EUVIMEDDescobrir EUVIMED
Editorial

The physiology of evolution

Denis Noble iD, Michael Joyner iD

The Journal of Physiology · 2024

DOI: 10.1113/jp284432 ↗

At a glance

Editorial in The Journal of Physiology, 2024. Written by Denis Noble and 1 co-authors. Institution: Department of Physiology, Anatomy & Genetics, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. Major MEDLINE topics: Biological Evolution. Cited 2 times so far (Crossref); 47 references.

ResumoSubjectsDados bibliográficosCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

The title of this Special Issue of The Journal of Physiology, 'The Physiology of Evolution', was chosen because only by reintegrating physiological processes back into evolutionary biology can evolutionary biology itself escape from the impasse into which a hardened version of the Modern Synthesis has led it (see Noble & Noble, 2023, specifically pp. 230−232, for the history of the hardening of the Modern Synthesis). As Charles Darwin would have been the first to recognise, it is only possible to achieve a separation between physiology and evolution by dogmatically insisting on a tight barrier between the soma and the germline, which is precisely what Weismann did in 1883 following Darwin's death in 1882. Weismann had no experimental evidence for his proposal. Indeed he wrote: 'It does not matter whether I am able to do so or not [provide experimental evidence] …once it is established that natural selection is the only principle which is to be considered, it necessarily follows that the facts can be correctly explained by natural selection' (Weismann, 1893, pp. 336−337, our emphasis). Dogma has no role in science, whether it is applied to soma–germline communication or to molecular biology. We will return to this central issue at the end of this Editorial, since we believe that the problem of the Weismann Barrier has now been solved experimentally. By contrast, Darwin worked hard during the last decade of his life, together with the physiologist George Romanes (1886a,b), to prove that there is soma–germline communication, so convinced was he that physiology held the clues to what was still missing from his grand scheme of evolutionary biology (Noble, 2022a). Today, 142 years later, we can at last see the beginnings of a reunion of these two great domains of biology. The ramifications of such a reunion are vast; well beyond the remit of a single issue of a journal. But the already substantial evidence we present here in this issue is sufficient to show what lies ahead. We hope that this will encourage more physiological research on evolution. For far too long, physiology has been relegated to being irrelevant to evolutionary biology. The 21 articles published here show that, on the contrary, it is deeply relevant. As Guest Editors for this Special Issue, we expected a good response, since for a decade now there has existed a group, THETHIRDWAYOFEVOLUTION (https://www.thethirdwayofevolution.com), that discusses and shares new insights well beyond the bounds of the standard Modern Synthesis. Even so, the range and depth of the work presented here shows that physiology is ready to meet the challenge of leading the way out of the impasse of the dogmatic versions of the Modern Synthesis. The articles can be divided into six areas of research. Munaron et al. (2024) show how our systems of naming protein functions can be very misleading. Proteins can be coaxed into various shapes by their microenvironment and do not therefore usually have single functions. As with DNA sequences, multi-functionality is common. We may have only 20,000 protein-coding genes, but we have hundreds of thousands of possible protein sequences, and even more possible three-dimensional structures. Intriguingly, they cite Lamarck as the first biologist to warn against confusing our categorisation of Nature with Nature itself. Spitzer's (2024) challenging article tackles the origin of life question. Early evolution included the incorporation of ions into functional RNAs and proteins, notably potassium and magnesium. He identifies the earth's rotation as the physical force that 'kept prebiotic molecules in continuous cyclic disequilibria in Usiglio-type intertidal pools.' Metal ions are therefore a kind of 'fossil' that may indicate what happened in the earliest stages of life on earth. They get incorporated into proteins, forming enzymes and channels, and can act as co-activators for RNA ribozymes (Brannvall & Kirsebom, 2001). Spitzer identifies crowding as a key factor, meaning that there is a critical degree to which living cells can tolerate free water. Much of the cell is more like a colloidal gel, which he calls the cytogel. From these speculations he designs a pre-Cambrian tree of life (Fig. 7 in his article). Of course, the story is necessarily incomplete: 'The puzzle is thus incomplete; completing it depends on new pieces from microbiology, geobiology, biochemistry and colloidal chemistry.' Reading this article, physiologists may be daunted by the challenge. To Spitzer's proposal, we suggest that it will require those areas of study to cooperate with open-minded physiologists to hope to resolve these important questions. Shapiro's (2024) article demonstrates how physiological regulation must have been a very early development in living systems since it can be found even in bacterial films, which use quorum sensing to regulate their growth and feeding. They also engage extensively in natural genetic engineering by freely exchanging DNA: 'DNA modification in bacteria occurs by fully organic processes subject to physiological regulation. That is the basic message of this brief note.' 