EUVIMEDOpdag EUVIMED
Open access · CC BY 4.0

Open generative AI changes a lot, but not everything

Carol A. Chapelle

The Modern Language Journal · 2024-06 · 108 (2) · 534-540

DOI: 10.1111/modl.12927 ↗

At a glance

Journal article in The Modern Language Journal, published online on 2024-05-08. Written by Carol A. Chapelle. Cited 23 times so far (Crossref); 20 references. The full text is freely available (open access, CC BY 4.0).

AbstractBibliografiske oplysningerCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

Technology is again a timely topic at this moment in our profession. The appearance of generative artificial intelligence (AI) has brought an unprecedented level of public awareness and appreciation of language—both English and other world languages. The November 2022 appearance of generative AI embodied in ChatGPT ignited a combination of curiosity, imagination, and trepidation among the public. The Economist named “ChatGPT” the word of the year for 2023, with the explanation that “nothing can stop technology from dominating this year's words” (The Johnson Column, 2023, para. 7). ChatGPT captivated the attention of the public with its language performance: “The breakthrough in particular of large language models (LLMs) has been stunning. They produce prose so human-like that they have ignited a debate about whether LLMs are actually thinking (and whether students will ever do homework without them again)” (The Johnson Column, 2023, para. 7). Similarly, The New Yorker’s Sue Halpern summed up 2023 with a column entitled “The year A.I. ate the internet: Call 2023 the year many of us learned to communicate, create, cheat, and collaborate with robots” (Halpern, 2023). These are but two of the many examples of how the public media in the United States has weighed in on the publicly accessible generative AI unleashed over the previous months. need to articulate and communicate the value of language study in a social context, identify what technology offers that is positive for language education, rethink how we organize our teaching in light of technology's affordances, and be clear about what technology cannot do. (Kern, 2024, this issue, p. XX) He opens the conversation with a discussion of the new technological capabilities offered by generative AI—specifically, machine translation and ChatGPT—and with concrete suggestions for prompting students’ “critical engagement with technology guided by human teachers” (p. XX). This inflection point suggests that it is time to grapple again with our understanding of the significance of language, language teaching, and our roles as language professionals. After all, language is at center stage. Google has been responding admirably to our queries for information for years with lists of sources, links, and more precise questions for us to explore. We already had access to copious information. ChatGPT captivated the world with its language: the grammatically idiomatic, responsively contingent turn taking in natural written conversation. It soothed our sensibilities that have been irritated for years by repetitive, irrelevant responses from robotic chatbots positioned between us and the personalized information we sought from websites built to mitigate the need for human communication. This is the time for us as language professionals to increase our own critical engagement with language and language technologies in a world never so fascinated by language. As a founding faculty member of the doctoral program in Applied Linguistics and Technology at Iowa State University, I am accustomed to watching the evolution of technology as it changes the ecology of language teaching, learning, and assessment. Over the past decades, technology has delivered a continuing stream of important issues for us to study and countless avenues for expanding learners’ access to language and culture learning while developing agency as language users. The constantly evolving technologies of the past should have prepared us well for the entrance of ChatGPT, but it is necessary to stop and consider what we have learned from the past. Taking Kern's (2024, this issue) prompt to consider our preparation for this moment, I recall three episodes where I find clues for understanding the opportunity presented by the technical accomplishment manifest as generative AI. The first episode is the 50-plus years of navigating technology in language learning through research and practice. The Modern Language Journal has documented a fitting sample of this history, which is more fully displayed in journals focusing on technology and language learning, most notably CALICO Journal, CALL Journal, Language Learning & Technology, and ReCALL Journal. These journals, as well as many books, have reported the fraught quest for AI-based tools and learning activities in language teaching. The vision of the 1970s was that tutorial programs would recognize students’ sentence-level errors and provide error-specific feedback while building “student models” from the cumulative data gathered from each student's performance (Sleeman & Brown, 1982). In the 1980s, some language teachers imagined computers interacting with learners in written playful or touristic conversations in which the computer would recognize the students’ written messages and respond accordingly, creating a conversation circumscribed by the limits of the program (Underwood, 1984). Such prototype “microworlds” were conceptualized for language learning and, in some cases, primitive ones were developed. A third strand