Weber’s law in feelings does not support James’s theory of emotions: Commentary on Berkovich and Meiran (2023, 2024).
Emotion · 2026-12 · 26 (8) · 2003-2009
DOI: 10.1037/emo0001656 ↗At a glance
Kommentar in Emotion, 2026-12. Written by Ardi Roelofs. Institution: Centre for Cognition, Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Radboud University. Major MEDLINE topics: Emotions, Psychological Theory, Pleasure.
Abstract (original language)
Using an evidence-accumulation model of feeling generation to analyze manual responses, Berkovich and Meiran (2023, 2024) observed that feelings of pleasure and displeasure evoked by stimuli follow Weber's law (Weber, 1834, 1846). They regarded this finding as strong support, and perhaps the strongest yet, for James's (1884) theory of emotions, according to which emotions are sensory experiences of bodily changes. Here, I argue that Weber's law in feelings cannot, strictly speaking, support James's sensory theory, simply because he excluded feelings of pleasure and displeasure from his theory. James (1894) made this particularly clear in response to Lehmann (1892), who observed that the bodily change (i.e., change in heartbeat and respiration) evoked by stimuli developed after the feeling of pleasure or displeasure was reported, and that therefore the experience of the change could not be the feeling. In modern physiological studies, central indicators of pleasure and displeasure have also been found to precede peripheral bodily changes. Furthermore, the primary interoceptive and proprioceptive brain areas were not found to be activated during pleasure and displeasure, compared to a neutral state. So even if we were to extend James's theory to feelings of pleasure and displeasure, Berkovich and Meiran's findings, in the absence of physiological evidence to the contrary, would not support the theory. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2026 APA, all rights reserved).
Subjects
MeSH terms (MEDLINE)
Authors and institutions
- Centre for Cognition, Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Radboud University.
ORCID profiles: Ardi Roelofs
Cite
APA
Roelofs, A. (2026). Weber’s law in feelings does not support James’s theory of emotions: Commentary on Berkovich and Meiran (2023, 2024). Emotion, 26(8), 2003-2009. https://doi.org/10.1037/emo0001656
Vancouver
Roelofs A. Weber’s law in feelings does not support James’s theory of emotions: Commentary on Berkovich and Meiran (2023, 2024). Emotion. 2026;26(8):2003-2009. doi:10.1037/emo0001656
BibTeX
@article{Roelofs2026,
author = {Roelofs, Ardi},
title = {Weber’s law in feelings does not support James’s theory of emotions: Commentary on Berkovich and Meiran (2023, 2024)},
journal = {Emotion},
year = {2026},
volume = {26},
number = {8},
pages = {2003--2009},
doi = {10.1037/emo0001656}
}
EUVIMED