EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Whitehead and the Axianoetic Tradition: A Speculative Relational Synthesis of Axiarchism, Idealism, and Theism

Andrew M. Davis

Revue roumaine de philosophie · 01.12.2025 · 69 (2) · 385-399

DOI: 10.59277/rrp.2025.69.2.13 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Revue roumaine de philosophie, online erschienen am 01.12.2025. Verfasst von Andrew M. Davis.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

It is underappreciated that the history of philosophical idealism, with its various affirmations of primordial mind, is also a history of axiarchism, the position that all existence is also founded on value. (Lossky, 1935; Leslie, 1979; Leslie 2001; MacDonald, 1991; Ferré, 1996) The intimate coupling of idealism and axiarchism constitutes the heart of what I have recently termed the “axianoetic” tradition of philosophical theology (Gr. axia: “worth” or “value,” + noētikos: “mind” or “mental activity”). (Davis, 2020) For this tradition, both value and mind are constitutive of divine and worldly reality, albeit with different emphases and priorities available, and various forms of theism, pantheism, and panentheism defensible. (Buckareff, Nagasawa 2016; Davis, 2020; Lougheed, 2024) The origins of the axianoetic tradition date back to Plato and Aristotle and are differently inherited by key figures throughout western philosophical and theological history, including Plotinus, Anselm, Aquinas, Descartes, Leibniz, Spinoza, Hegel, Whitehead, A.C. Ewing, and a variety of contemporary voices including, Keith Ward, John Leslie, and Peter Forrest (among others). Readings of the axianoetic tradition are diverse. Some thinkers prioritize abstract value as the condition of concrete mind, while others prioritize concrete mind as conditioning all abstract value. Still others suggest a deep mutuality between value and mind, such that each reciprocally sustains the other. The present article aims to express these respective priorities through the meeting of John Leslie’s axiarchism, Keith Ward’s personal idealism, and Alfred North Whitehead’s axianoetic philosophical theology. In dialogue with these figures, I seek to demonstrate how Whitehead might inspire a synthesis of axiarchism, idealism, and theism through a relational affirmation of value and mind for each other. What this involves is an axianoetic justification of abstract value by virtue of its relationship to concrete mind, and concrete mind by virtue of its relationship to abstract value. This reciprocity may be conceived in terms of the kind of relationality that Whitehead terms “mutual immanence,” where value lends to mind what mind cannot lend itself, just as mind lends to value what value cannot lend itself. In so doing, each reasons and explains the other. Although Whitehead does not state it in precisely this way, I will show that A.C. Ewing has done so explicitly, and in ways that not only resonate with Whitehead’s own expressions of mutual immanence, but also include and relativize the respective priorities of Leslie and Ward. I will conclude by suggesting that what is gained in the meeting of Leslie, Ward, Whitehead, and Ewing is speculative insight into the nature of divine necessity as beholden to the axianoetic tradition, and a particular interpretation of this tradition that prioritizes the mutual immanence of value and mind in God.

Zitieren

APA

Davis, A. M. (2025). Whitehead and the Axianoetic Tradition: A Speculative Relational Synthesis of Axiarchism, Idealism, and Theism. Revue roumaine de philosophie, 69(2), 385-399. https://doi.org/10.59277/rrp.2025.69.2.13

Vancouver

Davis AM. Whitehead and the Axianoetic Tradition: A Speculative Relational Synthesis of Axiarchism, Idealism, and Theism. Revue roumaine de philosophie. 2025;69(2):385-399. doi:10.59277/rrp.2025.69.2.13

BibTeX
@article{Davis2025,
  author = {Davis, Andrew M.},
  title = {Whitehead and the Axianoetic Tradition: A Speculative Relational Synthesis of Axiarchism, Idealism, and Theism},
  journal = {Revue roumaine de philosophie},
  year = {2025},
  volume = {69},
  number = {2},
  pages = {385--399},
  doi = {10.59277/rrp.2025.69.2.13}
}
Kostenlos starten →