EUVIMEDOpdag EUVIMED
Crossref

How to review an opinion

J. Leighton Reid, Valter Amaral, Rachel Miles, Mengyu Yin, Stephen Murphy

Restoration Ecology · 2026-11 · 34 (8)

DOI: 10.1111/rec.70514 ↗

At a glance

Journal article in Restoration Ecology, published online on 2026-08-17. Written by J. Leighton Reid and 4 co-authors. 27 references. Funded by: Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia.

AbstractBibliografiske oplysningerCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

Peer‐reviewed journals publish opinions as well as research articles. Opinions can be influential and highly cited. In 2009–2024, Restoration Ecology published 268 opinions (11% of articles), more than four out of five other ecology and conservation journals assessed (only Conservation Biology published more). Restoration Ecology opinions punched above their weight, garnering 14% of all citations. The most‐cited opinions include calls to action, questions about basic tenets, and proposed conceptual syntheses. Such papers raise unique challenges for editors and reviewers, who must evaluate manuscript quality without the typical standard of weighing evidence against conclusions. We posit six questions for editors and reviewers of opinions to consider: (1) Are there unreported conflicts of interest? (2) Is the literature review complete or does it cherry‐pick citations to support the author's narrative? (3) Can the reader build a compelling counterargument that is not sincerely represented? (4) Are citations appropriate for the statements they are purported to support? (5) Does the opinion cite empirical literature, or just other opinions? (6) Is the author misrepresenting dissenting opinion to build themselves up? We hope these questions help reviewers, editors, and readers weigh support for opinion articles and opinionated statements.

Funding

  • Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia

Cite

APA

Reid, J. L., Amaral, V., Miles, R., Yin, M., & Murphy, S. (2026). How to review an opinion. Restoration Ecology, 34(8). https://doi.org/10.1111/rec.70514

Vancouver

Reid JL, Amaral V, Miles R, Yin M, Murphy S. How to review an opinion. Restoration Ecology. 2026;34(8). doi:10.1111/rec.70514

BibTeX
@article{Reid2026,
  author = {Reid, J. Leighton and Amaral, Valter and Miles, Rachel and Yin, Mengyu and Murphy, Stephen},
  title = {How to review an opinion},
  journal = {Restoration Ecology},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {34},
  number = {8},
  doi = {10.1111/rec.70514}
}
Start for free →