Prof Benchie and Dr Athena—A modern tragedy…
Evidence-based Preclinical Medicine · 2015
DOI: 10.1002/ebm2.8 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Evidence-based Preclinical Medicine, 2015. Verfasst von Malcolm Macleod. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Centre for Clinical Brain Sciences University of Edinburgh Scotland UK. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 1-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 17 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0). Gefördert von: National Centre for the Replacement, Refinement and Reduction of Animals in Research.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
…..in which Professor Benchie, an established super-sub-speciality clinician who spends most of his time performing laboratory research, profers advice to Athena, an enthusiastic early career physician who, although she spent summers in the lab as a medical student, is just finishing a research fellowship that included a course in clinical research and wonders whether she would prefer to devote her research time to patient-based therapeutic trials. "I still can't tempt you to my laboratory? The clean white bench, the precision scales, the control of every variable? That's where the future lies, not in messy research involving human subjects who don't take their tablets, and who default from follow up, and where you need thousands of patients to say anything of substance. Why, I can show a drug improves pain symptoms using only 6 animals" "Well, here in the lab we tend not to get involved in that sort of methodology. Our job is to show that the drug can work in our model systems" "Under the right circumstances, of course, with a model of the correct severity, in experienced hands, when the moon is in the correct phase and other heavenly bodies are appropriately distributed" "Jeez, you're asking me? You're the one talking about wanting to do clinical trials. I guess though that there are a few things you could look out for. Firstly, do the in vivo data come from a good lab?" "Look, don't start with that mumbo-jumbo. You just know their results are true because you know their work, and have reviewed their papers and so you just know. None of your fancy biases apply in the lab, because we can control everything. All the animals are identical, and we measure outcomes using machines which are not susceptible to bias. If we lose an animal during an experiment we just add another, and if you use the right statistical test on the right subgroup you need hardly any animals" "Well, you'll want to know that the findings have been reported in another lab" "I'm afraid not, but you could look in Pubmed. The trouble (Professor Benchie shifts uneasily) is that some experiments might never have been published. And, it's possible that these unpublished studies are the ones that concluded the drugs don't work—but since they never got published we don't know. You'll just have to trust the research that did get published" "Protocols? You really don't understand how bench research works, do you? A publication should be a thing of rare beauty, flawless in every respect. We might start off with a protocol, but we'll end up doing something different. How that happens isn't important. So we might look at 4 or 5 different measures of outcome, and of course we'll report the ones that show significant effects. And we'll use a range of statistical tests according to what seems to fit the data best" "Prof, now I'm really worried. I'm not sure, from what you've said, that I can rely on conclusions that come out of the lab. Far from being clean, and precise, you seem to be ignoring problems with validity which, because they also bedevil clinical studies, we've worked to prevent and overcome. Let me go and read up about this …." With this Dr Athena goes off to the biomedical library and does some literature research, helpfully guided by their staff and an expanding number of relevant publications on this issue …. Later that same month …. "Cripes, Athena. Your systematic demolition of our cherished bench research methods has shaken my confidence in my own work, and I need to go away and read and think and reformulate my research strategies and tactics. I guess you won't be coming near the lab then" "But what if—it pains me to even consider the possibility—what if it's all wrong, like the MND research, or the stroke drugs? How will you know that there's any prospect of success?" "Fraud? Are you saying that you people fabricate data, too?" "I hope that is uncommon—I've never directly observed it in my colleagues" "So what should we do?" "That, Athena, sounds like the starting point for an exciting journey. Do you mind if I join you?" David Sackett kindly commented as this work was developed, and provide the story of "Looking for the Pony"
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Centre for Clinical Brain Sciences University of Edinburgh Scotland UK.
Förderung
- National Centre for the Replacement, Refinement and Reduction of Animals in Research
Zitieren
APA
Macleod, M. (2015). Prof Benchie and Dr Athena—A modern tragedy…. Evidence-based Preclinical Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1002/ebm2.8
Vancouver
Macleod M. Prof Benchie and Dr Athena—A modern tragedy…. Evidence-based Preclinical Medicine. 2015. doi:10.1002/ebm2.8
BibTeX
@article{Macleod2015,
author = {Macleod, Malcolm},
title = {Prof Benchie and Dr Athena—A modern tragedy…},
journal = {Evidence-based Preclinical Medicine},
year = {2015},
doi = {10.1002/ebm2.8}
}
EUVIMED