EUVIMEDOpdag EUVIMED
Leserbrief

A response to Singer, Lutz, Escher, and Halladay's “a full semantic toolbox is essential for autism research and practice to thrive” in Autism Research (published online 12 Dec 2022)

Ryan Collis iD

Autism Research · 2023

DOI: 10.1002/aur.2902 ↗

At a glance

Leserbrief in Autism Research, 2023. Written by Ryan Collis. Institution: Faculty of Education, York University, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Major MEDLINE topics: Autistic Disorder, Autism Spectrum Disorder, Singing. Cited 1 times so far (Crossref); 8 references.

AbstractSubjectsBibliografiske oplysningerCiteRelated studies

Abstract (original language)

I am a parent of an autistic child and one of the “students and early-career investigators” the authors are defending. I disagree with the premise that the demand for a “dramatic lexical shift” is harmful to research(ers) and that “certain words are labeled ‘ableist’ without thought or consideration given to the context in which they are used” because there is no context where such terms are not ableist. The authors acknowledge the language they are defending is stigmatizing but think it is more appropriate to ask society to change than to use less harmful language. Goffman, in his 1968 work on stigma, noted that social groups feel entitled to make decisions on behalf of other groups “strongly support[ing] a standard of judgement that they and others agree does not directly apply to them.” (Goffman, 1986, p. 16). Suffering the consequences of your actions is not censorship. If you include a racial slur in your article journals will not want to be associated with you, and the decision on what constitutes a slur is made by the group it targets. If “Reviewers for scientific journals ... demanded the use of neutral terms in research papers” and you refused, you are asking to use language you know is offensive to the population you are studying without being held responsible. When working with members of a marginalized community researchers must “acknowledge the inequalities between themselves and community participants” and share decision-making power (Israel et al., 1998, p. 179). The authors employ two logical fallacies: (1) they “beg the claim” by stating there are two kinds of dichotomously opposed autisms and imply they are talking about the true one; and (2) they use no true Scotsman fallacy, creating a model of a true, ‘profoundly autistic’ person while any autistic who can argue against the model is clearly not that kind of autistic and has no business commenting. They claim maintaining harmful language protects “individuals who are the most severely impacted by autism”, framing their desire to use language a minority group has described as problematic in a white savioresque desire to help the other kind of autistics. The authors cite McCoy et al. (2020)’s term “partial representation” and claim that autistics objecting to medicalized and deficit-based language cannot speak on behalf of all autistics. Yet McCoy et al. follow the language preferences of “autistic self-advocates” (McCoy et al., 2020, p. 13) and conclude that representatives should speak for subgroups with whom they share a “substantial set of lived experiences.” (McCoy et al., 2020, p. 23). The authors need to justify making themselves the “partial representatives” of these subgroups. As per the UNCRPD the role of parents is to “assist and empower persons with disabilities to have a voice and take full control of their own lives” (Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, 2018). The authors also claim (without evidence) that these demands are exclusive to “mostly white, non-Hispanic individuals” but do not see the irony in non-autistics deciding what language is appropriate for autistics. They assert that “accurate, scientifically and clinically appropriate terminology” is mutually exclusive with less stigmatizing language and call for “scientists and clinicians [to] use the terms they feel best represent” what they are identifying. There is an irony in demanding scientific language be used because of the way the clinician feels while ignoring how the recipient feels. While I agree no one should be attacked, if you choose to use language you were told is offensive you cannot act surprised when people are offended, when granting agencies do not want to fund you, and when journals do not want to publish your work. To better defend their position the authors used a comparison group: people with substance abuse issues. This is a flawed comparison because autism does not require a “public health approach that captures the medical malfunction inherent” in being autistic. A better comparison would be the D/deaf and hard of hearing and Blind communities. These are communities of disabled people who have created vibrant cultures – just as autistics are doing – and they decide on what language is appropriate. The National Federation of the Blind stated “only blind people themselves can legitimately speak for the blind community” (History and Governance, 2022) while “Deaf and hard of hearing people have the right to choose what they wish to be called, either as a group or on an individual basis.” (Community and Culture – Frequently Asked Questions, 2022). This power is what autistics are demanding. Received: 28 December 2022 Accepted: 1 February 2023

Subjects

MeSH terms (MEDLINE)

Autistic DisorderAutism Spectrum DisorderSingingHumansSemantics

Authors and institutions

  • Faculty of Education, York University, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.

ORCID profiles: Ryan Collis

Cite

APA

Collis, R. (2023). A response to Singer, Lutz, Escher, and Halladay's “a full semantic toolbox is essential for autism research and practice to thrive” in Autism Research (published online 12 Dec 2022). Autism Research. https://doi.org/10.1002/aur.2902

Vancouver

Collis R. A response to Singer, Lutz, Escher, and Halladay's “a full semantic toolbox is essential for autism research and practice to thrive” in Autism Research (published online 12 Dec 2022). Autism Research. 2023. doi:10.1002/aur.2902

BibTeX
@article{Collis2023,
  author = {Collis, Ryan},
  title = {A response to Singer, Lutz, Escher, and Halladay's “a full semantic toolbox is essential for autism research and practice to thrive” in Autism Research (published online 12 Dec 2022)},
  journal = {Autism Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1002/aur.2902}
}
Start for free →