EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Durability versus performance in total knee arthroplasty: has the safe zone become patient-specific?

Vitor Barion Castro de Padua

Mentors in Orthopedics · 10.09.2026 · 8 (043)

DOI: 10.71165/96o9-mjbr ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Mentors in Orthopedics, online erschienen am 10.09.2026. Verfasst von Vitor Barion Castro de Padua.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

For four decades, mechanical alignment and its neutral ±3° ‘safe zone’ have been the cornerstone of total knee arthroplasty (TKA), underpinning excellent long-term implant survival. Yet around one patient in five remains dissatisfied after a technically successful procedure, a reminder that durability and performance are not synonymous. This narrative review traces the shift from mechanical towards personalised alignment and asks whether a universal safe zone can still be defended or should give way to a patient-specific model. Drawing on survivorship studies, phenotype classifications, gap analyses and systematic reviews, it critically examines the assumptions underlying the classic safe zone. A 20-year follow-up of cemented TKAs showed no survival or functional advantage for knees aligned within ±3° of neutral. More than 30% of men have constitutional varus beyond this range, and the Coronal Plane Alignment of the Knee (CPAK) classification describes nine phenotypes. Ligamentous behaviour also varies widely among knees with similar alignment, so even radiographically ‘correct’ mechanical alignment can leave the soft tissues imbalanced. Kinematic, restricted kinematic and functional alignment aim to personalise implant positioning while respecting native anatomy and limiting soft-tissue releases; their short- and mid-term results are encouraging. However, evidence-based limits for personalised alignment have yet to be established, and long-term survivorship data remain scarce. In place of a single safe zone, the review offers surgeons and researchers a framework of four complementary safety domains: bony (limb axis and joint-line obliquity within defined boundaries), ligamentous (preservation of native laxity and avoidance of unnecessary releases), implant (each design’s tolerance of alignment variation) and functional (the patient’s expectations and activity level). Optimising one domain while neglecting the others can produce a radiographically perfect yet functionally disappointing knee. Robotic assistance and patient-specific planning may allow an individual target range to be defined preoperatively and verified intraoperatively. The future of TKA may therefore lie not in abandoning safety but in redefining it: rather than a single number, the safest zone may be a patient-specific balance between implant longevity and restored function.

Zitieren

APA

Padua, V. B. C. D. (2026). Durability versus performance in total knee arthroplasty: has the safe zone become patient-specific?. Mentors in Orthopedics, 8(043). https://doi.org/10.71165/96o9-mjbr

Vancouver

Padua VBCD. Durability versus performance in total knee arthroplasty: has the safe zone become patient-specific?. Mentors in Orthopedics. 2026;8(043). doi:10.71165/96o9-mjbr

BibTeX
@article{Padua2026,
  author = {Padua, Vitor Barion Castro de},
  title = {Durability versus performance in total knee arthroplasty: has the safe zone become patient-specific?},
  journal = {Mentors in Orthopedics},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {8},
  number = {043},
  doi = {10.71165/96o9-mjbr}
}
Kostenlos starten →