EUVIMEDScopri EUVIMED
Open access · CC BY-NC 4.0

An AHP-Based Hierarchy of IT PMO Success Factors: Evidence from an Indonesian Bank

Agnes Bina Krisanty Simamora, Betty Purwandari, Teguh Raharjo

Interdisciplinary Journal of Information, Knowledge, and Management · 2026 · 21 · 24

DOI: 10.28945/5869 ↗

At a glance

Journal article in Interdisciplinary Journal of Information, Knowledge, and Management, 2026. Written by Agnes Bina Krisanty Simamora and 2 co-authors. The full text is freely available (open access, CC BY-NC 4.0).

AbstractDati bibliograficiCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

Aim/Purpose: This study prioritizes the success criteria and factors of an Information Technology Project Management Office (IT PMO) in an Indonesian bank undergoing digital transformation. It addresses the limited empirical understanding of how IT PMO success should be defined in regulated banking environments and develops an AHP-based hierarchy to support the shift of the IT PMO from an administrative unit to a strategic governance function.

Background

Banking digital transformation depends on IT projects that are not only delivered on time but also aligned with business strategy, regulatory demands, and stakeholder expectations. Although prior PMO and AHP studies have identified general project success factors, limited attention has been given to the specific success hierarchy of IT PMOs in banking institutions. In the case bank, the decline in on-time project completion and the administrative orientation of the IT PMO indicate the need for a more contextual and strategic evaluation framework. Methodology: A mixed-methods case study was conducted. Candidate criteria and factors were derived from literature and practitioner insights, refined via Likert-scale validation, and consolidated into five success criteria and seven IT PMO success factors. These elements were subsequently prioritized using AHP based on expert pairwise comparisons, with consistency verified through the Consistency Ratio. The resultant hierarchy informed the development of strategic recommendations to enhance IT PMO performance. Contribution: This study contributes by extending PMO and AHP research into a regulated banking context, where IT projects must balance delivery performance, compliance, strategic alignment, and digital transformation goals. Its novelty lies in the development of a contextual hierarchy of five IT PMO success criteria and seven success factors, offering both theoretical insight and practical guidance for repositioning the IT PMO as a strategic governance mechanism.

Findings

The findings show that project strategic alignment is the most influential success criterion, with a weight of 34%, followed by project implementation effectiveness at 27% and stakeholder and project beneficiary satisfaction at 22%. At the factor level, management and leadership support is dominant at 36%, followed by team capability and resource availability at 18%, and organizational structure and role clarity at 15%. These results indicate that IT PMO success in banking is driven primarily by strategic sponsorship, capable resources, and clear governance roles. Recommendations for Practitioners: Practically, banking organizations should strengthen the strategic position of the IT PMO by involving it in portfolio planning, project prioritization, and executive decision-making. They should also invest in the IT PMO team’s capabilities, improve resource allocation, and clarify governance roles so that the IT PMO can support project delivery and business alignment more effectively. Recommendation for Researchers: Future studies can test the proposed hierarchy in other banking institutions, financial technology firms, or regulated industries to assess its transferability. Researchers may also compare AHP with other multi-criteria decision-making methods to examine whether different approaches produce similar priority structures. Impact on Society: A stronger IT PMO can improve the reliability, speed, and governance of banking IT projects. This may support more stable, secure, and inclusive digital banking services for customers and society. Future Research: Future research should apply multiple case studies, include broader stakeholder groups, and examine the relationship between IT PMO success factors and measurable project outcomes over time.

Cite

APA

Simamora, A. B. K., Purwandari, B., & Raharjo, T. (2026). An AHP-Based Hierarchy of IT PMO Success Factors: Evidence from an Indonesian Bank. Interdisciplinary Journal of Information, Knowledge, and Management, 21, 24. https://doi.org/10.28945/5869

Vancouver

Simamora ABK, Purwandari B, Raharjo T. An AHP-Based Hierarchy of IT PMO Success Factors: Evidence from an Indonesian Bank. Interdisciplinary Journal of Information, Knowledge, and Management. 2026;21:24. doi:10.28945/5869

BibTeX
@article{Simamora2026,
  author = {Simamora, Agnes Bina Krisanty and Purwandari, Betty and Raharjo, Teguh},
  title = {An AHP-Based Hierarchy of IT PMO Success Factors: Evidence from an Indonesian Bank},
  journal = {Interdisciplinary Journal of Information, Knowledge, and Management},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {21},
  pages = {24},
  doi = {10.28945/5869}
}
Start for free →