of research sought to develop pedagogical grammar checkers to provide grammatical feedback on learners’ writing (Cotos, 2014; Heift & Schulze, 2007). A fourth area where elements of AI have played a role is in virtual gaming and virtual reality (Peterson, 2023). The visions, descriptions of artifacts, and research are documented in professional journals and books, but their contribution seems almost negligible in the face of the Internet-eating, polyvocal superstar of 2023 and beyond. The interactive grammatical discourse of ChatGPT dwarfs the linguistic production limited by yesterday's AI in a tutorial, microworld, grammar checker, or virtual reality environment. The limited accuracy of the language recognition and machine translation of the past did not earn widespread trust of teachers and learners, leaving no worries about the technology writing papers for students. The anticipated results of the Athena project at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, intended to create pedagogical tools for learners of four European languages using natural language processing (NLP), instead discovered that, in Felshin's (1995) words, “NLP is hard” (p. 271). These strands of development of AI tools never made international headlines. Few made it into classrooms. Chatbots offering conversation on limited topics were not sufficiently interesting or accurate to be widely accepted; grammar checkers left errors unchecked or unresolved. They did not demand language teachers to fundamentally change how they teach. But they did contribute to the professional zeitgeist animating the study of the computer-assisted language learning of the time. This era left me with relevant takeaways including that (a) descriptive research is essential to document the contingencies in computer-mediated interactions, (b) students need guidance to learn effective strategies for using technology for language learning despite their ascribed identities as digital natives, (c) research can show benefits of technology-mediated pedagogies when they are carefully designed, appropriate to the needs of learners, engaged with over a sufficient span of time, and investigated with an appropriate methodology, and (d) perseverance is required to appreciate the unique contributions of each generation of technologies in language learning. During this period, the NLP capabilities in language learning tools improved incrementally, but the appearance of ChatGPT in November 2022 marked the beginning of a new era. A second episode that today's inflection point brings to mind was connected to the events of 9/11 in 2001. The Modern Language Association (MLA) Ad Hoc Committee on Foreign Languages referred to a “sense of crisis” at this time about the nation's “language deficit.” In the 2007 MLA report, Foreign Languages and Higher Education: New Structures for a Changed World, the ad hoc committee described the crisis in much different terms than those Kern (2024, this issue) used to characterize the circumstances giving rise to today's inflection point. The authors wrote, “In the context of globalization and in the post-9/11 environment, the usefulness of studying languages other than English is no longer contested” (Modern Language Association of America, 2007, para. 4). The challenge was seen as the need to stitch together the instrumental with the humanistic goals of world language teaching to build students’ “translingual and transcultural competence” (Modern Language Association of America, 2007, para. 4). The proposed solution was for language courses to “incorporate cultural inquiry at all levels” (Modern Language Association of America, 2007, para. 11) and the study of more subject areas in advanced courses. Cultural inquiry in language study would require that courses “situate language study in cultural, historical, geographic, and cross-cultural frames within the context of humanistic learning” (Modern Language Association of America, 2007, para. 11), which helps students to grasp their own subjectivity. Any movement toward curricula and materials targeting these goals has undoubtedly been useful for addressing today's challenges, which Kern (2024, this issue) sees as an opportunity for promoting critical engagement with technology, language, content, and culture. However, barriers to promoting cultural inquiry informed by cultural, historical, geographic, and cross-cultural frames may remain and perhaps have grown even stronger today. Kramsch (2012) identified a range of challenges including the following: a division of labor exists in language departments, where faculty teach culture only in the upper levels; some faculty do not support the goal of helping students understand their American identity; some language teachers are unprepared to discuss historical events; students’ lack of knowledge of history in general provides an insufficient basis for learning cultural histories; and textbooks do not su

Cite

APA

Chapelle, C. A. (2024). Open generative AI changes a lot, but not everything. The Modern Language Journal, 108(2), 534-540. https://doi.org/10.1111/modl.12927

Vancouver

Chapelle CA. Open generative AI changes a lot, but not everything. The Modern Language Journal. 2024;108(2):534-540. doi:10.1111/modl.12927

BibTeX
@article{Chapelle2024,
  author = {Chapelle, Carol A.},
  title = {Open generative AI changes a lot, but not everything},
  journal = {The Modern Language Journal},
  year = {2024},
  volume = {108},
  number = {2},
  pages = {534--540},
  doi = {10.1111/modl.12927}
}
Start for free →