Immersive Virtual Reality–Based Methods for Assessing Executive Functioning: Systematic Review
JMIR Serious Games · 2024-02-26 · 12 · e50282
DOI: 10.2196/50282 ↗At a glance
Übersichtsarbeit in JMIR Serious Games, published online on 2024-02-26. Written by Rebecca Kirkham and 5 co-authors. Institution: Turner Institute for Brain and Mental Health, School of Psychological Sciences and Monash Biomedical Imaging Facility, Monash University, Clayton, Au…. Cited 42 times so far (Crossref); 105 references. The full text is freely available in PubMed Central.
Abstract (original language)
Background
Neuropsychological assessments traditionally include tests of executive functioning (EF) because of its critical role in daily activities and link to mental disorders. Established traditional EF assessments, although robust, lack ecological validity and are limited to single cognitive processes. These methods, which are suitable for clinical populations, are less informative regarding EF in healthy individuals. With these limitations in mind, immersive virtual reality (VR)–based assessments of EF have garnered interest because of their potential to increase test sensitivity, ecological validity, and neuropsychological assessment accessibility.
Objective
This systematic review aims to explore the literature on immersive VR assessments of EF focusing on (1) EF components being assessed, (2) how these assessments are validated, and (3) strategies for monitoring potential adverse (cybersickness) and beneficial (immersion) effects.
Methods
EBSCOhost, Scopus, and Web of Science were searched in July 2022 using keywords that reflected the main themes of VR, neuropsychological tests, and EF. Articles had to be peer-reviewed manuscripts written in English and published after 2013 that detailed empirical, clinical, or proof-of-concept studies in which a virtual environment using a head-mounted display was used to assess EF in an adult population. A tabular synthesis method was used in which validation details from each study, including comparative assessments and scores, were systematically organized in a table. The results were summed and qualitatively analyzed to provide a comprehensive overview of the findings.
Results
The search retrieved 555 unique articles, of which 19 (3.4%) met the inclusion criteria. The reviewed studies encompassed EF and associated higher-order cognitive functions such as inhibitory control, cognitive flexibility, working memory, planning, and attention. VR assessments commonly underwent validation against gold-standard traditional tasks. However, discrepancies were observed, with some studies lacking reported a priori planned correlations, omitting detailed descriptions of the EF constructs evaluated using the VR paradigms, and frequently reporting incomplete results. Notably, only 4 of the 19 (21%) studies evaluated cybersickness, and 5 of the 19 (26%) studies included user experience assessments.
Conclusions
Although it acknowledges the potential of VR paradigms for assessing EF, the evidence has limitations. The methodological and psychometric properties of the included studies were inconsistently addressed, raising concerns about their validity and reliability. Infrequent monitoring of adverse effects such as cybersickness and considerable variability in sample sizes may limit interpretation and hinder psychometric evaluation. Several recommendations are proposed to improve the theory and practice of immersive VR assessments of EF. Future studies should explore the integration of biosensors with VR systems and the capabilities of VR in the context of spatial navigation assessments. Despite considerable promise, the systematic and validated implementation of VR assessments is essential for ensuring their practical utility in real-world applications.
Subjects
Author keywords
Authors and institutions
- Turner Institute for Brain and Mental Health, School of Psychological Sciences and Monash Biomedical Imaging Facility, Monash University, Clayton, Australia.
- Institute for Intelligent Systems Research and Innovation, Deakin University, Geelong, Australia.
- Queensland Institute of Medical Research Berghofer Medical Research Institute, Herston, Australia.
- Department of Psychiatry, School of Clinical Sciences, Monash University, Clayton, Australia.
- Monash Business School, Monash University, Caufield, Australia.
ORCID profiles: Rebecca Kirkham, Lars Kooijman, Lucy Albertella, Dan Myles, Murat Yücel, Kristian Rotaru
Cite
APA
Kirkham, R., Kooijman, L., Albertella, L., Myles, D., Yücel, M., & Rotaru, K. (2024). Immersive Virtual Reality–Based Methods for Assessing Executive Functioning: Systematic Review. JMIR Serious Games, 12, e50282. https://doi.org/10.2196/50282
Vancouver
Kirkham R, Kooijman L, Albertella L, Myles D, Yücel M, Rotaru K. Immersive Virtual Reality–Based Methods for Assessing Executive Functioning: Systematic Review. JMIR Serious Games. 2024;12:e50282. doi:10.2196/50282
BibTeX
@article{Kirkham2024,
author = {Kirkham, Rebecca and Kooijman, Lars and Albertella, Lucy and Myles, Dan and Yücel, Murat and Rotaru, Kristian},
title = {Immersive Virtual Reality–Based Methods for Assessing Executive Functioning: Systematic Review},
journal = {JMIR Serious Games},
year = {2024},
volume = {12},
pages = {e50282},
doi = {10.2196/50282}
}
EUVIMED