Entre a universalidade formal e a efetividade material dos direitos humanos: seletividade penal e encarceramento em massa no sistema prisional brasileiro a partir da ADPF 347.
Revista ft · 21.05.2026 · 30 (158)
DOI: 10.69849/bns98q05 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Revista ft, online erschienen am 21.05.2026. Verfasst von José Antônio Nunes Aguiar und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article analyzes the tension between the formal universality of human rights and their material effectiveness within the Brazilian prison system, taking as its central axis the Claim of Noncompliance with Fundamental Precept No. 347 (ADPF 347). The research is based on the hypothesis that mass incarceration in Brazil does not constitute a mere administrative crisis or a circumstantial insufficiency of the penitentiary system, but rather a structural expression of the selective rationality of contemporary punitive power. Through a qualitative approach, based on bibliographical research, jurisprudential analysis, and the use of institutional data produced by the National Secretariat of Penal Policies and the Brazilian Forum on Public Security, the study articulates theoretical contributions from Norberto Bobbio, Michel Foucault, Alessandro Baratta, Vera Regina Pereira de Andrade, Cláudio Alberto Gabriel Guimarães, Eugenio Raúl Zaffaroni, Florencia Luna, Achille Mbembe, Carlos Alexandre de Azevedo Campos, Ana Maria D’Ávila Lopes and Silviane Maria Cavalcante de Brito Pinheiro Freire. The article discusses how the recognition of an unconstitutional state of affairs by the Brazilian Supreme Federal Court reveals the dissociation between the normative recognition of fundamental rights and the material implementation of constitutional guarantees within Brazilian prisons. It argues that penal selectivity operates as an institutional mechanism of social containment, disproportionately affecting historically vulnerable groups, especially poor and Black populations. The study concludes that the persistence of structural violations of fundamental rights compromises the democratic legitimacy of the punitive system and exposes the concrete limits of juridical universality within contemporary penal structures.
Zitieren
APA
Aguiar, J. A. N., & Mesquita, S. C. L. (2026). Entre a universalidade formal e a efetividade material dos direitos humanos: seletividade penal e encarceramento em massa no sistema prisional brasileiro a partir da ADPF 347. Revista ft, 30(158). https://doi.org/10.69849/bns98q05
Vancouver
Aguiar JAN, Mesquita SCL. Entre a universalidade formal e a efetividade material dos direitos humanos: seletividade penal e encarceramento em massa no sistema prisional brasileiro a partir da ADPF 347. Revista ft. 2026;30(158). doi:10.69849/bns98q05
BibTeX
@article{Aguiar2026,
author = {Aguiar, José Antônio Nunes and Mesquita, Sílvio Carlos Leite},
title = {Entre a universalidade formal e a efetividade material dos direitos humanos: seletividade penal e encarceramento em massa no sistema prisional brasileiro a partir da ADPF 347},
journal = {Revista ft},
year = {2026},
volume = {30},
number = {158},
doi = {10.69849/bns98q05}
}
EUVIMED