Utilizing co‐production to improve patient‐centeredness and engagement in healthcare delivery: Lessons from the Patient and Family‐Centered I‐PASS studies
Journal of Hospital Medicine · 2023
DOI: 10.1002/jhm.13055 ↗At a glance
Journal article in Journal of Hospital Medicine, 2023. Written by Jennifer K O'Toole and 14 co-authors. Institution: Departments of Pediatrics, Division of Hospital Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, Division of General Internal Medicine, Cincinnati Children…. Major MEDLINE topics: Delivery of Health Care, Patients. Cited 9 times so far (Crossref); 20 references. The full text is freely available (open access, CC BY-NC 4.0).
Abstract (original language)
PFCRs have become commonplace in pediatric hospitals across the United States.1 PFCRs are a "model of communicating and learning between the patient, family, medical professionals, and students on an academic, inpatient ward setting" that includes "the active participation of the patient and family in the discussion."2 Ideally, PFCRs should allow the patient, their caregivers, and all members of the interprofessional team to effectively communicate with one another and be active and equitable members of the decision-making experience, while not sacrificing efficiency or the education of trainees.1, 3-5 While the healthcare team typically goes to the patient's bedside for PFCRs, often the conversation becomes "patient proximate" (physicians speaking in the presence of patients and other providers) and not "patient-centered" (physicians engaging the patient, family, and other members of the healthcare team in active discussion), preventing effective communication, partnership, and learning between all team members.4, 6-8 Too often, physicians' voices dominate PFCRs, precluding patients, families, and nurses from participating fully.6 Despite best intentions, PFCRs, as commonly practised often create a dichotomy of "us" versus "you" that may amplify underlying inequities in healthcare.9 Why has this happened? Many hospitals and healthcare systems have not actively engaged patients and their families in a truly meaningful and fully invested way in the design and delivery of PFCRs that would allow their voices to be heard and valued. This lack of engagement has made it challenging for patients and families to become equitable partners working with physicians to ensure the health and well-being of their children, instead of bystanders to a process that was created for them.10 As a result, the design of rounds, including both its structure, timing, and language (e.g., using medical jargon or not enlisting interpreters), is insufficient to meet the needs of patients and families, and also often fails to accommodate nurses' workflow needs.11 We believe that the model of co-production provides a methodology to avoid having patients and families become bystanders in their clinical care. Further, we believe this model has wide application to inpatient healthcare delivery beyond PFCRs. Co-production allows for an environment where patients and families are included in an equitable fashion in the design of healthcare services to ensure their voice and experiences are valued and incorporated. In this report, we will share our experiences developing the Patient and Family-Centered (PFC) I-PASS Program as a model of this strategy and share our key tips for using co-production in designing healthcare delivery for the inpatient setting. Batalden et al.12 first proposed co-production as a model of service delivery in healthcare in 2016. In their model, the authors delineate a process by which health professionals and patients partner to maximize health and well-being through co-commissioning, co-design, co-delivery, and co-assessment of healthcare services. The model is based upon the premise that healthcare is a service-focused, versus product-focused, industry in which a close and equal relationship between patients and providers is pivotal. This paper stimulated further work demonstrating that co-production of healthcare services through a partnership between clinicians and patients resulted in improvements in the quality of care, safety, and patient experience.13-15 To meet the needs both of patients and a service-driven healthcare industry in the 21st century, this model suggests that healthcare providers must be trained to recognize the expertise of patients and their families in promoting their health and well-being. In 2014, the I-PASS Study Group launched the PFC I-PASS Study at seven pediatric hospitals in North America.10, 13 The study sought to redesign PFCRs through a novel bundle of interventions and to assess whether implementing this bundle of changes was associated with improvements in patient safety, family experience and engagement, and education of learners. The bundle we developed included a structured communication framework for rounds incorporating key principles of (1) family engagement, family preferences, and health literacy; (2) written communication for families; (3) multimodal training for healthcare providers; and (4) other teamwork enhancing strategies in the curricular roll-out, including real-time