Challenges of Single-Reference Benchmarks for Clinical Reasoning in Large Language Model–Based Decision Support
Journal of Medical Internet Research · 2026-11-13 · 28 · e99019-e99019
DOI: 10.2196/99019 ↗At a glance
Journal article in Journal of Medical Internet Research, published online on 2026-11-13. Written by Jiawei Zhou and 7 co-authors. Institution: Cancer Hospital of Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Panjiayuan Nanli 17, Beijing, 100021, China, 86 0316-591-8787. Major MEDLINE topics: Benchmarking, Decision Support Systems, Clinical, Clinical Reasoning. 16 references. The full text is freely available in PubMed Central.
Abstract (original language)
This viewpoint addresses developers and evaluators of large language model (LLM)–based clinical decision support systems. Although recent benchmarks increasingly evaluate multiple clinical reasoning domains, many still rely substantially on reference decision agreement—whether model outputs conform to predefined decisions. Our aim is to clarify when such agreement remains useful, when it becomes insufficient for complex or preference-sensitive decisions, and how it can be complemented by reasoning-centered assessment. Clinical decision-making often depends on structured reasoning under uncertainty, integrating probabilistic evidence, contextual constraints, and patient values. Using oncology as an illustrative domain, we argue that some decision variability is a structural feature of clinical reasoning rather than noise or error. Used alone in such settings, single-reference benchmarks may conflate reasonable divergence with incorrectness and reward answer imitation over transparent reasoning. We conclude that reference decision agreement should be retained for tasks with stable ground truth but supplemented by evidence grounding, reasoning quality, patient-centeredness, and safety checks for open-ended clinical decision support. This multidimensional approach is intended to support safer and more clinically meaningful evaluation.
Subjects
MeSH terms (MEDLINE)
Author keywords
Authors and institutions
- Cancer Hospital of Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Panjiayuan Nanli 17, Beijing, 100021, China, 86 0316-591-8787.
- Baichuan Inc, Beijing, China.
Cite
APA
Zhou, J., He, H., Yu, W., Zhong, Z., Ju, Q., Wang, S., Wang, X., & Li, N. (2026). Challenges of Single-Reference Benchmarks for Clinical Reasoning in Large Language Model–Based Decision Support. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 28, e99019-e99019. https://doi.org/10.2196/99019
Vancouver
Zhou J, He H, Yu W, Zhong Z, Ju Q, Wang S, et al. Challenges of Single-Reference Benchmarks for Clinical Reasoning in Large Language Model–Based Decision Support. Journal of Medical Internet Research. 2026;28:e99019-e99019. doi:10.2196/99019
BibTeX
@article{Zhou2026,
author = {Zhou, Jiawei and He, Hanqing and Yu, Weijie and Zhong, Zihan and Ju, Qiang and Wang, Shuhang and Wang, Xiaochuan and Li, Ning},
title = {Challenges of Single-Reference Benchmarks for Clinical Reasoning in Large Language Model–Based Decision Support},
journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
year = {2026},
volume = {28},
pages = {e99019--e99019},
doi = {10.2196/99019}
}
EUVIMED