The Shadow Phenomenon of Intangible Heritage Selection: From the Cultural Property Regime to the K-Culture Industrialization Regime
The Korean Society of Human and Nature · 30.07.2026 · 7 (2) · 161-188
DOI: 10.54913/hn.2026.7.2.161 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Korean Society of Human and Nature, online erschienen am 30.07.2026. Verfasst von Seoksoon Kim.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This paper examines, through the concept of the “shadow phenomenon,” how the state’s act of selecting intangible heritage renders the unselected invisible. It takes as its starting point what may be called the “paradox of designation” - the phenomenon, long noted in intangible heritage studies, whereby the designation of particular items or holders for the purpose of protection ironically marginalizes undesignated heritage of the same kind and hastens its disappearance - and extends the discussion in two directions. First, rather than confining the paradox of designation to a side effect internal to the intangible heritage legal framework, it generalizes the paradox into a structural property inherent in the act of selection as such, an act that concentrates finite resources and legitimacy upon particular objects. Second, it attends to how state intervention in intangible heritage has been shifting its center of gravity from the cultural property preservation regime to the K-culture industrialization regime. The paper sets the shadow phenomenon as a structural tendency that recurs across historical eras, and the criteria of selection as a variable that changes over time. Whereas past preservation-based selection, taking historicity and typicality as its criteria, worked to strip away the commercial character of its objects, today’s industry-based selection, taking marketability and utility as its criteria, works to attach commercial character. This is not a mere addition of selection criteria but a reversal in the very direction in which commerciality is handled, and the two modes of selection do not stand in a relation of replacement but coexist in layered fashion. Moreover, while preservation-based selection is closer to a sole act of the state, industry-based selection operates as a field in which state policy and the market are interlocked, and the two thus differ in their agents as well. Within this analytical framework, the paper examines three configurations formed by the intersection of preservation-based and industry-based selection. These are Haman Nakhwa-nori, which passed both modes of selection, with the legitimacy conferred by preservation redeployed as grounds for industrial evaluation; jeongga and samulnori, each selected by only one side; and undesignated village pungmul, selected by neither. In particular, the contrast between jeongga - which, despite holding national designation and UNESCO inscription, is commercially neglected and classified as an endangered transmission item - and samulnori - which, though left in the shadow of preservation, has established itself in the industrial domain - shows that passing one mode of selection neither guarantees nor precludes selection by the other, and that the light of one cannot fill the shadow of the other. The invisibility of intangible heritage is not a failure that can be eliminated by refining policy, but a structural product attendant upon the act of selection itself. Changing the criteria does not remove the shadow; it reconfigures the location and the depth of the shadow. The task of policy, therefore, lies not in eliminating the shadow but in consciously choosing which items will be left within it.
Zitieren
APA
Kim, S. (2026). The Shadow Phenomenon of Intangible Heritage Selection: From the Cultural Property Regime to the K-Culture Industrialization Regime. The Korean Society of Human and Nature, 7(2), 161-188. https://doi.org/10.54913/hn.2026.7.2.161
Vancouver
Kim S. The Shadow Phenomenon of Intangible Heritage Selection: From the Cultural Property Regime to the K-Culture Industrialization Regime. The Korean Society of Human and Nature. 2026;7(2):161-188. doi:10.54913/hn.2026.7.2.161
BibTeX
@article{Kim2026,
author = {Kim, Seoksoon},
title = {The Shadow Phenomenon of Intangible Heritage Selection: From the Cultural Property Regime to the K-Culture Industrialization Regime},
journal = {The Korean Society of Human and Nature},
year = {2026},
volume = {7},
number = {2},
pages = {161--188},
doi = {10.54913/hn.2026.7.2.161}
}
EUVIMED