EUVIMEDSkopri EUVIMED
QuerschnittstudieOpen access

Evaluating Generative AI Psychotherapy Chatbots Used by Youth: Cross-Sectional Study

Kunmi Sobowale iD, Daniel Kevin Humphrey iD, Sophia Yingruo Zhao iD

JMIR Mental Health · 2025-12-10 · 12 · e79838-e79838

DOI: 10.2196/79838 ↗

At a glance

Querschnittstudie in JMIR Mental Health, published online on 2025-12-10. Written by Kunmi Sobowale and 2 co-authors. Institution: Department of Psychiatry and Biobehavioral Sciences, University of California, 760 Westwood Plaza, Suite 48-241, Los Angeles, CA, 90024, United State…. Major MEDLINE topics: Psychotherapy, Artificial Intelligence, Mental Disorders, Communication. Cited 40 times so far (Crossref); 87 references. The full text is freely available in PubMed Central.

AstrattSubjectsDettalji biblijografiċiCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

Background

Many youth rely on direct-to-consumer generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) chatbots for mental health support, yet the quality of the psychotherapeutic capabilities of these chatbots is understudied.

Objective

This study aimed to comprehensively evaluate and compare the quality of widely used GenAI chatbots with psychotherapeutic capabilities using the Conversational Agent for Psychotherapy Evaluation II (CAPE-II) framework.

Methods

In this cross-sectional study, trained raters used the CAPE-II framework to rate the quality of 5 chatbots from GenAI platforms widely used by youth. Trained raters role-played as youth using personas of youth with mental health challenges to prompt chatbots, facilitating conversations. Chatbot responses were generated from August to October 2024. The primary outcomes were rated scores in 9 sections. The proportion of high-quality ratings (binary rating of 1) across each section was compared between chatbots using Bonferroni-corrected chi-square tests.

Results

While GenAI chatbots were found to be accessible (104/120 high-quality ratings, 86.7%) and avoid harmful statements and misinformation (71/80, 89%), they performed poorly in their therapeutic approach (14/45, 31%) and their ability to monitor and assess risk (31/80, 39%). Privacy policies were difficult to understand, and information on chatbot model training and knowledge was unavailable, resulting in low scores. Bonferroni-corrected chi-square tests showed statistically significant differences in chatbot quality in the background, therapeutic approach, and monitoring and risk evaluation sections. Qualitatively, raters perceived most chatbots as having strong conversational abilities but found them plagued by various issues, including fabricated content and poor handling of crisis situations.

Conclusions

Direct-to-consumer GenAI chatbots are unsafe for the millions of youth who use them. While they demonstrate strengths in accessibility and conversational capabilities, they pose unacceptable risks through improper crisis handling and a lack of transparency regarding privacy and model training. Immediate reforms, including the use of standardized audits of quality, such as the CAPE-II framework, are needed. These findings provide actionable targets for platforms, regulators, and policymakers to protect youth seeking mental health support.

Subjects

MeSH terms (MEDLINE)

PsychotherapyArtificial IntelligenceMental DisordersCommunicationHumansCross-Sectional StudiesAdolescentMaleFemaleGenerative Artificial Intelligence

Author keywords

ChatGPTartificial intelligencechatbotsconversational agentdigital health: therapyevaluation frameworkgenerative AIlarge language modelspsychotherapypsychotherapy chatbots

Authors and institutions

  • Department of Psychiatry and Biobehavioral Sciences, University of California, 760 Westwood Plaza, Suite 48-241, Los Angeles, CA, 90024, United States, 1 310-794-7035, 1 925-281-3270.
  • Department of Psychology, College of Arts and Science, University of San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States.
  • University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, United States.

ORCID profiles: Kunmi Sobowale, Daniel Kevin Humphrey, Sophia Yingruo Zhao

Cite

APA

Sobowale, K., Humphrey, D. K., & Zhao, S. Y. (2025). Evaluating Generative AI Psychotherapy Chatbots Used by Youth: Cross-Sectional Study. JMIR Mental Health, 12, e79838-e79838. https://doi.org/10.2196/79838

Vancouver

Sobowale K, Humphrey DK, Zhao SY. Evaluating Generative AI Psychotherapy Chatbots Used by Youth: Cross-Sectional Study. JMIR Mental Health. 2025;12:e79838-e79838. doi:10.2196/79838

BibTeX
@article{Sobowale2025,
  author = {Sobowale, Kunmi and Humphrey, Daniel Kevin and Zhao, Sophia Yingruo},
  title = {Evaluating Generative AI Psychotherapy Chatbots Used by Youth: Cross-Sectional Study},
  journal = {JMIR Mental Health},
  year = {2025},
  volume = {12},
  pages = {e79838--e79838},
  doi = {10.2196/79838}
}
Start for free →