From Syria to Gaza: A Critical Analysis of the Changing Role of Neutrality in Humanitarian Discourse
Journal of Humanitarian Affairs · 01.03.2025 · 7 (1) · 38-48
DOI: 10.7227/jha.137 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Humanitarian Affairs, erschienen am 01.03.2025. Verfasst von Estella Carpi und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 142 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This paper interrogates the evolving politics of humanitarian neutrality at a discursive – rather than operational – level, through an analytical review of aid organisations’ responses to two major conflicts in the Middle East: Syria (2011–24) and Gaza (2023–present). Drawing on predominant humanitarian discourse, including fundraising appeals, media statements and official communications, the study explores how neutrality has shifted from cautious detachment in Syria to a more vocal, maximalist framing in Gaza. While humanitarian narratives during the Syrian conflict often avoided naming the government as a perpetrator – even in the face of mass atrocities – humanitarian discourse on Gaza has increasingly identified Israel as an aggressor and invoked legal terminology, including ‘genocide’. This discursive shift is attributed to intensified grass-roots mobilisation, broader alignment with the Palestinian cause, and shifting geopolitical dynamics challenging the moral viability of neutral language. Despite this transformation in public-facing discourse, institutional practices often remain constrained by donor politics and bureaucratic limitations, raising questions about the gap between narrative and action. The Gaza moment reflects a broader crisis in humanitarian legitimacy, where neutrality is no longer a universally accepted ethical stance but a contested position under growing public scrutiny. The analysis contributes to critical debates on the role of humanitarian discourse in shaping moral and political engagement during conflict.
Zitieren
APA
Carpi, E., & Diab, J. L. (2025). From Syria to Gaza: A Critical Analysis of the Changing Role of Neutrality in Humanitarian Discourse. Journal of Humanitarian Affairs, 7(1), 38-48. https://doi.org/10.7227/jha.137
Vancouver
Carpi E, Diab JL. From Syria to Gaza: A Critical Analysis of the Changing Role of Neutrality in Humanitarian Discourse. Journal of Humanitarian Affairs. 2025;7(1):38-48. doi:10.7227/jha.137
BibTeX
@article{Carpi2025,
author = {Carpi, Estella and Diab, Jasmin Lilian},
title = {From Syria to Gaza: A Critical Analysis of the Changing Role of Neutrality in Humanitarian Discourse},
journal = {Journal of Humanitarian Affairs},
year = {2025},
volume = {7},
number = {1},
pages = {38--48},
doi = {10.7227/jha.137}
}
EUVIMED