Competition in Russian Science: A Mutual Defect of the Institutional and Natural Components
Science Management: Theory and Practice · 25.06.2026 · 8 (2) · 79-103
DOI: 10.19181/smtp.2026.8.2.5 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Science Management: Theory and Practice, erschienen am 25.06.2026. Verfasst von Alexander Gusev und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 26 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article addresses the problem of forming an effective competition system in science that maximizes productivity and maintains a healthy professional environment. The research is based on the hypothesis of a hierarchical three-level model of competition, which includes the upper institutional level that determines the vector of scientific development (Level 1: political competition), the operational-tactical institutional circuit (Level 2: competition for goal-setting and resources), and the level of natural competition among researchers for new discoveries (Level 3). The qualitative state of relations at each level of competition and their mutual influence shape the specific character of competition in the field. The aim of this work is to identify competing positions at the two institutional levels of competition and to assess their alignment with the level of natural competition. The information base for the study comprises the results of the “Science Policy of Russia” surveys from 2021–2024, which made it possible to uncover and systematize the sought-after positions. Drawing on sociological survey data and an analysis of regulatory legal acts, we demonstrate a malfunction at the upper level of political competition, where a choice between the inertial and mobilization modes of scientific development was not made and was replaced by palliative theses aligned with the moderate sentiments of the majority of the academic community. At the operational-tactical level, due to low trust in state regulators, the research community seeks to intercept the levers of managing the scientific sphere from state structures, taking upon itself the tasks of defining goals, selecting performers and approving results, while largely maintaining its dependence on budget expenditures for research and development. The natural competition among researchers depends on their passionarity and the constructive settings at the institutional levels of competition. The decline of the first factor and the indeterminacy of the second one lead to the aimlessness of natural competition and the erosion of ethical norms, as illustrated by the example of the practice of awarding undeserved academic degrees, according to representatives of the research community. The study concludes that the necessary conditions for implementing an effective model of competition in science are the certainty of an adequate vector for scientific development (Level 1) and sufficient passionarity within the academic community (Level 3). In turn, an effective competition model will be able to build an institutionally passionate (energetic and effective) science and technology complex as a system.
Zitieren
APA
Gusev, A., & Yurevich, M. (2026). Competition in Russian Science: A Mutual Defect of the Institutional and Natural Components. Science Management: Theory and Practice, 8(2), 79-103. https://doi.org/10.19181/smtp.2026.8.2.5
Vancouver
Gusev A, Yurevich M. Competition in Russian Science: A Mutual Defect of the Institutional and Natural Components. Science Management: Theory and Practice. 2026;8(2):79-103. doi:10.19181/smtp.2026.8.2.5
BibTeX
@article{Gusev2026,
author = {Gusev, Alexander and Yurevich, Maxim},
title = {Competition in Russian Science: A Mutual Defect of the Institutional and Natural Components},
journal = {Science Management: Theory and Practice},
year = {2026},
volume = {8},
number = {2},
pages = {79--103},
doi = {10.19181/smtp.2026.8.2.5}
}
EUVIMED