EUVIMEDUpptäck EUVIMED
Crossref

Does the Analysis of Explanations Belong to the Domain of Logic?

Олександр Кулик

Grani · 2026-05-04 · 29 (2) · 118-124

DOI: 10.15421/72694 ↗

At a glance

Journal article in Grani, published online on 2026-05-04. Written by Олександр Кулик.

AbstractBibliografiska uppgifterCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

The relevance of this article stems from the fact that the question remains open among scholars as to whether the analysis of explanations falls within the domain of logic, traditionally defined as the science of correct arguments. In this context, it is especially important to determine whether explanations as such are capable of generating knowledge, or whether this capacity is connected with the presence of an argument. The purpose of the article is to substantiate the thesis that only those explanations which are connected with arguments and are capable of forming a justified true belief, that is, knowledge, belong to the domain of logic. Among the results obtained in this study is, in particular, an argument for the thesis that successful arguments are characterized by the perlocutionary act of forming a justified true belief. It is also shown that explanations which neither contain an argument nor are accompanied by one do not provide justification and therefore cannot generate knowledge. The article argues against the position that explanations are self-sufficient as a source of knowledge. It is demonstrated that explanations can generate knowledge in three cases: (1) when they are accompanied by an inductive argument that appeals to the opinion of an epistemic authority; (2) when they take the form of an abductive argument; or (3) when they take the form of a deductive-nomological explanation. It is shown that explanations involving non-deductive arguments can provide only probabilistic truth, whereas deductive explanations yield necessary truth. It is also argued that the illocutionary act of explanation may coincide with the illocutionary act of argument, which calls into question the thesis of a principled distinction between explanations and arguments based on the criterion of the speaker’s intention. In conclusion, the article maintains that the analysis of explanations belongs to the domain of logic only insofar as explanations are carried out in the form of an argument or are accompanied by one. Logic does not study all aspects of explanation, but only those that directly concern its argumentative structure.

Cite

APA

Кулик, О. (2026). Does the Analysis of Explanations Belong to the Domain of Logic?. Grani, 29(2), 118-124. https://doi.org/10.15421/72694

Vancouver

Кулик О. Does the Analysis of Explanations Belong to the Domain of Logic?. Grani. 2026;29(2):118-124. doi:10.15421/72694

BibTeX
@article{2026,
  author = {Кулик, Олександр},
  title = {Does the Analysis of Explanations Belong to the Domain of Logic?},
  journal = {Grani},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {29},
  number = {2},
  pages = {118--124},
  doi = {10.15421/72694}
}
Start for free →