'Natural genetic engineering', for which Shapiro is to be applauded, requires physiological regulation if it is to succeed in harnessing stochasticity. The outcome is that the evolution of genomes cannot be purely random (Beavan et al., 2023). Gontier (2024) tackles head-on the fact that 'The main reason for this exclusion [of physiology from evolutionary biology] is that physiology has a presential and futuristic outlook on life, while evolutionary theory is traditionally defined as the study of natural history.' She argues that physiology necessarily needs to deal with function, causation, teleonomy, agency and cognition. She concludes that 'physiologists have been key players in larger debates held in the evolutionary and biomedical sciences over reductionism versus holism, mechanism versus emergentism, structure versus function, proximate versus ultimate causes of behaviour, ontogeny versus phylogeny, and gene-determinism versus epigenetics.' These arguments are further developed in the article by de Loof (2024). '"Life" sounds like a noun, but denotes an activity, and thus is a verb.' Life is therefore a process, not itself a thing. Its cessation (death) is not therefore the disappearance of any particular matter. It is the disappearance of a particular physiological organisation. 'Through problem-solving that precedes selection, life itself is the driving force of its own evolution.' He paraphrases Dobzhansky: 'Nothing in biology and evolutionary theory makes sense except in the light of the ability of living matter to communicate, and by doing so, to solve problems both the hardware and the software way.' It all comes down to agency, organismic autonomy. Rosslenbroich (2024) argues persuasively that 'throughout evolution organisms increase their independence from and stability towards environmental influences.' This is the key factor in the evolving of the evolutionary process. It is what Philip Ball (2024), in his new book, How Life Works, calls 'causal spreading'. Causation is taken increasingly away from molecules and towards higher and higher levels of organisation. Or, to put it as Rosslenbroich does: 'There seems to be a large-scale trajectory in evolution during which some organisms gained in autonomy and flexibility.' Again, this requires that genome evolution cannot be purely random (Beavan et al., 2023). Agency is nowhere more apparent than in 'a suite of apparently non-functional, pleasurable behaviours observed in human and non-human animals', otherwise called 'play'. Lewis (2024) explores possible physiological feedforward and feedback processes that may underly this intriguing process. She shows that play behaviour can have many different physiological functions. This is important, just as much as the fact (referred to in previous articles) that molecules do too, notably including genes and proteins. Recall Munaron et al's (2024) reminder from Lamarck about confusing our categorisation of Nature with Nature itself! Ariza-Mateos et al. (2024a) explore what they call 'mRNA archaeology', which refers to 'the search for such structural/functional relics that may be informative of early evolutionary developments in the cellular and viral worlds.' That would mean that 'RNA enzymes (ribozymes) and protein enzymes have … certain structural elements that are present in some cellular mRNAs and viral RNAs, so raising the possibility that there could be a continuity of form and function, even though the biochemical basis is different. Their hope is to 'trace the origin of proto-mRNA molecules, prior to the advent of the genetic code and the elements able to bind to the ribosome.' In their second article (Ariza-Mateos et al., 2024b), the authors explore another feature that follows from treating living systems as causal agents: they communicate meaning as well as the physical objects by which communication is achieved. This is a further area in which physiology can contribute to a deeper understanding of evolutionary biology. On a strictly reductionist interpretation of biology, the issue of meaning does not even exist. Yet the popularisations of neo-Darwinism freely attribute words that imply meaning where such meaning cannot even make sense, such as 'selfish', 'book of life' and 'blueprint' as applied to the molecule DNA. The authors of this article are to be thanked for providing an over-arching review of the many aspects of biosemiosis as the field has developed in recent years. It is no longer possible for physiology or evolutionary biology to avoid the issue of meaning in living systems (Noble, 2021). Related to the issues of biosemiosis are the issues surrounding the concept of cognition applied to living systems. Now that we apply the word to artificial intelligence, it is surely no longer possible to deny it to living systems. Alexander (2024) points out that cognition is not just a property of nerve cells and brains. All cells are cognitive in the relevant sense. Her article focuses on what she calls irrational learning, and proceeds to show that, perhaps paradoxically, such neural irrational cognition 'may also lead to favourable outcomes and "creative" solutions.' 