Farming as a Way of Life: Precarious and Complex
Culture, Agriculture, Food and Environment · 2013
DOI: 10.1111/cuag.12012 ↗At a glance
Journal article in Culture, Agriculture, Food and Environment, 2013. Written by Stephanie Paladino and 1 co-authors. Cited 3 times so far (Crossref).
Abstract (original language)
“Economically speaking, industrial farming is a difficult, precarious, and expensive endeavor,” note Gray and Gibson in their study (this issue) of the forces affecting farmer decisions in Kansas. Whether in Africa or the Americas, on U.S. network TV or in rituals in Zanzibar, the hardships and precariousness of farming of any kind, particularly in the face of increasing environmental, economic, and political risk, pervade most of the articles in this issue of CAFE. Sustainability, everyone's ideal, requires us to take a long-term view. It requires us to make decisions that preserve land resources and life systems; that retain and expand knowledge for resilience and adaptation; and that produce satisfying, stable livelihoods and sustenance for farmers and global populations alike. All things being equal, what farmer would not prefer to nurture land and community guided by this vision? Yet the range of cases presented here show the complex sets of interactions—where all things are indeed not equal—within which farmers practice, and the complex problems and risks they negotiate on a constant basis. One pervasive theme is the impact of various degrees and scales of market integration, technification, and industrialization on farmers and farming. The cases presented show different sides of the industrialization and globalization conundrum: on the one hand, farmers driven almost inextricably into increasing scales of high-stakes, high-risk industrialization in the United States, and on the other hand, driven off the land and into poverty by export commodity production in Senegal. In Zanzibar, farmers turn decidedly away from “technical,” “scientific,” and market-oriented production, while in Senegal and Mexico, they create new narratives for the social, spiritual, and environmental goals of agricultural production. Other common threads weave through these case studies. We see how different kinds of knowledge, authority, and power compete, complement, and transform one another in response to changing social–ecological environments. There is a decided holism and avoidance of reductionist analyses. These authors take special care to place farmers and farming practices in historical and contemporary context, and to link multiple scales of agency and interaction. As a result, we see how farming policies and practices evolve not only as ways to meet food and material needs, but also as strategies to resolve different social, economic, political, and environmental problems created by dynamics operating at personal to global scales. Seen in these ways, it becomes clearer why farming as a way of life, at all scales and degrees of commercialization, is so precarious, and how it is that some farming practices can come to seem so counterintuitive in relation to sustainability, to the point of trading human or environmental welfare for the achievement of fragile, short-term goals. At the same time, we see how farming's predicament is giving rise to strategies to reclaim environmental stewardship, while strengthening community livelihoods, identity, and well-being. In our first article, “Actor–Networks, Farmer Decisions, and Identity,” Benjamin Gray and Jane Gibson provide an outstanding study of industrialized agriculture in the state of Kansas in the United States, that, in many ways, sets the stage for a fuller appreciation of the insights from all the articles in this issue. Analytically, it packs a triple punch: a capsule history of industrialized agriculture in the United States; a lucid explanation of actor–network theory (ANT), contrasted with different ways that farmer decision making has been studied; and finally, the application of ANT to their careful field research. The authors provide a crystal clear and sympathetic analysis of how Kansas farmers become increasingly committed to an ever-escalating mode of high-technology, high-finance, and high-risk agriculture, even as they recognize its detrimental effects on farmer autonomy and knowledge, as well as on family, community, and environmental welfare. By using ANT, Gray and Gibson achieve an unusual degree of holistic analysis, showing how “the industrial agricultural network” is constructed over time by an array of actors, including people, organizations, and nature, and ultimately generates increasing inequalities of influence among its participants. Erin Dean's “Contested Ecologies: Gender, Genies, and Agricultural Knowledge in Zanzibar” provides a dramatic and informative snapshot of highly gendered agricultural practices and knowledge, embodying significant ecological, social, and spiritual interrelationships. At first, Dean uses this snapshot to pose provocative questions about the role of gendered knowledge and authority in shaping women's agricultural practices, which here operate without commercialization and resist the incursions of “scientific” and “technical” knowledge from outside agents. She then expands the analysis in time and place, however, to show how women's farming practices and environmental knowledge cannot be fully explained without