Does a Mugger Dominate? Episodic Power and the Structural Dimension of Domination
Journal of Political Philosophy · 2020-06 · 28 (2) · 199-221
DOI: 10.1111/jopp.12202 ↗At a glance
Journal article in Journal of Political Philosophy, published online on 2019-09-10. Written by Dorothea Gädeke. Cited 76 times so far (Crossref); 37 references. The full text is freely available (open access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
Abstract (original language)
IMAGINE you are walking through a park in the twilight. Suddenly, a mugger points a gun at you, threatening to shoot you if you do not hand over your valuables. Is this an instance of domination? Many authors working within the neo-republican framework—including Philip Pettit himself—are inclined to say ‘yes’. After all, the mugger case seems to be a paradigmatic example of what it means to be at someone’s mercy; to be dependent on someone else’s will. However, I argue that this conclusion is based on a misleading, purely interactional account of domination that misconceives its essentially structural character. Domination, I maintain, is a structurally constituted form of power. Whether the mugger in the park dominates you or not can only be established by analysing the wider power structures in which your interaction is embedded. My argument is a contribution to neo-republican debates on the concept of domination. I focus on a power-theoretic analysis of the structural dimension of domination. I do not address the merits of non-domination as a conception of freedom (though I briefly highlight implications of my argument for critics of Pettit’s theory of freedom in Section III). Neither do I provide a full account of domination. My aim is limited: I will show that domination, as conceived of in neo-republican terms, is best interpreted as a structurally constituted form of power. This holds for both interpersonal and systemic domination. While this argument contributes to the recent debate on ‘structural domination’, my point
Cite
APA
Gädeke, D. (2020). Does a Mugger Dominate? Episodic Power and the Structural Dimension of Domination. Journal of Political Philosophy, 28(2), 199-221. https://doi.org/10.1111/jopp.12202
Vancouver
Gädeke D. Does a Mugger Dominate? Episodic Power and the Structural Dimension of Domination. Journal of Political Philosophy. 2020;28(2):199-221. doi:10.1111/jopp.12202
BibTeX
@article{Gdeke2020,
author = {Gädeke, Dorothea},
title = {Does a Mugger Dominate? Episodic Power and the Structural Dimension of Domination},
journal = {Journal of Political Philosophy},
year = {2020},
volume = {28},
number = {2},
pages = {199--221},
doi = {10.1111/jopp.12202}
}
EUVIMED