Resurrection: Extraordinary Evidence for an Extraordinary Claim
Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith · 2026-06 · 78 (2) · 131-133
DOI: 10.56315/pscf6-26meader ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 2026-06. Verfasst von Nick Meader.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
RESURRECTION: Extraordinary Evidence for an Extraordinary Claim by Nick Meader. Eugene, OR: Resource Publications, 2024. 286 pages. Paperback; $29.98. ISBN: 9781666783056. *In Resurrection, statistician and health psychologist Nick Meader notes: "Christians and atheists discussing Jesus' resurrection can sometimes resemble young children on a play date. They use the same toys but play alongside each other--rather than with each other" (p. 11). The brilliance of his book is precisely that it encourages Christians and atheists to come face-to-face. In doing so, Meader plays, and plays well, the role of the rational parent who gets these children to interact directly with each other by providing them with a universal language for conversation: the language of probability. *The primary thesis of the book is that if you apply probability-based statistical modeling (common tools in my own field of psychology) to atheists' claims that the resurrection of Jesus is not probable, those models show that atheists are wrong. In fact, these probability models reveal that the traditional Christian explanation of the widespread belief that Jesus miraculously rose from the dead is more probable than the other explanations that have been offered over the years as alternatives. *To make this case, the book opens with one of the cleverest applications of probabilistic reasoning to apologetics I have ever seen: Meader uses statistical modeling to evaluate a famous example given by atheist philosopher David Hume. To illustrate the kind of evidence he believed we ought to see if something unusual was true, Hume argued that if an eight-day period of darkness had truly occurred in 1600, this extraordinary fact would be matched by equally powerful evidence demonstrating its validity; expected evidence that Hume himself subsequently articulated. Meader, however, beats Hume at his own game by showing that probability modeling suggests Hume's own hypothetical evidence would not be enough to make the hypothetically true event probable! *After that opening salvo, the book turns its attention to atheists' Hume-like arguments that Christians should have extraordinary evidence for such an extraordinary claim as the resurrection of Christ. Because probability modeling is based on the prior likelihood of an explanation being true, much of the book focuses on establishing the prior probabilities associated with things that contribute to our understanding of Jesus's resurrection, ranging from naturalistic worldviews to psychological mechanisms involved in interpretations of the event. At the close of the book, Meader then quantifies all of these probabilities into a series of statistical models that consistently show that the Christian explanation is the most likely. *The primary strength of the book lies in its much-welcome application of the probabilistic method to apologetics. Even if one disagrees with the conclusions--and Meader acknowledges the limitations, quite admirably calling the model a "work in progress"--the application of probabilistic models to such an important religious event is (at a minimum) a meaningful conversation starter. It forces both sides to truly evaluate the probability estimates that, in reality, are already a part of their argument calculus. *The primary weakness of the book is an offshoot of this strength: Meader (who is an extremely successful and highly cited scientist) is of course aware of that the output of any probability model is only as good as the prior probability estimates that go into it; this explains why the book spends the majority of its energy defending the specific probabilities that go into the model. I imagine, however, that many of these probability estimates will be the source of future debate. For the sake of brevity, I will here limit my own comments to specific examples from my own areas of expertise within psychology. *In almost every psychological case (ranging from cognitive dissonance to mass psychosis), I agreed with Meader's prior probability estimates. However, two possible difficulties stood out to me. First, in chapter 8, Meader argues that Christian theology has a higher probability of being true because it is simpler than naturalism. I have spent my entire career studying psychological complexity,1 and I find this argument lacking. Something is not more likely to be true because it is simpler. As I argued in my Christian apologetics book Complex Simplicity (2017), the world is, in fact, quite complex. Mere psychological or structural simplicity does not increase the probability of a match with that reality. Further, Christian doctrine is (as Meader acknowledges) often quite complex, and theism is almost by definition more complex than naturalism in that it posits everything naturalism posits plus the supernatural. *Second, Meader discusses many psychological arguments that might offer alternative accounts of the spread of Christian belief, but in my view he fails to clearly articulate the most probable one: an explanation based not in mass psychosis or cognitive dissonance, but in the much more mundane psychological properties of selective communication. Research suggests, for example, that information is passed on because it is communicable or interesting independent of its truth value.2 As anyone who has played the game "telephone" can attest, it does not take very long in a communication chain for reality to be reshaped. Of course, communication often does work, and most of what we know that is true about our world is because of accurate communication from other people. But even though I disagree with atheists' ultimate conclusions, I have nonetheless thought communication distortion was their best argument--and it seems omitted from Meader's probability models. *To help offset these difficulties inherent in estimating prior probabilities, Meader provides multiple estimates in which he changes the parameters in a more atheist-friendly way. On balance, these alternative estimates--despite being biased toward atheism--still show a pro-Christian conclusion. (Indeed, I wanted more of this kind of analysis; the most useful part of the technique is to illuminate exactly what it would take for each side to "win" the probability debate). However, I could not entirely shake the feeling that the overall result seemed at times like a large kitchen sink that is in danger of running the very risk Meader is trying to overcome: If the final probability estimate is dependent on the author being right on this many things, perhaps the model itself cannot be trusted? *No work is perfect, especially one that attempts such a grand undertaking as Meader does. But in the final analysis, this book is well worth reading. Indeed, Resurrection accomplishes an amazing double: It provides an excellent summary of the burgeoning area of probabilistic apologetics for the curious outsider and simultaneously offers a remarkable novel contribution for the knowledgeable insider. I have never read anything quite like it, and I hope it inspires a generation of Christian apologists to use probability theory to honestly explore--and defend--our faith. *Notes *1For example, Lucian Gideon Conway III and Alivia Zubrod, "Are US Presidents Becoming Less Rhetorically Complex? Evaluating the Integrative Complexity of Joe Biden and Donald Trump in Historical Context," Journal of Language and Social Psychology 41, no. 5 (2022): 613-25, https://doi.org/10.1177/0261927X221081126. *2For a summary, see Lucian Gideon Conway III and Mark Schaller, "How Communication Shapes Culture," in Frontiers of Social Psychology: Social Communication, ed. K. Fiedler (Psychology Press, 2007), 107-27. *Reviewed by Lucian Gideon Conway III, PhD, Department of Psychology, Grove City College, PA.
Zitieren
APA
Meader, N. (2026). Resurrection: Extraordinary Evidence for an Extraordinary Claim. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 78(2), 131-133. https://doi.org/10.56315/pscf6-26meader
Vancouver
Meader N. Resurrection: Extraordinary Evidence for an Extraordinary Claim. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith. 2026;78(2):131-133. doi:10.56315/pscf6-26meader
BibTeX
@article{Meader2026,
author = {Meader, Nick},
title = {Resurrection: Extraordinary Evidence for an Extraordinary Claim},
journal = {Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith},
year = {2026},
volume = {78},
number = {2},
pages = {131--133},
doi = {10.56315/pscf6-26meader}
}
EUVIMED