reference to additional political, economic, and identity contexts, such as recent controversies over land control and appropriation. In contrast to the first two articles, which look at different ends of the subsistence-industrialization spectrum, the Senegalese cases Laura Cochrane describes fall somewhere in the middle. In “Land Degradation, Faith-Based Organizations, and Sustainability in Senegal,” Cochrane also takes care to put Senegalese agriculture in historical context. Policies pushing export production at the expense of diverse local subsistence strategies, in combination with economic crises, extensive droughts, and political change, have resulted in degraded rural landscapes and loss of local environmental knowledge and skills. Here, Cochrane highlights how local, faith-based organizations seek to rebuild the rural landscape from the inside out and ground up, as they “involve whole communities in their own reorganization, and they do so in a way that employs the cultural heritage and resources of the communities to adapt to” and restore their changing environments. The emphasis is on reclaiming and expanding local knowledge to fashion new-old techniques of production, within frameworks of community self-definition. In a related theme of reinvention, Sarah Lyon shows us how Mexican agriculturalists, both large and small scale, work at redefining their identities and positions within global markets. In “Coffee Tourism in Chiapas: Recasting Colonial Narratives for Contemporary Markets,” Lyon describes an increasing response to the volatility of global markets for certain kinds of commodities: the use of identity narratives to create specialty product niches. Lyon focuses on two different kinds of coffee producers in southern Mexico, each linked by a common history of export coffee production, but divided by historical placement on opposite sides of the labor/capital equation. Here, in order to improve market positions, a foreign-owned, large-scale plantation and a cooperative of smallholder, indigenous producers each use agritourism and contrasting, distinctly refashioned, historical and political narratives to “ascribe value to their own product and identity in the global economy.” CAFE's research report and commentary section also highlights the relationships among knowledge, identity, narrative, markets, and sustainability. In “Anthropology and Traditional Ecological Knowledge: A Summary of Quantitative Approaches to Traditional Knowledge, Market Participation, and Conservation,” Elizabeth Olson provides a review of recent advances in quantitative approaches to studying the distribution of traditional ecological knowledge (TEK), primarily among indigenous populations in Latin America. She further summarizes the evolution and findings of studies of TEK in relation to market integration, and elaborates the implications of such studies for improving environmental conservation policy and projects. In a lighter vein, Annie Specht's “Killer Corn and Capitalist Pigs: Forensic Noir and Television Portrayals of Modern Agricultural Technology” shows us how even contemporary CSI-type television shows have entered the debate: “You think farming is Ma and Pa with a pitchfork. Farming is big business. You have to take risks.” She analyzes episodes of two programs, CSI: Miami and Bones, where the crimes committed were directly related to intensive production agriculture. The forensic dramas paint a largely negative portrait of modern agriculture as exploitative and profit driven—criticisms often lobbed at television itself as a medium for cultural production. In the journal's last section, three book reviews link corporate agriculture, food production, and health in general. Brent Wasser explores Cornucopia: Leveraging Agriculture to Improve Health and Nutrition; Daniel Schneider and Joan Mencher review Will Allen's The War on Bugs; and Gregory Gullette reviews The Built Environment and Public Health by Russell P. Lopez. Finally, in CAFE's film review, Katherine O'Donnell looks at environmental justice as presented in Yellow Fever: The Navajo Uranium Legacy, a 2013 documentary coproduced by Tina Garnanez and Jay Minton. This issue of CAFE asks us to consider the increasing complexities and risks of agriculture as a way of life, as faced by farmers worldwide. Sixty years ago, family farming was still a strong part of an American identity narrative that linked an agrarian past to a resilient and optimistic future. This agrarian promise, represented by one of our most symbolic crops, corn, was often summed up in the simple saying “knee high by the Fourth of July.” Today, climate, genetic resources, markets, water and energy, and other environmental and social challenges militate against any easy predictions about the agricultural future.
Cite
APA
Paladino, S., & Simonelli, J. (2013). Farming as a Way of Life: Precarious and Complex. Culture, Agriculture, Food and Environment. https://doi.org/10.1111/cuag.12012
Vancouver
Paladino S, Simonelli J. Farming as a Way of Life: Precarious and Complex. Culture, Agriculture, Food and Environment. 2013. doi:10.1111/cuag.12012
BibTeX
@article{Paladino2013,
author = {Paladino, Stephanie and Simonelli, Jeanne},
title = {Farming as a Way of Life: Precarious and Complex},
journal = {Culture, Agriculture, Food and Environment},
year = {2013},
doi = {10.1111/cuag.12012}
}
EUVIMED