Prominent Premaxilla in Bilateral Cleft Lip: A Blinded Expert-Panel Assessment of Orthopedic Response and Final Aesthetic Outcomes

Vollständiger Abstract

Worum geht es in dieser Arbeit?

Background: A prominent premaxilla in bilateral cleft lip presents significant orthopedic and surgical challenges. Although presurgical infant orthopedics (PSIO) is widely used, evidence linking orthopedic response to clinically meaningful outcomes remains limited. This study evaluated orthopedic response, need for lip adhesion, and final aesthetic outcomes using blinded expert-panel assessments. Methods: Fifty consecutive bilateral cleft patients treated with PSIO were reviewed, including 25 treated with nasal elevator and lip taping (NE) and 25 treated with Presurgical Lip-Alveolus-Nose Approximation (PLANA). Twenty-seven patients with prominent premaxilla underwent blinded assessment of orthopedic response by 3 cleft surgeons and 3 orthodontists. Final aesthetic outcomes were evaluated in a separate blinded assessment of 50 postoperative cases, mixing patients with and without prominent premaxilla to minimize recognition bias. Results: The prevalence of prominent premaxilla was similar between groups (60.0% versus 48.0%; P =0.571). Lip adhesion was required more frequently in NE-treated than PLANA-treated patients (46.7% versus 8.3%; P =0.043). Patients treated with PLANA demonstrated superior orthopedic outcomes for premaxillary position, columellar length, and overall PSIO response (all P 0.05). Evaluators showed poor ability to identify initially prominent premaxilla based on final appearance alone. Overall PSIO response correlated with final nasolabial appearance (ρ=0.48, P =0.024). Conclusions: Although a prominent premaxilla represents a more challenging initial deformity, it did not predict inferior final appearance. Better orthopedic response was associated with more favorable final aesthetic outcomes, supporting the clinical relevance of effective presurgical orthopedic correction.