EUVIMEDOpdag EUVIMED
Leserbrief

The RCOG statement on foetal pain: Still much to do

Carlo Bellieni

European Journal of Pain · 2023

DOI: 10.1002/ejp.2109 ↗

At a glance

Leserbrief in European Journal of Pain, 2023. Written by Carlo Bellieni. Institution: Department of Pediatrics, University of Siena, Siena, Italy. Major MEDLINE topics: Pain, Fetus. Cited 2 times so far (Crossref); 6 references.

AbstractSubjectsBibliografiske oplysningerCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recently issued a revision (Royal College of Obstetrics and Gynecologists, 2022) of its previous document on foetal pain. This theme is particularly important, because it allows us to shed light on the development of nociceptive systems in particular in humans. It also has the aim of contrasting the hypothesis of an excessively early appearance of foetal pain. Reading the document carefully, however, some things convince us, others a little less. First of all, we note that the reference to a supposed foetal analgesia induced by neuro-inhibitory substances in the foetal blood has disappeared in the new version. We had already pointed out that these substances are not present at a level capable of giving analgesia to the foetus; indeed in some cases, they are found at higher levels in the pregnant mother than in the foetus (Bellieni, 2021). Furthermore, these substances at most give sedation, and the concept of sedation is very different from that of analgesia. The second positive note is that, while in the previous document, the use of foetal analgesia was not recommended for foetal therapeutic surgery, in the present document it is admitted in the case of surgical interventions. This is important both because in case of pain, the foetus can move abruptly compromising the operation, and because pain can provoke a blood pressure increase that can cause brain damage. We had already reported which pain medications are used in these cases (Bellieni, 2019). The weak point of this document is its insistence on the threshold of 28 weeks from conception to distinguish when the foetus can feel pain. The drafters of the document rely on three points to make this distinction. The first is the presence of foetal movements in response to noises: ‘Sonographic assessment of auditory evoked reflexes between 16 and 40 weeks of gestation reveals their onset at 28 weeks, as the incidence of spontaneous movements declines (Das et al., 2020)’ In reality, this study was performed to assess the onset of hearing responses and not of pain, and in this trial, it is reported that these responses increase at 29 weeks, but are not absent before that age. So authors write: “These findings suggest fetal hearing develops at or before 28 weeks of intrauterine life”; moreover, in the RCOG document the authors explain that other reports show this date to be earlier. The second point is the appearance of the ‘human connectome’ at 28 weeks: ‘Advances in MRI have made it possible to characterize distributed spatial patterns of correlated fluctuations in spontaneous brain activity known as resting state networks (…). These networks can be readily identified in preterm infants from 28 weeks postmenstrual age’. However, the study the authors cite to endorse this statement (Doria et al., 2010) is done in a cohort of babies older than 29 weeks of gestational age, so it is hard to tell what occurs in younger babies and foetuses. Furthermore, the same authors cited by RCOG are uncertain about the meaning of the resting state neurons, to which the RCOG instead attributes an important meaning in the perception of pain: ‘The functions of the resting state neurons remain unclear’ (Doria et al., 2010). The third relies on a study of infant facial movements that shows no difference at 28 weeks between movements in response to a painful versus a non-painful stimulus (Green et al., 2019), though in reality, this study shows that a different response emerges at 33 weeks. Two remarks on this last point are necessary. The first is that newborns have a lower pain threshold than older children (see R. Slater in Neuroimage, 2010), so the apparently painless stimulus used in the quoted paper (rubbing a piece of metal under the foot) can be perceived as painful as a heel prick. Secondly, face movements alone are neither specific nor sensitive enough to evaluate pain; that is why multifactorial scales are used in the newborn: no single behaviour (e.g., crying, oxygen saturation and grimacing) is sufficient to measure pain (see Eva Gignacco in BMC Pediatr 2017). Establishing the appearance of pain sensitivity at 28 weeks worries us for another reason. If it was correct, then all babies born earlier than that date would not feel pain and should not receive analgesic treatments. This clashes with the evidence, and with the current established practice that prevents, measures and treats pain in all premature babies born and hospitalized in the neonatal intensive care unit, even those aged 24 or 26 weeks. Premature newborns at 28 weeks who survive may have some difference with foetuses of the same age in a continuing gestation; they may be under different stress and hormonal states (e.g., having received steroids); nonetheless, no evidence exists that this is associated with differences in pain threshold. In conclusion, the 2010 RCOG document on foetal pain had raised several objections (Platt, 2011); the present one has improved some aspects, but I propose a further careful revision.

Subjects

MeSH terms (MEDLINE)

PainFetusHumans

Authors and institutions

  • Department of Pediatrics, University of Siena, Siena, Italy.
  • Bioethics Committee of the Tuscany Region, Florence, Italy.

Cite

APA

Bellieni, C. (2023). The RCOG statement on foetal pain: Still much to do. European Journal of Pain. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejp.2109

Vancouver

Bellieni C. The RCOG statement on foetal pain: Still much to do. European Journal of Pain. 2023. doi:10.1002/ejp.2109

BibTeX
@article{Bellieni2023,
  author = {Bellieni, Carlo},
  title = {The RCOG statement on foetal pain: Still much to do},
  journal = {European Journal of Pain},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1002/ejp.2109}
}
Start for free →