“All My Sons”: A Play By Arthur Miller and Henrik Ibsen
The Arthur Miller Journal · 2013
DOI: 10.2307/42909100 ↗At a glance
Journal article in The Arthur Miller Journal, 2013. Written by Kurt Taroff. Cited 2 times so far (Crossref); 12 references.
Abstract (original language)
In seeking sources and influences for the work of Arthur Miller, Henrik Ibsen has always been seen as a clear progenitor. Ibsen's influence may arguably be seen in Miller in ways both great and small-from overarching notions of dramatic structure and the very purpose of drama itself to individual characters and plot devices in specific plays. This essay will briefly examine Ibsen's overall influence on Miller, before turning to examine the specific and manifest influence of two of Ibsen's plays-The Pillars of Society and The Wild Duck-on Miller's first Broadway hit, All My Sons.Ibsen's influence on Miller began at a rather early point in Miller's career. From Professor Kenneth Rowe Thorpe, Miller's playwriting professor at the University of Michigan, Miller learned two significant concepts based on Ibsen's methods-that the writing of a play should begin with the writing of a scenario, and "the problem-complication-crisis formula for dramatic construction" (Gottfried 34). Stephen Barker has seen Ibsen as an idol for Miller, arguing that "Miller's great mentor for the critical analysis of existence was, of course, Ibsen" (232), and further, that "Miller has always emulated Ibsen, desiring to be successful at the level of theatrical presentation and dramatic/symbolic content" (242). Critics, and Miller himself, have noted that at the root of Ibsen's influence was the late point-of-attack structure, resulting in the past being brought to light over the course of the drama. For Miller, this resulted in a playwriting style with exceptional economy, and one in which the way events occurred was just as significant as what happened: "I connected with Ibsen not because he wrote about problems, but because he was illuminating process. Nothing in his plays exists for itself, not a smart line, not a gesture that can be isolated. It was breath-taking" (Miller 1958, 180).The one unarguable site of direct influence from Ibsen is Miller's 1950 adaptation of An Enemy of the People. Perhaps ironically here, Miller was criticized by some for his deviation from Ibsen, with the suggestion being that in softening the contours of Doctor Stockmann, he eschewed some of the Norwegian's insistence upon a balanced and ambiguous conflict. Nevertheless, while the initial impetus for the adaptation may have been the prodding of director Robert Lewis and the actors Frederic March and Florence Eldridge (Abbotson 152), Miller asserted that the purpose behind the work was to encourage a reassessment of Ibsen in American eyes: "I had a private wish to demonstrate that Ibsen is really pertinent today, that he is not 'oldfashioned,' and, implicitly, that those who condemn him are themselves misleading our theater and our playwrights" (Miller 1951, 17). Miller insisted that while he did seek to ensure that the play would speak to contemporary American audiences, beneath any alterations he may have made "there still lives the terrible wrath of Henrik Ibsen, who could make a play as men make watches, precisely, intelligently, and telling not merely the minute and hour but the age" (Miller 1951, 21). That Miller would seek to hew closely to the original version written by his idol is hardly surprising. The more interesting question is the role that the Norwegian master may have played in those works by Miller that were not (named as) adaptations.The notion that Henrik Ibsen had a major and frequently specifically traceable influence on the work of Arthur Miller has only ever really had one significant objector: Arthur Miller. Miller, as we have noted, never denied an admiration for Ibsen's work, but challenged the extent to which that admiration translated into a direct presence into the former's work. In particular regard to All My Sons, Miller noted, first and foremost, a public and/or critical perception of the Norwegian master's influence on the play: "When All My Sons opened on Broadway, it was called an 'Ibsenesque' play. Some people liked it for this reason and others did not" (Miller 1957, 123). …
Cite
APA
Taroff, K. (2013). “All My Sons”: A Play By Arthur Miller and Henrik Ibsen. The Arthur Miller Journal. https://doi.org/10.2307/42909100
Vancouver
Taroff K. “All My Sons”: A Play By Arthur Miller and Henrik Ibsen. The Arthur Miller Journal. 2013. doi:10.2307/42909100
BibTeX
@article{Taroff2013,
author = {Taroff, Kurt},
title = {“All My Sons”: A Play By Arthur Miller and Henrik Ibsen},
journal = {The Arthur Miller Journal},
year = {2013},
doi = {10.2307/42909100}
}
EUVIMED