observations.16 Patients, families, nurses, and physicians coproduced the entire intervention. We built our team to ensure representation of patients and families at all levels of the project in a meaningful and equitable fashion across the lifecycle of the project, from planning to delivery, and evaluation. These individuals were volunteer representatives from our various study sites and national family advocacy organizations. They were represented on every committee, working group, and decision-making element of the national study team, and we also created dedicated family and nurse advisory councils for the study. We believe that creating our PFCRs bundle in co-production with patients and families ensured we embraced making families true partners in the design and delivery of healthcare delivery rather than spectators.17 Implementation of our PFCRs communication bundle was associated with a 38% reduction in preventable adverse events and improvements in family experience and engagement on rounds, without an increase in rounds duration or a decrease in trainee teaching.13 Our group followed this study with an effectiveness/implementation hybrid study at 21 sites across the United States, known as the PFC I-PASS Safer Communication On Rounds Every time (SCORE) Study, continuing the strategy of co-production as we embraced a continuous improvement mindset.18, 19 For this study, our team reviewed and refined the bundle following lessons learned from our earlier efforts to implement large-scale patient safety and communication projects in complex healthcare environments. We created adaptations with input from our family advisory committee members to fit the evolving needs of patients and families and to allow flexibility at the site level to account for local expertise, culture, and workflow while maintaining the core framework of the bundle. For example, with family member input, we developed a "do every time" process for rounds that encourages patients and families to speak first on rounds to ensure theirs is the first voice heard, and we allowed sites to adapt the written rounds' report to align with their institutional culture. Co-production in the design and delivery of healthcare endeavors prepares providers to embrace informed, equitable, and full partnerships with the patients and families for whom they care; however, operationalizing it requires careful planning, flexibility, and continual monitoring. Our experiences in the PFC I-PASS and SCORE Studies highlighted that implementing this type of program in diverse, complex healthcare environments is feasible and can result in improved communication, patient experience, and safety, albeit messy and requiring adaptability.10, 13 Creating an ideal process, to be performed the same way every time should not be the goal. Rather, striving for a process that is adaptable, meets the evolving needs of individual patients and families, works for and is supported by key invested partners, and still drives sustained improvement is the goal. Based on our team's experience, we suggest the following tips for incorporating the model for co-production in the design and delivery of healthcare endeavors, especially in the inpatient setting, which are detailed in Figure 1. These tips include: (1) intentional team development, (2) structured team engagement, (3) creating an environment of psychological safety, (4) promoting ongoing assessment and improvement, (5) incorporating patients and families into training, and (6) allowing for adaptability. While we understand the use of co-production in the design of healthcare delivery may not always be feasible, we believe that with appropriate adaptions, it could be broadly applied. This is particularly true for activities that focus on interpersonal and communication skills, shared decision-making, and patient and family engagement and education. As we increasingly drive towards healthcare as a service-focused industry in which patients and families are at the center and equity is paramount, the model of healthcare delivery must evolve. We must account for complex inpatient environments where perfection is not attainable (nor the goal), and adaptability is key. We must also ensure that the healthcare delivered includes input from patients and families. The practice of PFCRs is a prime example of which healthcare delivery, even when well-intentioned, needs to evolve. Co-production with patients and families is a key method of advancing inpatient healthcare design and delivery to meet the needs of patients in a modern, equitable world. By its nature, this model incorporates diversity of thought and experience, which has the potential to drive safer clinical environments through improved patient experience, engagement, and equity. By sharing our model of co-production in the redesign of PFCRs, we hope to promote similar activities in healthcare delivery for hospitalized children and adults. It is essential that we make patients and families—our most critical invested partners in all healthcare activities—an integral part of our systems, especially the design of patient-facing activities that involve interpersonal