Establishing J. von Neumann’s result of the incompatibility between hidden variables and quantum mechanics
Academia Quantum · 2025
DOI: 10.20935/acadquant7657 ↗At a glance
Journal article in Academia Quantum, 2025. Written by C. S. Unnikrishnan. Cited 1 times so far (Crossref); 29 references.
Abstract (original language)
The impossibility of making quantum mechanics deterministic by adding ‘hidden variables’ was discussed by J. von Neumann in 1932. His proof of the impossibility of dispersion-free ensembles was criticized as being logically circular, by Grete Hermann soon after, and as fundamentally flawed, by John Bell in 1964. Bell’s severe criticism and an explicit counter-example are generally considered as the definitive demonstration that J. von Neumann’s proof is inadequate. I show, without using the formalism of quantum mechanics, that J. von Neumann’s central assumption of the linear additivity of the expectation values, even for incompatible (noncommuting) observables, is a necessary consequence that follows directly from the fundamental conservation laws of physical quantities, applicable universally. With this result, J. von Neumann’s result is fully resurrected. I identify the physical reason why dispersion-free ensembles cannot exist. After discussing the conflict of Bell’s counter-example with the factual mechanics, I highlight the result that the local hidden variable theories, for which the Bell’s inequalities were derived, are grossly incompatible with the fundamental conservation laws. In a scrutiny of the vital difference between the ‘causal incompleteness’ of quantum mechanics, discussed by J. von Neumann, and the ‘representational incompleteness’ discussed by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen, I prove the striking demarcating result that a multi-particle system that is considered causally completed can remain EPR-incomplete. I identify the wave nature of the action as the reason behind the irreducible quantum dispersion and the impossibility of dispersion-free ensembles.
Cite
APA
Unnikrishnan, C. S. (2025). Establishing J. von Neumann’s result of the incompatibility between hidden variables and quantum mechanics. Academia Quantum. https://doi.org/10.20935/acadquant7657
Vancouver
Unnikrishnan CS. Establishing J. von Neumann’s result of the incompatibility between hidden variables and quantum mechanics. Academia Quantum. 2025. doi:10.20935/acadquant7657
BibTeX
@article{Unnikrishnan2025,
author = {Unnikrishnan, C. S.},
title = {Establishing J. von Neumann’s result of the incompatibility between hidden variables and quantum mechanics},
journal = {Academia Quantum},
year = {2025},
doi = {10.20935/acadquant7657}
}
EUVIMED