'Understanding new learning in such physical terms, makes it easier to imagine how cognition does, in fact, occur in simple organisms, body tissue and plants, not just in organisms with complex neural tissue.' Baluška et al. (2024) base physiology on the cell principle: all cells derive from other cells: 'all currently living organisms supports a singular principle: all organismal physiology is based on cellular physiology that extends from unicellular roots.' Their view is that 'all cells are endowed with individual sentient cognition that guides their individual agency, behaviour and evolution.' They define the senome as 'the effective apparatus that links the cellular reception of external environmental cues to its productive cellular deployment.' In other words, 'the cellular senome supports cellular sentience as the embodied mind of the cell.' Their article raises important questions concerning multicellularity and the identification of self. This innovative view of the evolution and physiology of all currently living organisms supports a singular principle: all organismal physiology is based on cellular physiology that extends from unicellular roots. Using the theme 'bubbling beyond the Barrier', Phillips and Noble (2024) lay Weismann's imagined barrier finally to rest. There can surely no longer be any doubt that the barrier idea, first formulated in 1883, has misled evolutionary biology for nearly a century and a half. Most damagingly, it cut physiology off from having any role whatsoever in the process of evolution. They write: 'How gametes learn about bodily changes has implications not only for the clinic, but also for evolutionary theory by bringing together intra- and intergenerational mechanisms of phenotypic plasticity and adaptation.' They also conclude by paying homage to Darwin's gemmule theory: 'because GEI [germline epigenetic inheritance] may use a soma–germline vehicle so close to Darwin's 'gemmule', this ought to remind us that, in science, 'progress [is] often achieved by a 'criticism from the past' … Theories are abandoned and superseded by more fashionable accounts long before they have had an opportunity to show their 'virtues.' A letter to The Journal (Sun & Liu, 2024) commenting on this article confirms what Darwin and Romanes were aiming to achieve in their research together and highlights the role of DNA in soma–germline communication. Noble and Phillips (2024) then use the principle of germline epigenetic inheritance to propose a solution to the problem of speciation. They use the evidence from Romanes's 1886 publications to show that he and Charles Darwin were actively exploring a physiological solution to the problem that, without mechanisms of reproductive isolation, natural selection alone would not be able to account for speciation. Romanes called this process 'physiological selection'. By updating the idea using epigenetic changes as leading the process, they show that the idea is open to experimental test. This is an open invitation to the world of physiology to search for specific ways in which this could be done: 'Through clarifying the basis of reproductive isolation in populations, further physiological studies, including emerging epigenetic methodologies, could now lead the way to a more complete understanding of the origin of species.' Moelling (2024) also addresses the issue of epigenetic inheritance. In her article, the focus is on the precise processes by which the genome is regulated by small RNAs. Her conclusions open the way to many unanswered questions that remain for future research: 'How sperm RNA-encoded information is decoded in early embryos to control offspring phenotypes also remains unclear. Is there a "sperm RNA memory" and how is it deciphered? This is not only interesting scientifically but may also be important for future applications and precision medicine, and may help to control intergenerational transmission of obesity and type 2 diabetes mellitus susceptibility … In humans it remains unknown to what extent sperm RNA can be directly amplified and how it can affect next generations by transgenerational effects.' Root-Bernstein and Bernstein (2024) describe an agent-based model of the results of the long-running Lenski experiment on the evolution of Escherichia coli. 'The key problem today is to explain the conservation of the interactomes that constitute core physiological processes. Stated simply, how does an evolutionary process that is based on random variations that produce divergent adaptations also result in increasingly networked interactomes that are highly conserved across species?' They show that 'the answer lies in the possibility that evolution selects on functional modules composed of connected biochemical and physiological processes rather than on individual genetic variations. Natural selection acts upon phenotypes, not genotypes.' 