How Do Collaborative Approaches Shape Power Dynamics in Therapeutic Relationships? Evidence From Recovery‐Oriented Mental Health Services
Wie kollaborative Ansätze Machtverhältnisse in therapeutischen Beziehungen prägen? Evidenz aus recovery-orientierten psychiatrischen Diensten
Health Expectations · 2026-06 · 29 (3)
DOI: 10.1111/hex.70707 ↗Auf einen Blick
Die qualitative Studie beschreibt, wie Macht in recovery-orientierten therapeutischen Beziehungen interaktiv sichtbar wird. Aus 30 Einzel- und 15 dyadischen Interviews ergaben sich vier Beziehungsmuster.
Fragestellung
Wie werden Machtverhältnisse in recovery-orientierten therapeutischen Beziehungen interaktiv hergestellt, ausgehandelt und sichtbar?
Methode
Qualitative Studie mit 15 Service-Usern aus einer italienischen recovery-orientierten psychiatrischen Versorgung und 15 von ihnen benannten Bezugspersonen; 30 Einzel- und 15 dyadische Interviews; narrative-interaktionelle Analyse.
Ergebnisse
Identifiziert wurden vier interpretative Muster: parity-oriented dynamics, declared parity with observed dominance, non-categorizable dynamics und acknowledged dominance. In einigen Dyaden zeigte sich trotz beschriebener Kollaboration asymmetrische narrative Kontrolle.
Einschränkungen
Die vier Muster werden als heuristische Konfigurationen und nicht als definitive Typologie beschrieben.
Schlussfolgerung der Autor:innen
Kollaboration in recovery-orientierten Beziehungen lässt sich nicht allein aus Aussagen oder Berufsrollen ableiten, sondern muss über die situativen interaktionellen Praktiken analysiert werden.
Kernaussagen
- Vier Beziehungsmuster wurden identifiziert, darunter parity-oriented dynamics und acknowledged dominance.
- Selbst bei beschriebener Kollaboration zeigte sich teils asymmetrische narrative Kontrolle.
- Macht erscheint als relationaler, ausgehandelter Prozess in therapeutischen Beziehungen.
Deutsche Zusammenfassung: KI-gestützt aus dem Original-Abstract erstellt; alle Zahlen wurden automatisch mit dem Original abgeglichen. Maßgeblich ist der Original-Abstract.
At a glance
Journal article in Health Expectations, published online on 2026-06-02. Written by Elena Faccio and 8 co-authors. Institution: Department of Philosophy, Sociology, Education and Applied Psychology, University of Padua, Padua, Italy. Major MEDLINE topics: Mental Health Services, Mental Disorders, Cooperative Behavior, Power, Psychological. 39 references. The full text is freely available (open access, CC BY 4.0). Funded by: Università degli Studi di Padova.
Topics: Psychiatrische Pflege
Abstract (original language)
Introduction
Recovery‐oriented mental health services emphasise collaboration, empowerment and service‐user involvement. However, less is known about how power is enacted within relationships described as collaborative. This study explores how power dynamics are interactionally produced, negotiated and made visible within recovery‐oriented therapeutic relationships.
Methods
The study involved 15 service users from an Italian recovery‐oriented mental health service and 15 facilitators identified by them as significant to their recovery. Data comprised 30 individual interviews and 15 dyadic interviews. Dyadic interviews served both to gather participants’ accounts and to observe how the relationship was narratively enacted in interaction. Transcripts were analysed through a narrative‐interactional framework informed by Gubrium and Holstein's approach, with attention to narrative activation, composition, performance, collaboration and control. Coding focused on both what participants said about the relationship and how they co‐constructed, confirmed, redirected or constrained each other's narratives.
Results
Four interpretive patterns were identified: parity‐oriented dynamics, declared parity with observed dominance, non‐categorizable dynamics, and acknowledged dominance. These patterns are better understood as heuristic configurations rather than definitive typologies. Parity‐oriented dyads were characterised by reciprocal narrative completion, mutual recognition and flexible turn‐taking. In other dyads, participants described the relationship as collaborative, while interaction showed more asymmetrical narrative control. One dyad displayed acknowledged directiveness, experienced by the service user as supportive rather than coercive. Across cases, professional role alone did not explain how power was enacted.
Conclusion
Collaboration in recovery‐oriented relationships cannot be inferred from participants’ declarations or professional role categories alone. Rather, it needs to be examined through the situated interactional practices by which participants make space for, limit, complete or authorise one another's accounts. The study contributes a qualitative framework for analysing power as a relational and negotiated process within therapeutic relationships. Patient or Public Contribution Individuals with lived experience were actively involved in interpreting the research findings through discussion and feedback sessions. A final dissemination meeting with participants enabled the validation of these interpretations and contributed to concluding reflections on the practical implications for mental health services.
Subjects
MeSH terms (MEDLINE)
Author keywords
Authors and institutions
- Department of Philosophy, Sociology, Education and Applied Psychology, University of Padua, Padua, Italy.
- University of Naples Federico II, Napoli, Italy.
- Transmural Mental Health Department, Head of Psychiatry Unit - Northern District - Trento (Italy), Integrated University Healthcare of Trento, Via Giovanni Battista Borsieri, Trento, Italy.
- University of Naples Federico II. Department of Neurosciences and Reproductive and Odontostomatological Sciences, University of Naples, Federico II, Napoli, Italy.
ORCID profiles: Elena Faccio, Michele Rocelli, Diego Romaioli, Giacomo Chiara, Roberto Vitelli, Ludovica Aquili
Funding
- Università degli Studi di Padova
Cite
APA
Faccio, E., Rocelli, M., Binaggia, L., Giolli, E., Romaioli, D., Chiara, G., Agostini, C., Vitelli, R., & Aquili, L. (2026). How Do Collaborative Approaches Shape Power Dynamics in Therapeutic Relationships? Evidence From Recovery‐Oriented Mental Health Services. Health Expectations, 29(3). https://doi.org/10.1111/hex.70707
Vancouver
Faccio E, Rocelli M, Binaggia L, Giolli E, Romaioli D, Chiara G, et al. How Do Collaborative Approaches Shape Power Dynamics in Therapeutic Relationships? Evidence From Recovery‐Oriented Mental Health Services. Health Expectations. 2026;29(3). doi:10.1111/hex.70707
BibTeX
@article{Faccio2026,
author = {Faccio, Elena and Rocelli, Michele and Binaggia, Lorenzo and Giolli, Elisa and Romaioli, Diego and Chiara, Giacomo and Agostini, Claudio and Vitelli, Roberto and Aquili, Ludovica},
title = {How Do Collaborative Approaches Shape Power Dynamics in Therapeutic Relationships? Evidence From Recovery‐Oriented Mental Health Services},
journal = {Health Expectations},
year = {2026},
volume = {29},
number = {3},
doi = {10.1111/hex.70707}
}
EUVIMED