EUVIMEDObjevte EUVIMED
Crossref

Getting to grips with the bovine tuberculosis biosecurity evidence base

Andrew W Byrne

Veterinary Record · 2025-01-04 · 196 (1) · 31-33

DOI: 10.1002/vetr.5083 ↗

At a glance

Journal article in Veterinary Record, published online on 2025-01-03. Written by Andrew W Byrne. Institution: One Health Scientific Support Unit, Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Dublin, Ireland. Cited 1 times so far (Crossref); 26 references.

AbstraktBibliografické údajeCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

BOVINE tuberculosis (bTB), caused by Mycobacterium bovis, remains stubbornly persistent in parts of the UK and Ireland despite ongoing and expensive eradication efforts.1, 2 The presence of wildlife reservoirs, particularly badgers (Meles meles), appears to be a common factor in regions where eradication is challenging.3 While the primary approach to controlling bTB at the population level is a test-and-cull regime, the insidious nature of the pathogen, including complex transmission pathways that can involve wildlife, means that a multifaceted approach is likely to be most successful in reducing disease risk. Indeed, evidence suggests that the bTB risk of individual herds can vary considerably depending on several modifiable biosecurity-related risk factors.4, 5 Biosecurity involves practicable actions to keep infection out of a herd, also known as external biosecurity, and reduce the possibility that infection might spread if it gets into the herd, also known as internal biosecurity or biocontainment.6 When it comes to bTB, biosecurity-related risk-mitigation approaches aim to prevent the introduction of infection via the movement of animals, prevent spread via fomites or the shared environment and prevent spillback infection from wildlife sources. Encouraging farmers to adopt these risk-mitigating approaches requires significant levels of engagement, clear communication and provision of advice on what measures they can practically implement to reduce their herd's bTB risk.7 Similarly, veterinarians in the field are key stakeholders that can influence farmer ‘buy in’ for bTB control programmes,7 and they have been found to express more confidence in fulfilling this role when bTB biosecurity training is provided.8 However, such advice and training requires robust evidence and clear communication about uncertainties. Current evidence on the effectiveness of biosecurity measures to reduce contact between cattle and wildlife in reducing the bovine tuberculosis risk in cattle is inconsistent and sometimes contradictory. This may partly explain the low uptake of such measures on English cattle farms Sourcing cattle from high-risk locations or herds with a recent history of bTB emerged as one of the most significant contributors to bTB risk.9 Such evidence is essential for informing debates around the regionalisation of control13 and risk-informed trading policies14 to empower farmers to manage their exposure to infection. The contiguity of neighbouring farms and the bTB status and history of these farms were also found to be important factors influencing a farm's bTB risk. Having many higher-risk farms that are contiguous or within the same local area was associated with increasing bTB risk across several of the studies analysed by Voller and colleagues.9 The mechanism of spread in these scenarios may be via direct contact, with evidence for increased risk associated with animal-to-animal contacts among contiguous or non-contiguous neighbours supporting advice to reduce such contact. However, one cannot discount that the clustering of infection among neighbours at local levels may be due to indirect transmission pathways involving wildlife reservoirs. There was sparse evidence for manure and slurry management as a biosecurity factor associated with elevated bTB risk. While there was evidence for an increased risk associated with using contractors to spread slurry15 or manure and spreading slurry all year round,16 another study found a reduced risk of bTB where cattle had access to fields after slurry had been recently applied.17 However, M bovis can survive in manure and slurry when spread on pasture, and some have speculated about the risk of indirect transmission via these routes.18 More research is clearly required to fully understand the risk posed by manure and slurry management and develop effective mitigations. Similarly, internal biosecurity, which focuses on limiting the spread of infection within herds, has received relatively little attention in the context of bTB. Strategies such as quarantining newly purchased animals, improving housing, improving ventilation and separating animals according to their disease risk all have strong preventive potential19 but remain underexplored for bTB. However, improving internal biosecurity is particularly important in the face of evolving herd structures (eg, increasing herd size, intensification of production, zero-grazing system adoption). Therefore, there is an urgent need for more robust evidence-based internal biosecurity practices. Beyond the systematic review of the literature, Voller and colleagues also analysed 4074 disease report forms completed after bTB incidents on cattle farms in England in 2018 and 2019. The majority of these farms reported badger activity (68-85 per cent), but there was little reported evidence of risk mitigation towards this potential exposure.9 Other research would suggest that risk mitigation approaches (eg, fencing off badger setts) might be even lower on farms that have not recently had a breakdown.15 Why farmers are not engaging with risk mitigation is a difficult and complex question, but it may be related to a lack of knowledge, the perceived impracticality of interventions, feelings of negativity and disengagement or their prioritisation of bTB risk relative to other on-farm activities.20-24 In conclusion, the study by Voller and colleagues provides a critical benchmark for understanding the current evidence base for bTB biosecurity. Importantly, while there are lines of evidence supporting the advice contained in current plans, such as the Defra five-point plan in Great Britain10 and the bTB biosecurity targeted advisory service on animal health in Ireland,25 all current studies are retrospective, and many have significant design limitations. While study quality was not explicitly evaluated in the review, most of the included studies would only achieve a low rank (eg, level 4 of 5) using the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine levels of evidence.26 This study should be a clarion call to improve the evidence base for biosecurity advice by undertaking further work using improved study designs, standardised and validated measures of biosecurity and increased statistical power to measure effects.

Authors and institutions

  • One Health Scientific Support Unit, Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Dublin, Ireland.

Cite

APA

Byrne, A. W. (2025). Getting to grips with the bovine tuberculosis biosecurity evidence base. Veterinary Record, 196(1), 31-33. https://doi.org/10.1002/vetr.5083

Vancouver

Byrne AW. Getting to grips with the bovine tuberculosis biosecurity evidence base. Veterinary Record. 2025;196(1):31-33. doi:10.1002/vetr.5083

BibTeX
@article{Byrne2025,
  author = {Byrne, Andrew W},
  title = {Getting to grips with the bovine tuberculosis biosecurity evidence base},
  journal = {Veterinary Record},
  year = {2025},
  volume = {196},
  number = {1},
  pages = {31--33},
  doi = {10.1002/vetr.5083}
}
Start for free →