EUVIMEDObjevte EUVIMED
Crossref

Does Meritocracy Lead to Bureaucratic Quality? Revisiting the Experience of Prussia and Imperial and Weimar Germany

David Delfs Erbo Andersen

Social Science History · 2018 · 42 (2) · 245-268

DOI: 10.1017/ssh.2017.48 ↗

At a glance

Journal article in Social Science History, published online on 2018-01-14. Written by David Delfs Erbo Andersen. Cited 15 times so far (Crossref); 72 references.

AbstraktBibliografické údajeCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

How do state bureaucracies become high-quality organizations? Leading comparative politics studies assume that bureaucratic quality is forged by the introduction of meritocratic personnel systems because meritocracies, in contrast to politicized bureaucracies, select the most competent applicants for the jobs at hand. However, in line with principal-agent theory I propose that without a certain level of responsiveness of bureaucrats to the government in place and its policies, the positive consequences of meritocracy for bureaucratic quality are drastically reduced. Meritocracy is likewise essential to bureaucratic quality but, given that it demands some bureaucratic autonomy, meritocracy also creates a control problem. To study the consequences of meritocracy for bureaucratic quality, I revisit bureaucratic developments in the paradigmatically important historical cases of Prussia as well as Imperial and Weimar Germany. Based on extant scholarship of Prussian and German bureaucratic history, the analysis shows that bureaucratic quality varies over time with responsiveness even when meritocraticness is constant at high and low levels, and that governments knowing this hesitate to adopt meritocratic systems despite their advantages if they believe the bureaucracy will be unresponsive. Studying Prussia and Germany historically helps distinguish between the consequences for bureaucratic quality of meritocracy from those of responsiveness. On this basis, I identify where comparative politics studies may benefit from adding, in a comparative historical perspective, responsiveness to the explanation of bureaucratic quality.

Cite

APA

Andersen, D. D. E. (2018). Does Meritocracy Lead to Bureaucratic Quality? Revisiting the Experience of Prussia and Imperial and Weimar Germany. Social Science History, 42(2), 245-268. https://doi.org/10.1017/ssh.2017.48

Vancouver

Andersen DDE. Does Meritocracy Lead to Bureaucratic Quality? Revisiting the Experience of Prussia and Imperial and Weimar Germany. Social Science History. 2018;42(2):245-268. doi:10.1017/ssh.2017.48

BibTeX
@article{Andersen2018,
  author = {Andersen, David Delfs Erbo},
  title = {Does Meritocracy Lead to Bureaucratic Quality? Revisiting the Experience of Prussia and Imperial and Weimar Germany},
  journal = {Social Science History},
  year = {2018},
  volume = {42},
  number = {2},
  pages = {245--268},
  doi = {10.1017/ssh.2017.48}
}
Start for free →