EUVIMEDDécouvrir EUVIMED
Systematische ÜbersichtOpen access

Assessing the Impact of Evidence-Based Mental Health Guidance During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Systematic Review and Qualitative Evaluation

Katharine A Smith iD, Edoardo G Ostinelli iD, Roger Ede iD, Lisa Allard iD, Michaela Thomson iD, Kiran Hewitt iD, Petra Brown iD, Caroline Zangani iD, Matthew Jenkins iD, Verena Hinze iD, George Ma iD, Prajnesh Pothulu iD and 4 more

JMIR Mental Health · 2023

DOI: 10.2196/52901 ↗

At a glance

Systematische Übersicht in JMIR Mental Health, 2023. Written by Katharine A Smith and 15 co-authors. Institution: Department of Psychiatry, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom. Major MEDLINE topics: COVID-19, Psychiatry, Telemedicine. Cited 4 times so far (Crossref); 94 references. The full text is freely available in PubMed Central. Funded by: Wellcome Trust, Department of Health.

RésuméSubjectsRéférences bibliographiquesCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

Background

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Oxford Precision Psychiatry Lab (OxPPL) developed open-access web-based summaries of mental health care guidelines (OxPPL guidance) in key areas such as digital approaches and telepsychiatry, suicide and self-harm, domestic violence and abuse, perinatal care, and vaccine hesitancy and prioritization in the context of mental illness, to inform timely clinical decision-making.

Objective

This study aimed to evaluate the practice of creating evidence-based health guidelines during health emergencies using the OxPPL guidance as an example. An international network of clinical sites and colleagues (in Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom) including clinicians, researchers, and experts by experience aimed to (1) evaluate the clinical impact of the OxPPL guidance, as an example of an evidence-based summary of guidelines; (2) review the literature for other evidence-based summaries of COVID-19 guidelines regarding mental health care; and (3) produce a framework for response to future global health emergencies.

Methods

The impact and clinical utility of the OxPPL guidance were assessed using clinicians’ feedback via an international survey and focus groups. A systematic review (protocol registered on Open Science Framework) identified summaries or syntheses of guidelines for mental health care during and after the COVID-19 pandemic and assessed the accuracy of the methods used in the OxPPL guidance by identifying any resources that the guidance had not included.

Results

Overall, 80.2% (146/182) of the clinicians agreed or strongly agreed that the OxPPL guidance answered important clinical questions, 73.1% (133/182) stated that the guidance was relevant to their service, 59.3% (108/182) said that the guidelines had or would have a positive impact on their clinical practice, 42.9% (78/182) that they had shared or would share the guidance, and 80.2% (146/182) stated that the methodology could be used during future health crises. The focus groups found that the combination of evidence-based knowledge, clinical viewpoint, and visibility was crucial for clinical implementation. The systematic review identified 2543 records, of which 2 syntheses of guidelines met all the inclusion criteria, but only 1 (the OxPPL guidance) used evidence-based methodology. The review showed that the OxPPL guidance had included the majority of eligible guidelines, but 6 were identified that had not been included.

Conclusions

The study identified an unmet need for web-based, evidence-based mental health care guidance during the COVID-19 pandemic. The OxPPL guidance was evaluated by clinicians as having a real-world clinical impact. Robust evidence-based methodology and expertise in mental health are necessary, but easy accessibility is also needed, and digital technology can materially help. Further health emergencies are inevitable and now is the ideal time to prepare, including addressing the training needs of clinicians, patients, and carers, especially in areas such as telepsychiatry and digital mental health. For future planning, guidance should be widely disseminated on an international platform, with allocated resources to support adaptive updates.

Subjects

MeSH terms (MEDLINE)

COVID-19PsychiatryTelemedicineHumansMental HealthPandemicsEmergencies

Author keywords

COVID-19digital healtheHealthevidence synthesisfocus groupguidelinesmental healthmobile phonepandemicsurveysystematic review

Authors and institutions

  • Department of Psychiatry, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom.
  • Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust, Oxford, United Kingdom.
  • Oxford Precision Psychiatry Lab, NIHR Oxford Health Biomedical Research Centre, Oxford, United Kingdom.
  • Pharmacy Department, Royal Brisbane and Women's Hospital, Brisbane, Australia.
  • Mersey Care NHS Foundation Trust, Liverpool, United Kingdom.
  • Lincolnshire Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, Lincoln, United Kingdom.

ORCID profiles: Katharine A Smith, Edoardo G Ostinelli, Roger Ede, Lisa Allard, Michaela Thomson, Kiran Hewitt, Petra Brown, Caroline Zangani, Matthew Jenkins, Verena Hinze, George Ma, Prajnesh Pothulu, Catherine Henshall, Gin S Malhi, Susanna Every-Palmer, Andrea Cipriani

Funding

  • Wellcome Trust
  • Department of Health

Cite

APA

Smith, K. A., Ostinelli, E. G., Ede, R., Allard, L., Thomson, M., Hewitt, K., Brown, P., Zangani, C., Jenkins, M., Hinze, V., Ma, G., Pothulu, P., Henshall, C., Malhi, G. S., Every-Palmer, S., & Cipriani, A. (2023). Assessing the Impact of Evidence-Based Mental Health Guidance During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Systematic Review and Qualitative Evaluation. JMIR Mental Health. https://doi.org/10.2196/52901

Vancouver

Smith KA, Ostinelli EG, Ede R, Allard L, Thomson M, Hewitt K, et al. Assessing the Impact of Evidence-Based Mental Health Guidance During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Systematic Review and Qualitative Evaluation. JMIR Mental Health. 2023. doi:10.2196/52901

BibTeX
@article{Smith2023,
  author = {Smith, Katharine A and Ostinelli, Edoardo G and Ede, Roger and Allard, Lisa and Thomson, Michaela and Hewitt, Kiran and Brown, Petra and Zangani, Caroline and Jenkins, Matthew and Hinze, Verena and Ma, George and Pothulu, Prajnesh and Henshall, Catherine and Malhi, Gin S and Every-Palmer, Susanna and Cipriani, Andrea},
  title = {Assessing the Impact of Evidence-Based Mental Health Guidance During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Systematic Review and Qualitative Evaluation},
  journal = {JMIR Mental Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2196/52901}
}
Start for free →