EUVIMEDAtrasti EUVIMED
Crossref

A Legal Analysis of The Practice of Review Manipulation (Fake Reviews) on Marketplaces as A Form of Unfair Business Competition in Indonesia

Raihan Muhammad Maliki, Muhammad Fahmi Ramdhani, Syifa Walidatunnisa, Muhammad Habib Al badawy, Najda Inayah Nurfadiah, Muhammad Alhikam Badruttamam, Arzhety Ityana Kamalia Mukhlis, Nandang Najmudin

Journal of Management, Entrepreneurship, and Tourism · 2026-05-23 · 1 (2) · 183-192

DOI: 10.65310/jkdfzb74 ↗

At a glance

Journal article in Journal of Management, Entrepreneurship, and Tourism, published online on 2026-05-23. Written by Raihan Muhammad Maliki and 7 co-authors.

SantraukaBibliografiniai duomenysCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

This study examines the legal status of review manipulation practices in digital marketplaces and evaluates their qualification as a form of unfair business competition within the Indonesian legal framework. Employing a non empirical legal research design with a normative juridical approach, the study analyzes statutory regulations, legal doctrines, and conceptual principles related to competition law, consumer protection, electronic transactions, and criminal law. The findings indicate that fake reviews constitute a deceptive mechanism that distorts market transparency and creates artificial competitive advantages that are inconsistent with the principles of fair competition. Although Indonesian Competition Law does not explicitly regulate fake reviews, systematic and teleological interpretation demonstrates that such practices contradict the objectives of maintaining equal market opportunities and protecting competitive neutrality. The analysis further reveals significant regulatory fragmentation among consumer protection, electronic transaction, and criminal law regimes, resulting in enforcement difficulties and legal uncertainty. Comparative examination of foreign regulatory developments suggests the importance of strengthening marketplace accountability, establishing mandatory review verification systems, improving digital evidence standards, and expanding institutional oversight. Legal reform is therefore necessary to ensure effective governance of digital marketplaces and preserve competitive integrity in Indonesia’s evolving digital economy.

Cite

APA

Maliki, R. M., Ramdhani, M. F., Walidatunnisa, S., badawy, M. H. A., Nurfadiah, N. I., Badruttamam, M. A., Mukhlis, A. I. K., & Najmudin, N. (2026). A Legal Analysis of The Practice of Review Manipulation (Fake Reviews) on Marketplaces as A Form of Unfair Business Competition in Indonesia. Journal of Management, Entrepreneurship, and Tourism, 1(2), 183-192. https://doi.org/10.65310/jkdfzb74

Vancouver

Maliki RM, Ramdhani MF, Walidatunnisa S, badawy MHA, Nurfadiah NI, Badruttamam MA, et al. A Legal Analysis of The Practice of Review Manipulation (Fake Reviews) on Marketplaces as A Form of Unfair Business Competition in Indonesia. Journal of Management, Entrepreneurship, and Tourism. 2026;1(2):183-192. doi:10.65310/jkdfzb74

BibTeX
@article{Maliki2026,
  author = {Maliki, Raihan Muhammad and Ramdhani, Muhammad Fahmi and Walidatunnisa, Syifa and badawy, Muhammad Habib Al and Nurfadiah, Najda Inayah and Badruttamam, Muhammad Alhikam and Mukhlis, Arzhety Ityana Kamalia and Najmudin, Nandang},
  title = {A Legal Analysis of The Practice of Review Manipulation (Fake Reviews) on Marketplaces as A Form of Unfair Business Competition in Indonesia},
  journal = {Journal of Management, Entrepreneurship, and Tourism},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {1},
  number = {2},
  pages = {183--192},
  doi = {10.65310/jkdfzb74}
}
Start for free →