What Are Journals and Reviewers Concerned About in Data Papers? Evidence From Journal Guidelines and Review Reports
Learned Publishing · 2025-04 · 38 (2)
DOI: 10.1002/leap.2001 ↗At a glance
Leitlinie in Learned Publishing, published online on 2025-03-14. Written by Xinyu Wang and 1 co-authors. Cited 4 times so far (Crossref); 35 references. The full text is freely available (open access, CC BY 4.0). Funded by: National Office for Philosophy and Social Sciences.
Abstract (original language)
The evolution of data journals and the increase in data papers call for associated peer review, which is intricately linked yet distinct from traditional scientific paper review. This study investigates the data paper review guidelines of 22 scholarly journals that publish data papers and analyses 131 data papers' review reports from the journal Data . Peer review is an essential part of scholarly publishing. Although the 22 data journals employ disparate review models, their review purposes and requirements exhibit similarities. Journal guidelines provide authors and reviewers with comprehensive references for reviewing, which cover the entire life cycle of data. Reviewer attitudes predominantly encompass Suggestion, Inquiry, Criticism and Compliment during the specific review process, focusing on 18 key targets including manuscript writing, diagram presentation, data process and analysis, references and review and so forth. In addition, objective statements and other general opinions are also identified. The findings show the distinctive characteristics of data publication assessment and summarise the main concerns of journals and reviewers regarding the evaluation of data papers.
Funding
- National Office for Philosophy and Social Sciences
Cite
APA
Wang, X., & Xu, L. (2025). What Are Journals and Reviewers Concerned About in Data Papers? Evidence From Journal Guidelines and Review Reports. Learned Publishing, 38(2). https://doi.org/10.1002/leap.2001
Vancouver
Wang X, Xu L. What Are Journals and Reviewers Concerned About in Data Papers? Evidence From Journal Guidelines and Review Reports. Learned Publishing. 2025;38(2). doi:10.1002/leap.2001
BibTeX
@article{Wang2025,
author = {Wang, Xinyu and Xu, Lei},
title = {What Are Journals and Reviewers Concerned About in Data Papers? Evidence From Journal Guidelines and Review Reports},
journal = {Learned Publishing},
year = {2025},
volume = {38},
number = {2},
doi = {10.1002/leap.2001}
}
EUVIMED