communication and patient and family education. As so eloquently articulated by Valerie Billingham in her address to the Salzburg Seminar (Session 356) in 1998, "Nothing about me without me."20 The authors acknowledge the efforts of the Patient and Family-Centered I-PASS SCORE Program's Education and Training Committeethat, included the following individuals: Jennifer K. O'Toole (Co-Chair), Sharon Calaman (Co-Chair), Brenda K. Allair (Family Advisor), Jennifer Hepps, Kheyandra Lewis, Katherine P. Litterer (Family Advisor), Benard P. Dreyer (Health Literacy Expert), H. Shonna Yin (Health Literacy Expert), Jennifer D. Baird, Jennifer L. Everhart, Alisa Khan, Nicholas Kuzma, Theodore C. Sectish, Nancy D. Spector, Clifton E. Yu. The authors would also like to acknowledge the efforts of the original Patient and Family-Centered I-PASS Study's Education Executive Committee, including the following individuals: Alisa Khan (Co-Chair), Theodore Sectish (Co-Chair), Nancy Spector (Co-Chair), Brenda Allair, Jennifer Baird, Claire Alminde, Rebecca Blankenburg, Sharon Calaman, Lauren Destino, Benard Dreyer, Jennifer Everhart, Jennifer Hepps, Christopher Landrigan, Christina Ledford, Amanda Mangen, Maria Obermeyer, Jennifer O'Toole, Shilpa Patel, Glenn Rosenbluth, Rajendu Srivastava, Amy Starmer, Anupama Subramony, Daniel West, Clifton Yu. This project was supported by a grant from the Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI) Award (DI-2017C3-9232). C. P. L., S. J. P., T. C. S., N. D. S., and D. C. W. hold equity in the I-PASS Patient Safety Institute. S. C., J. K. O. 'T, and S. J. P. hold stock options in the I-PASS Patient Safety Institute. J. B., S. C., C. P. L., J. K. O. 'T., S. J. P., G. R., T. C. S., N. D. S., and D. C. W. have consulted with the I-PASS Patient Safety Institute. The I-PASS Patient Safety Institute is a company that seeks to train institutions in best handoff practices and aid in their implementation. S. C., C. P. L., J. K. O. 'T., S. J. P., G. R., T. C. S., N. D. S., and D. C. W. have received monetary awards, honoraria, and travel reimbursement from multiple academic and professional organizations for teaching and consulting on various topics including handoffs, patient and family-centered care, physician performance, and medical education. The Patient and Family-Centered I-PASS SCORE Program was approved by the Institutional Review Board at Boston Children's Hospital (IRB-P00030462).
Subjects
MeSH terms (MEDLINE)
Authors and institutions
- Departments of Pediatrics, Division of Hospital Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, Division of General Internal Medicine, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, University of Cincinnati College of Medici…
- Department of Pediatrics, Division of Pediatric Critical Care, NYU Grossman School of Medicine and NYU Langone Health, New York City, New York, USA.
- Family Centered Care Department, Lucile Packard Children's Hospital Stanford, Palo Alto, California, USA.
- Institute for Nursing and Interprofessional Research, Children's Hospital Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA.
- Center for Quality Improvement with the Society of Hospital Medicine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
- Department of Pediatrics, Division of General Pediatrics, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
ORCID profiles: Jennifer K O'Toole, Michelle Anderson, Jennifer Baird, Tyler Johnson, Alisa Khan, Shilpa J Patel, Christopher P Landrigan, Nancy D Spector
Cite
APA
O'Toole, J. K., Calaman, S., Anderson, M., Baird, J., Fegley, A., Goldstein, J., Johnson, T., Khan, A., Patel, S. J., Rosenbluth, G., Sectish, T. C., West, D. C., Landrigan, C. P., Spector, N. D., & Patient and Family-Centered I-PASS Education Executive and SCORE Program Education and Training Committees (2023). Utilizing co‐production to improve patient‐centeredness and engagement in healthcare delivery: Lessons from the Patient and Family‐Centered I‐PASS studies. Journal of Hospital Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1002/jhm.13055
Vancouver
O'Toole JK, Calaman S, Anderson M, Baird J, Fegley A, Goldstein J, et al. Utilizing co‐production to improve patient‐centeredness and engagement in healthcare delivery: Lessons from the Patient and Family‐Centered I‐PASS studies. Journal of Hospital Medicine. 2023. doi:10.1002/jhm.13055
BibTeX
@article{OToole2023,
author = {O'Toole, Jennifer K and Calaman, Sharon and Anderson, Michelle and Baird, Jennifer and Fegley, April and Goldstein, Jenna and Johnson, Tyler and Khan, Alisa and Patel, Shilpa J and Rosenbluth, Glenn and Sectish, Theodore C and West, Daniel C and Landrigan, Christopher P and Spector, Nancy D and Patient and Family-Centered I-PASS Education Executive and SCORE Program Education and Training Committees, Patient and Family-Centered I-PASS Education Executive and SCORE Program Education and Training Committees},
title = {Utilizing co‐production to improve patient‐centeredness and engagement in healthcare delivery: Lessons from the Patient and Family‐Centered I‐PASS studies},
journal = {Journal of Hospital Medicine},
year = {2023},
doi = {10.1002/jhm.13055}
}
EUVIMED