Exploring the Guessing‐Game Experimental Paradigm: Inferences From Closed‐ Versus Open‐Ended Semantic Space
Cognitive Science · 2026-03 · 50 (3)
DOI: 10.1111/cogs.70199 ↗At a glance
Journal article in Cognitive Science, published online on 2026-03-23. Written by Svetlana Kuleshova and 8 co-authors. Institution: Center for Language Evolution Studies, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń. Major MEDLINE topics: Semantics, Comprehension. 46 references. The full text is freely available (open access, CC BY 4.0). Funded by: Sarka Kadava for the inspiration to use WordNet and ConceptNet. We also want to thank two anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments and suggestions, National Science Centre of Poland (NCN).
Abstract (original language)
How we measure success in signal comprehension experiments fundamentally shapes our conclusions. Two recent studies have demonstrated that humans can guess the meanings of novel vocalizations and ape gestures above chance when selecting from limited alternatives. We replicated both experiments using open‐ended responses instead of multiple choice. For the vocalization data, where participants provided single‐word or short‐phrase responses, we systematically compared three evaluation methods applied to the same responses: exact matching, graded similarity ratings, and computational semantic similarity. For the gesture data, we applied graded similarity ratings. Each evaluation method revealed a different semantic landscape. Participants’ success was very low when measured by exact matching, moderate by similarity ratings, and substantially greater by computational measures, which capture broader thematic connections. Despite these differences, a consistent pattern emerged across both datasets and all evaluation methods: success was determined primarily by properties of the signals (their semantic category and degree of transparency) rather than individual participant abilities. Participants often reliably distinguished broad categories (actions vs. objects, animals vs. artifacts) but rarely identified specific concepts—and these distinct patterns only became visible through a combination of evaluation methods. In sum, our results partly align with the original studies yet also diverge in ways conducive to different conclusions about naïve humans’ ability to understand novel vocalizations or ape gestures. We show that closed‐ versus open‐ended response formats, and different evaluation scales, function as complementary research tools rather than competing approaches. Each reveals different aspects of how humans navigate semantic space when interpreting novel signals. Experimental and evaluation designs are, therefore, not a technical detail but a theoretical choice about which semantic relationships we seek to expose.
Subjects
MeSH terms (MEDLINE)
Author keywords
Authors and institutions
- Center for Language Evolution Studies, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń.
- Institute of Advanced Studies, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń.
- ArScAn-Équipe AnTET (UMR 7041), CNRS, Université Paris Nanterre.
- Leibniz-Zentrum Allgemeine Sprachwissenschaft (ZAS).
- German Department, Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf.
- Centre for Languages and Literature, Lund University.
Funding
- Sarka Kadava for the inspiration to use WordNet and ConceptNet. We also want to thank two anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments and suggestions
- National Science Centre of Poland (NCN)
Cite
APA
Kuleshova, S., Ćwiek, A., Hartmann, S., Pleyer, M., Sibierska, M., Placiński, M., Blomberg, J., Żywiczyński, P., & Wacewicz, S. (2026). Exploring the Guessing‐Game Experimental Paradigm: Inferences From Closed‐ Versus Open‐Ended Semantic Space. Cognitive Science, 50(3). https://doi.org/10.1111/cogs.70199
Vancouver
Kuleshova S, Ćwiek A, Hartmann S, Pleyer M, Sibierska M, Placiński M, et al. Exploring the Guessing‐Game Experimental Paradigm: Inferences From Closed‐ Versus Open‐Ended Semantic Space. Cognitive Science. 2026;50(3). doi:10.1111/cogs.70199
BibTeX
@article{Kuleshova2026,
author = {Kuleshova, Svetlana and Ćwiek, Aleksandra and Hartmann, Stefan and Pleyer, Michael and Sibierska, Marta and Placiński, Marek and Blomberg, Johan and Żywiczyński, Przemysław and Wacewicz, Sławomir},
title = {Exploring the Guessing‐Game Experimental Paradigm: Inferences From Closed‐ Versus Open‐Ended Semantic Space},
journal = {Cognitive Science},
year = {2026},
volume = {50},
number = {3},
doi = {10.1111/cogs.70199}
}
EUVIMED