'The result is a punctuated form of evolution …, in which evolution proceeds very quickly when interactomes begin to form but which slows as interactomes become more robust.' Their work vindicates an approach based on phenotype selection of physiological processes. This article has also attracted an intriguing commentary letter, Tez (2024), arguing that 'the application of chaos opens up the opportunity of a novel dynamic access to evolution' since 'Evolution is problem solving' (De Loof, 2004; Popper, 2001). Bacigalupi and Favareau (2024) propose a 'view of coordination on the neuronal level that is neither sequential nor stochastic, but instead implements a causal logic of phasic alignment, such that an organism's learned and inherited sets of diverse biological affinities and sympathies can be resolved into a continuous and complex range of patterns that will implement the kind of novel orientations and radical generativity required of such organisms to adaptively explore their environments and to learn from their experiences.' A key feature of their model is that it draws on the distinction between two kinds of cycle in biology: sequential ring causation, like coupled enzyme reactions (e.g. the Krebs cycle), and simultaneous cycles, like the Hodgkin cycle. The forms of casualty are significantly different (Noble, 2022b, 2023). Physiology has yet to explore the full consequences of this difference. They conclude: 'physiological coordination in living systems can be explained by the harnessing of ever-novel dimensions within the relevant noise via the large population of reactive nodes with diverse affinities for their shared milieu.' Caporale (2024) explains why the ability to evolve itself evolves. The reason is that 'multiple biochemical mechanisms can and have evolved that increase the relative probability of adaptive mutations' since 'the generation of heritable variation is in a feedback loop with selection.' She concludes: 'The power to observe the generation of variation directly, paired with metadata documenting environmental contexts in time series, is opening a groundbreaking path into a deeper understanding of the organization and representation of information in genomes, and of the mechanisms that generate distinct classes of variation, upon which selection acts.' As evolution evolves it inevitably increases the probability of adaptive mutations. King (2024) also shows that there are multiple processes by which adaptive mutations can occur. 'The probability for adaptive variation can be increased by several mechanisms that generate mutations abundantly. Such mechanisms, here called "mutation protocols," implement implicit "constraints which deconstrain".' He concludes: 'The memorable assertion that evolution is "just something that happens, willy-nilly", in spite of unrelenting selection to minimize mutation rates (Dawkins, 1976), is wrong. Protocols for the spontaneous, nonaccidental production of potentially adaptive mutations are woven into normal physiology. As memorably asserted by Earl and Deem (2004), "Not only has life evolved, but life has evolved to evolve."' Cano-Martinez et al. (2024) contribute to adaptive variation processes with an article on homeostasis and evolution in relation to regeneration and repair. Their article might equally well have been categorised under the heading 'physiology and speciation' since their argument is that regeneration and repair processes lead to different stable stationary states, and therefore inevitably to different forms of epigenetic inheritance. Such states will also be candidates for eventual hard-wiring via genetic assimilation if the relevant environmental conditions persist. They conclude: 'Although many articles have been published that mention the terms evolution and homeostasis, most of them do not show the vision on the role of evolution in homeostasis through hormetic and homeorhetic loops, particularly in the field of regeneration and repair. Furthermore, we do not know of papers exploring the role of natural selection on the feedback loops involved in these processes. Moreover, there are no relevant publications that impact the thesis of this review as far as we know.' Having summarised the contributions to this issue, we return to the question of soma–germline communication. We highlighted Charles Darwin's decade-long collaboration with the physiologist George Romanes (Romanes, 1886a,b, 1892) because they were convinced that physiological research might complete Darwin's grand scheme of evolutionary biology. Their problem was that, in the nineteenth century, the resolution of light microscopy did not permit identification of the small particles that Darwin proposed might convey information from the som

Subjects

MeSH terms (MEDLINE)

Biological EvolutionAnimalsHumansPhysiology

Authors and institutions

  • Department of Physiology, Anatomy & Genetics, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
  • Department of Anesthesiology and Perioperative Medicine, The Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.

ORCID profiles: Denis Noble, Michael Joyner

Cite

APA

Noble, D., & Joyner, M. (2024). The physiology of evolution. The Journal of Physiology. https://doi.org/10.1113/jp284432

Vancouver

Noble D, Joyner M. The physiology of evolution. The Journal of Physiology. 2024. doi:10.1113/jp284432

BibTeX
@article{Noble2024,
  author = {Noble, Denis and Joyner, Michael},
  title = {The physiology of evolution},
  journal = {The Journal of Physiology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1113/jp284432}
}
Start for free →