Editorial Comment: Transcatheter Closure of Patent Ductus Arteriosus in Infants: Interpreting High Procedural Success and Its Implications for Pediatric Cardiology in Pakistan
Pakistan Heart Journal · 31.10.2026 · 59 (5) · 1645-1648
DOI: 10.47144/phj.v59i5.4020 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Pakistan Heart Journal, online erschienen am 31.10.2026. Verfasst von Abdul Razzaq Mughal und 2 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The management of patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) has undergone considerable advancement over recent decades, reflecting improvements in diagnostic imaging, catheter-based interventions, device technology, and perioperative care. Contemporary clinical decision-making extends beyond identifying ductal patency to determining its hemodynamic significance, evaluating the anticipated benefits of intervention, and selecting the safest and most effective closure strategy. Transcatheter PDA closure has emerged as an important alternative to surgical ligation in appropriately selected patients, with expanding applications in infants of increasingly lower body weights [1–3]. Nevertheless, successful intervention requires careful consideration of ductal anatomy, patient characteristics, procedural expertise, and potential complications. The retrospective study by Riaz et al. [4], published in the current issue of the Pakistan Heart Journal, provides valuable evidence regarding the feasibility and early outcomes of transcatheter PDA closure in infants within a Pakistani tertiary-care setting. Over the study period, 247 infants underwent evaluation, of whom 239 proceeded to attempted transcatheter closure. Successful device implantation was achieved in 238 patients, corresponding to a procedural success rate of 99.6% among attempted interventions. Only one major complication, device embolization, was documented and successfully managed through percutaneous retrieval. Five additional patients experienced minor complications, while no procedure-related mortality or clinically significant left pulmonary artery or descending aortic obstruction was identified before discharge. These findings are encouraging and highlight the potential for favorable procedural outcomes when interventions are performed in experienced centers with appropriate patient selection and multidisciplinary support. The reported success rate compares favorably with published international experiences, although differences in patient characteristics and procedural complexity warrant careful interpretation. Backes et al. [5], analyzing data from the National Cardiovascular Data Registry IMPACT Registry, reported a procedural success rate of 94.3% among 747 infants weighing less than 6 kg. However, this population included substantially smaller and younger infants than those represented in the present study. Similarly, earlier multicenter investigations demonstrated the feasibility of transcatheter PDA closure in infants weighing 6 kg or less, while emphasizing the importance of patient selection and procedural expertise [6]. Consequently, the exceptionally high success rate reported by Riaz et al. should be interpreted in the context of the study population rather than as evidence of superior effectiveness across all infant age and weight categories. An important contribution of this study is its demonstration of individualized device selection according to ductal morphology and anatomical characteristics. Conventional PDA occluders were employed in most procedures, whereas ventricular septal defect occluders were utilized in selected patients with larger or atypical ductal configurations. Such procedural adaptability is particularly relevant in pediatric interventional cardiology, where anatomical variability can influence device stability, residual shunting, and the risk of obstruction involving adjacent vascular structures. Device selection should therefore incorporate ductal diameter, length, configuration, patient body weight, and the anatomical relationship between the ductus, descending aorta, and left pulmonary artery [7]. The findings reinforce the importance of anatomy-guided intervention rather than reliance on a uniform device strategy. The vascular access strategy adopted in this cohort also deserves attention. A venous-only approach was employed in 61.9% of procedures, suggesting the feasibility of minimizing arterial instrumentation in selected infants. Avoidance of femoral arterial access may reduce exposure to access-related vascular complications, which are particularly concerning in smaller patients because of limited vessel caliber. Previous investigations have demonstrated the feasibility and effectiveness of venous-only transcatheter PDA closure, although procedural suitability depends on ductal anatomy, imaging capabilities, device characteristics, and operator experience [8,9]. Accordingly, venous-only access should be considered an individualized procedural option rather than a universally preferable technique. Importantly, the present retrospective findings do not establish comparative superiority over conventional arteriovenous approaches. Despite the favorable procedural outcomes, the occurrence of device embolization highlights the need for continued vigilance regarding potentially serious complications. Although successfully managed through percutaneous retrieval in the present series, device embolization may necessitate urgent intervention and can result in substantial clinical consequences if not promptly recognized. The availability of appropriate retrieval equipment, immediate echocardiographic and fluoroscopic assessment, experienced interventional personnel, and surgical backup remains essential for safe procedural practice. International evidence similarly emphasizes that technical success must be evaluated alongside procedural complications and institutional preparedness [5,7]. An additional consideration concerns the generalizability of these findings. The study population had a mean age of 11.0 months and mean body weight of 7.8 kg, indicating that the findings predominantly reflect outcomes among relatively larger infants. They should not be extrapolated directly to premature neonates, extremely low-birth-weight infants, or patients with substantially different hemodynamic and anatomical characteristics. Although advances in transcatheter techniques have expanded treatment options for smaller