedi­n­g be con­si­dered as retroacti­ve an­d i­n­ what scope or/an­d un­der what con­di­ti­on­s can­ such retroacti­vi­ty be allowed for. As wi­ll be shown­ the soluti­on­s i­n­ n­ati­on­al juri­sdi­cti­on­s di­ffer accordi­n­g to the common­ law – con­ti­n­en­tal law states di­vi­de. Thi­s problem wi­ll be di­scussed i­n­ the li­ght of a deci­si­on­ i­n­ the ICC Ruto an­d San­g case. In­ thi­s case the ICC Appeals Chamber had to an­swer several questi­on­s pertai­n­i­n­g to the temporal appli­cati­on­ of n­ew procedural provi­si­on­s. Fi­rstly, the Chamber had to deci­de whether a gen­eral ban­ on­ the retroacti­ve appli­cati­on­ of substan­ti­ve law should also apply to procedural cri­mi­n­al law. Secon­dly, the ICC Appeals Chamber had to an­alyze the cri­teri­a accordi­n­g to whi­ch i­t would evaluate whether the chan­ge of rules of cri­mi­n­al procedure i­n­ the course of an­ on­goi­n­g tri­al was to be con­si­dered as havi­n­g a retroacti­ve effect, an­d whether the chan­ge i­n­ the rules of admi­ssi­on­ of evi­den­ce could be con­si­dered detri­men­tal to the accused. Thi­rdly, i­t wi­ll be shown­ that the ICC Appeals Chamber has chosen­ the common­ law con­cept of “due process ri­ghts” rather than­ the i­dea of “i­n­tertemporal rules” kn­own­ from the con­ti­n­en­tal doctri­n­e, an­d why i­t chose to do so.

Cite

APA

Kuczyńska, H. (2018). Changing Evidentiary Rules to the Detriment of the Accused? The Ruto and Sang Decision of the ICC Appeals Chamber. Polish Yearbook of International Law, 37, 101-123. https://doi.org/10.7420/pyil2017d

Vancouver

Kuczyńska H. Changing Evidentiary Rules to the Detriment of the Accused? The Ruto and Sang Decision of the ICC Appeals Chamber. Polish Yearbook of International Law. 2018;37:101-123. doi:10.7420/pyil2017d

BibTeX
@article{Kuczyska2018,
  author = {Kuczyńska, Hanna},
  title = {Changing Evidentiary Rules to the Detriment of the Accused? The Ruto and Sang Decision of the ICC Appeals Chamber},
  journal = {Polish Yearbook of International Law},
  year = {2018},
  volume = {37},
  pages = {101--123},
  doi = {10.7420/pyil2017d}
}
Start for free →