The Impending Crisis In Healthcare
The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration · 2001
DOI: 10.5580/1eb0 ↗At a glance
Journal article in The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration, 2001.
Abstract (original language)
The extremely small, and diminishing, labor supply pool in the healthcare sector is exposing an alarming weakness in the industry. Human capital management practices in many healthcare organizations are dangerously outdated and, if left unchecked, will do irreparable harm. There is a solution but it is not a quick fix and will require considerable investment of time, effort, and energy. ThinkShed, Inc. is a consulting and software company that enables healthcare organizations to implement effective human capital management strategies. ThinkShed is leveraging research and methods from Berkeley, Santa Clara and Stanford Universities to build web based software that dramatically speeds and improves the execution of these strategies. Everything ThinkShed does is focused on the delivery of tangible, demonstrable return on human capital investment. ThinkShed is the Xerox PARC of human capital management; they work at the cutting edge of theory and practice and are, without a doubt, the shape of things to come. Visit ThinkShed at www.thinkshed.com or contact Keith Jones at keith@thinkshed.com or 512 615 6580 to find out more. “The definition of insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” Benjamin Franklin, 1706-1790 THE PROBLEM IN HEALTHCARE Employee turnover in the healthcare sector is extremely high; so high in fact that in some US states it is more than double the national average of 15.6%. This alarming (and rapidly worsening) statistic costs healthcare systems billions of dollars every year and is a direct threat to the future of the healthcare sector. So why is employee turnover so high? At first glance it would appear that the root cause of this problem is an extremely small talent-supply pool leading to a whirlwind of aggressive headhunting amongst competing healthcare organizations. It is ThinkShed’s view, however, that the real cause of this crippling turnover is poor human capital management in the healthcare sector. Certainly, the severe shortage of talent does not help matters, but it is a compounding factor rather than the cause itself. It is also ThinkShed’s view that as a compounding influence, limited talent supply is going to get worse rather than better. Although many healthcare organizations may not recognize it, high turnover will be the difference between corporate success and failure. Data gathered by the Department of Health & Human Services in their 2000 Sample Survey of Registered Nurses provides compelling evidence of the existing problem and the impending crisis: 1. The average age of nurses is climbing rapidly In 1980 more than 50% of RNs were younger than 40, in 2000 that figure has dropped to 31% In 2000 the average age of the RN population was 45.2 years nearly 1 year older than in 1996 2. The number of nurses entering the profession is declining In the 4 years from 1996 & 2000 the number of RNs grew 5.4% to 2,696,540 In the 4 years from 1992 to 1996 that figure was 14.2% 3. The average salary of Registered Nurses is not growing at an alarming rate The “actual” average full time salary of RN’s in The Impending Crisis In Healthcare 2 of 5 2000 was $46,782 The “real” average salary of RN’s (based on 82-84 CPI) has remained flat since 1992 at $23,000 The bottom line is that not only are fewer nurses entering the profession, they are doing so later in life. A shrinking, aging, talent pool is a crisis waiting to happen if you don’t manage your workforce effectively. In addition, “real” average salaries have not climbed (relative to consumer price index) since 1992 indicating that organizational loyalty is practically non-existent in this sector. Analysis of other “talent short” sectors explains this opinion – in the tech sector aggressive headhunting as a result of talent shortages has driven salary growth at an alarming rate. So why hasn’t this happened in the healthcare sector? It is ThinkShed’s opinion that employees are simply not “attached” enough to their current employers to make headhunting them difficult. I.e. whereas in the tech sector large salary premiums are used to attract talent from competitive organizations, in the healthcare sector it is merely the promise of a greener pasture that causes workers to make the move. Once again an indictment of existing human capital management practices in this sector. If you still think that all of this doesn’t really matter, that somehow these are soft issues that are not really connected to the corporate bottom line, think again! Studies by the DHHS clearly demonstrate the effect of RN staffing levels on both medical and surgical patient outcomes; for example, a shortage of RN staff has been found to impact patient “Length Of Stay” by up to 12%, and in surgical environments “Risk of Failure” by up to 14%. Put another way, every RN role that remains unfilled has a significant and traceable adverse impact on the bottom line. The point that we wish to make in all of this is that the current practice of simply trying to recruit more aggressively does not address the real issue. The real issue is that most healthcare organizations are the equivalent of a badly leaking bucket; pouring more water into them does not solve the root problem. To think otherwise is pure insanity.
Cite
APA
(2001). The Impending Crisis In Healthcare. The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration. https://doi.org/10.5580/1eb0
Vancouver
The Impending Crisis In Healthcare. The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration. 2001. doi:10.5580/1eb0
BibTeX
@article{euvimed2001,
title = {The Impending Crisis In Healthcare},
journal = {The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration},
year = {2001},
doi = {10.5580/1eb0}
}
EUVIMED