Editorial - Hospital Information Systems: Still a Long Way to Go!
The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration · 2000
DOI: 10.5580/137c ↗At a glance
Journal article in The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration, 2000.
Abstract (original language)
Hospital information systems form a cornerstone of modern hospital care. Developers of such mission-critical systems place special emphasis on maintaining the reliability of the system, as well on as avoiding misinformation that could result in patient harm and on avoiding ergonomic design flaws that make the system difficult or even dangerous to use. It is the latter aspects of clinical information system design about which I write. Specifically, I would like to share with this journal’s readership some observations about user interface design based on my experiences as a user of clinical information systems and computer-based medical devices over the last decade. PREVENTING BAD DATA ENTRY The main clinical information system at the hospital where I work, a system sometimes cynically described as “the best of 1970’s mainframe technology,” allows the user to enter entirely unreasonable patient parameters, such as a height of five inches with a weight of 200 kilograms, or even a heart rate of zero. When I complained to the appropriate hospital authorities about this, I was told that it was the user’s responsibility to ensure that the data was entered correctly, as the software could not easily be modified to put range checks on all entered data. A related problem is that the computer expects that entered patient weight be entered in kilograms, but frequently the patients tell the nurse their weight in pounds (they are not actually weighed in many cases), and this numeric value is then sometimes entered in the weight field without the necessary “LB” modifier. I suggested that a “weight-toheight” ratio might be used as a simple indicator of how reasonable the entered data was (with a user warning for strange ratios), but this suggestion was dismissed as being impractical given the awkward, outdated software technology that the programmers were forced to use, and given the many other demands made on their time as hospital budgets are cut to the bone. Perhaps this attitude would change if a 100 pound patient died from an 2.2 times overdose of a toxic drug based on an assumed weight of 100 kilograms. Could it happen? Of course, especially if one were busy and did not actually cast eyes on the patient to note the obvious discrepancy between the weight entered in the patient’s chart and one’s visual impression. Indeed, several years ago (at another hospital) a patient died when a miscalculation resulted in the administration of a lethal dose of a toxic anti-cancer drug. The newspaper account noted that the software involved had been subsequently modified to disallow any dosages above a particular ceiling. SELECTION MENU DESIGN ISSUES One complaint voiced to me by my colleagues was that the system user menu presented to them varied depending on what part of the hospital they were working in. For example, the menu selection presented when they log onto the system is not the same in the Intensive Care Unit as it is in the Recovery Room. The intent is apparently to have a menu optimized for the clinical needs of each area, but, of course, this necessitates that the clinician to be familiar with more than one user interface, obviously not ideal from an ergonomic viewpoint. A better concept might be for each clinician to have a single interface tuned (optimized) to that clinician’s particular practice, thereby standardizing the excursion route through a complex menu structure. Editorial Hospital Information Systems: Still a Long Way to Go! 2 of 4 EXAMPLE: ORDERING X-RAYS Although one of the alleged advantages of a computer-based physician order system is to reduce physician workload, it soon became apparent with our system that this is not always the case. For example, after heart surgery, patients are admitted to our Intensive Care Unit (ICU), where the clinical routine often requires a daily chest X-ray for three successive days. For years, getting this done was as simple as writing the following order on the patient’s ICU order sheet: “Portable CXR daily x 3”. When we first switched to the computer-based order system this simple order for a while required the physician to enter something akin to following FOR EACH X-ray required: select “laboratory tests menu” select “radiological investigations menu” select “portable chest X-ray”
Cite
APA
(2000). Editorial - Hospital Information Systems: Still a Long Way to Go!. The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration. https://doi.org/10.5580/137c
Vancouver
Editorial - Hospital Information Systems: Still a Long Way to Go!. The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration. 2000. doi:10.5580/137c
BibTeX
@article{euvimed2000,
title = {Editorial - Hospital Information Systems: Still a Long Way to Go!},
journal = {The Internet Journal of Healthcare Administration},
year = {2000},
doi = {10.5580/137c}
}
EUVIMED