Announcements of Capitalism and Their Reception in Eighteenth-Century Europe: The Dispute Between Diderot and Morellet in 1770-71
Canadian Journal of History · 1998-12 · 33 (3) · 417-436
DOI: 10.3138/cjh.33.3.417 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Canadian Journal of History, 1998-12. Verfasst von Daniel M. Klang. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 1-mal zitiert (Crossref).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In the second half of the eighteenth century various Europeans began to write about the investment of capital in broad and dramatic terms, identifying it as a transforming force capable of making immense headway against poverty and scarcity. However, despite their powerful import, these “announcements of capitalism” were often ignored or misconstrued. In the dispute between Morellet and Diderot the former called for the bringing of capital and entrepreneurs to French agriculture while the latter, rather than rejecting the plea, simply circumvented it and went on to other issues. Morellet’s use of abstractions or ideal types to advance his economic ideas contrasted with Diderot’s insistence upon drawing insight only from a known landscape which happened to be short on capital and entrepreneurs. Likewise, when Morellet neglected to distinguish the entrepreneur from other kinds of European leasefarmers Diderot could suppose the argument won by pointing to operators who were too poor to produce much or who used their money to establish commercial monopolies. Nonetheless, we do not argue that Diderot failed to understand Morellet’s literary presentation of agrarian capitalism just because he had at his disposal no actual examples of it. Instead, we offer the instance of Austrian Lombardy where rich and productive leasefarmers dominated agriculture in the wet plains and where the accomplished student of political economy, Pietro Verri, residing practically next door to the great dairy farms of the Lodigiano, never managed to make sense of them, in particular refusing to see in the substitution of capital for labour anything other than a narrow pursuit of personal gain. In sum, if the Enlightenment invented the ideas of capitalism and the entrepreneur it also put up effective barriers to their reception.
Zitieren
APA
Klang, D. M. (1998). Announcements of Capitalism and Their Reception in Eighteenth-Century Europe: The Dispute Between Diderot and Morellet in 1770-71. Canadian Journal of History, 33(3), 417-436. https://doi.org/10.3138/cjh.33.3.417
Vancouver
Klang DM. Announcements of Capitalism and Their Reception in Eighteenth-Century Europe: The Dispute Between Diderot and Morellet in 1770-71. Canadian Journal of History. 1998;33(3):417-436. doi:10.3138/cjh.33.3.417
BibTeX
@article{Klang1998,
author = {Klang, Daniel M.},
title = {Announcements of Capitalism and Their Reception in Eighteenth-Century Europe: The Dispute Between Diderot and Morellet in 1770-71},
journal = {Canadian Journal of History},
year = {1998},
volume = {33},
number = {3},
pages = {417--436},
doi = {10.3138/cjh.33.3.417}
}
EUVIMED