infants, procedural risks and technical requirements vary according to body weight, ductal morphology, pulmonary vascular physiology, and institutional experience [5,7]. Future investigations should therefore incorporate stratified analyses according to age, weight, ductal anatomy, and clinical risk to identify patient groups most likely to benefit from specific closure strategies. The retrospective, single-center design introduces additional limitations that warrant consideration. The study period extending from 2014 to 2025 encompasses substantial developments in interventional technology, imaging modalities, device availability, and operator experience. These temporal changes may have influenced procedural selection and outcomes. Furthermore, the exclusion of eight evaluated infants from attempted device closure underscores the importance of distinguishing procedural success among selected candidates from the broader feasibility of transcatheter intervention among all infants assessed. The absence of a comparative surgical or alternative-treatment group also prevents conclusions regarding relative safety, effectiveness, or resource utilization. Another significant limitation is the emphasis on immediate and early postprocedural outcomes. Although the absence of clinically significant vascular obstruction and other major complications before discharge is reassuring, these observations cannot establish long-term device safety or durability. Potential late complications, including residual shunting, progressive vascular obstruction, device-related infection, and the need for reintervention, require systematic longitudinal evaluation. Prospective follow-up incorporating standardized echocardiographic assessment and clinically meaningful outcomes would strengthen the evidence regarding sustained procedural effectiveness. From a broader healthcare perspective, this study demonstrates the capacity of specialized pediatric cardiac centers in Pakistan to achieve favorable outcomes in selected patients undergoing catheter-based congenital heart interventions. However, successful implementation depends on more than the availability of occlusion devices. It requires coordinated expertise in pediatric cardiology, echocardiography, anesthesia, catheterization laboratory services, postoperative monitoring, and emergency complication management. The development and maintenance of such multidisciplinary infrastructure are particularly important in healthcare systems where access to specialized pediatric cardiac services may be uneven. The findings also provide a compelling rationale for establishing collaborative national or regional registries of congenital cardiac interventions. Standardized multicenter data collection would facilitate evaluation of procedural indications, patient characteristics, anatomical complexity, device selection, vascular access strategies, complications, resource utilization, and long-term outcomes. Such initiatives could also support quality improvement, identify institutional training needs, and generate evidence relevant to the healthcare priorities and resource constraints of Pakistan. Importantly, future research should extend beyond procedural success rates to examine patient-centered outcomes, healthcare accessibility, cost-effectiveness, and equity in access to specialized interventions. In conclusion, the study by Riaz et al. [4] represents a valuable contribution to the evolving evidence on transcatheter PDA closure in Pakistan. The reported 99.6% procedural success rate demonstrates excellent technical outcomes among carefully selected infants treated in an experienced center. Nevertheless, these findings should be interpreted alongside the retrospective design, patient selection, limited representation of smaller infants, and absence of comprehensive long-term follow-up. Transcatheter PDA closure remains an effective therapeutic option for appropriately selected infants with hemodynamically significant PDA when performed by skilled congenital cardiac intervention teams. The next priority should be to translate these encouraging institutional outcomes into broader improvements in pediatric cardiac care through standardized clinical practices, collaborative research, multicenter registries, and prospective long-term surveillance. References Backes CH, Hill KD, Shelton EL, Slaughter JL, Lewis TR, Weisz DE, et al. Patent ductus arteriosus: a contemporary perspective for the pediatric and adult cardiac care provider. J Am Heart Assoc. 2022;11(17):e025784. DOI: 10.1161/JAHA.122.025784 Köstekci YE, Erdeve Ö. Patent ductus arteriosus (PDA): recent recommendations for to close or not to close. Global Pediatr. 2024;7:100128. DOI: 10.1016/j.gpeds.2023.100128 Honnorat M, Perouse-De-Montclos T, Bakloul M, Walton C, Butin M, Vo Van P. Transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus in preterm infants: results from a single-center cohort. Front Pediatr. 2023;11:1292623. DOI: 10.3389/fped.2023.1292623 Riaz Q, Sheikh AM, Kanwal A, Azim K, Ali MA, Fayyaz F. Transcatheter closure of patent ductus arteriosus in infants: a retrospective single-center study of procedural feasibility, success, and early outcomes. Pak Heart J. 2026;59(5):1636-1644. DOI: 10.47144/phj.v59i5.3364 Backes CH, Kennedy KF, Locke M, Cua CL, Ball MK, Fick TA, et al. Transcatheter occlusion of the patent ductus arteriosus in 747 infants
Zitieren
APA
Mughal, A. R., Javed, M., & Shaikh, A. S. (2026). Editorial Comment: Transcatheter Closure of Patent Ductus Arteriosus in Infants: Interpreting High Procedural Success and Its Implications for Pediatric Cardiology in Pakistan. Pakistan Heart Journal, 59(5), 1645-1648. https://doi.org/10.47144/phj.v59i5.4020
Vancouver
Mughal AR, Javed M, Shaikh AS. Editorial Comment: Transcatheter Closure of Patent Ductus Arteriosus in Infants: Interpreting High Procedural Success and Its Implications for Pediatric Cardiology in Pakistan. Pakistan Heart Journal. 2026;59(5):1645-1648. doi:10.47144/phj.v59i5.4020
BibTeX
@article{Mughal2026,
author = {Mughal, Abdul Razzaq and Javed, Motia and Shaikh, Abdul Sattar},
title = {Editorial Comment: Transcatheter Closure of Patent Ductus Arteriosus in Infants: Interpreting High Procedural Success and Its Implications for Pediatric Cardiology in Pakistan},
journal = {Pakistan Heart Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {59},
number = {5},
pages = {1645--1648},
doi = {10.47144/phj.v59i5.4020}
}
EUVIMED