EUVIMEDOpdag EUVIMED
StudienprotokollOpen access

Effectiveness of The Umbrella Collaboration Versus Traditional Umbrella Reviews for Evidence Synthesis in Health Care: Protocol for a Validation Study

Beltran Carrillo iD, Marta Rubinos-Cuadrado iD, Jazmin Parellada-Martin iD, Alejandra Palacios-López iD, Beltran Carrillo-Rubinos iD, Fernando Canillas-Del Rey iD, Juan Jose Baztán-Cortes iD, Javier Gómez-Pavon iD

JMIR Research Protocols · 2025

DOI: 10.2196/67248 ↗

At a glance

Studienprotokoll in JMIR Research Protocols, 2025. Written by Beltran Carrillo and 7 co-authors. Institution: The Umbrella Collaboration, Madrid, Spain. Major MEDLINE topics: Delivery of Health Care, Evidence-Based Medicine, Review Literature as Topic. 27 references. The full text is freely available in PubMed Central.

AbstractSubjectsBibliografiske oplysningerCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

Background

The synthesis of evidence in health care is essential for informed decision-making and policy development. This study aims to validate The Umbrella Collaboration (TU), an innovative, semiautomatic tertiary evidence synthesis methodology, by comparing it with Traditional Umbrella Reviews (TUR), which are currently the gold standard.

Objective

This study aimed to evaluate whether TU, an artificial intelligence—assisted, software-driven system for tertiary evidence synthesis, can achieve comparable effectiveness to TURs, while offering a more timely, efficient, and comprehensive approach. In addition, as a secondary objective, the study aims to assess the accessibility and comprehensibility of TU’s outputs to ensure its usability and practical applicability for health care professionals.

Methods

This protocol outlines a comparative study divided into 2 main parts. The first part involves a quantitative comparison of results obtained using TU and TURs in geriatrics. We will evaluate the identification, size effect, direction, statistical significance, and certainty of outcomes, as well as the time and resources required for each methodology. Data for TURs will be sourced from Medline (via PubMed), while TU will use artificial intelligence—assisted informatics to replicate the research questions of the selected TURs. The second part of the study assesses the ease of use and comprehension of TU through an online survey directed at health professionals, using interactive features and detailed data access.

Results

Expected results include the assessment of concordance in identifying outcomes, the size effect, direction and significance of these outcomes, and the certainty of evidence. In addition, we will measure the operational efficiency of each methodology by evaluating the time taken to complete projects. User perceptions of the ease of use and comprehension of TU will be gathered through detailed surveys. The implementation of new methodologies in evidence synthesis requires validation. This study will determine whether TU can match the accuracy and comprehensiveness of TURs while offering benefits in terms of efficiency and user accessibility. The comparative study is designed to address the inherent challenges in validating a new methodology against established standards.

Conclusions

If TU proves as effective as TURs but more time-efficient, accessible, and easily updatable, it could significantly enhance the process of evidence synthesis, facilitating informed decision-making and improving health care. This study represents a step toward integrating innovative technologies into routine evidence synthesis practice, potentially transforming health research. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID) PRR1-10.2196/67248

Subjects

MeSH terms (MEDLINE)

Delivery of Health CareEvidence-Based MedicineReview Literature as TopicHumansArtificial IntelligenceSystematic Reviews as TopicResearch DesignValidation Studies as Topic

Author keywords

AIAI-assistedAI-assisted synthesisMLThe Umbrella Collaborationalgorithmsanalyticsartificial intelligencedigital healthdigital interventionsdigital technologyevidence-based decision makinghealth research methodologymachine learningmodels

Authors and institutions

  • The Umbrella Collaboration, Madrid, Spain.
  • Hospital Universitario Cruz Roja, Madrid, Spain.
  • Universidad Alfonso X el Sabio, Villanueva de la Cañada, Madrid, Spain.

ORCID profiles: Beltran Carrillo, Marta Rubinos-Cuadrado, Jazmin Parellada-Martin, Alejandra Palacios-López, Beltran Carrillo-Rubinos, Fernando Canillas-Del Rey, Juan Jose Baztán-Cortes, Javier Gómez-Pavon

Cite

APA

Carrillo, B., Rubinos-Cuadrado, M., Parellada-Martin, J., Palacios-López, A., Carrillo-Rubinos, B., Canillas-Del Rey, F., Baztán-Cortes, J. J., & Gómez-Pavon, J. (2025). Effectiveness of The Umbrella Collaboration Versus Traditional Umbrella Reviews for Evidence Synthesis in Health Care: Protocol for a Validation Study. JMIR Research Protocols. https://doi.org/10.2196/67248

Vancouver

Carrillo B, Rubinos-Cuadrado M, Parellada-Martin J, Palacios-López A, Carrillo-Rubinos B, Canillas-Del Rey F, et al. Effectiveness of The Umbrella Collaboration Versus Traditional Umbrella Reviews for Evidence Synthesis in Health Care: Protocol for a Validation Study. JMIR Research Protocols. 2025. doi:10.2196/67248

BibTeX
@article{Carrillo2025,
  author = {Carrillo, Beltran and Rubinos-Cuadrado, Marta and Parellada-Martin, Jazmin and Palacios-López, Alejandra and Carrillo-Rubinos, Beltran and Canillas-Del Rey, Fernando and Baztán-Cortes, Juan Jose and Gómez-Pavon, Javier},
  title = {Effectiveness of The Umbrella Collaboration Versus Traditional Umbrella Reviews for Evidence Synthesis in Health Care: Protocol for a Validation Study},
  journal = {JMIR Research Protocols},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.2196/67248}
}
Start for free →