Claim Strength, Evidence Quality, and Research Boundaries in K–12 Computational Thinking Professional Development
Journal of Materials Education (Electronic) · 2025
DOI: 10.71448/jme2025121 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Materials Education (Electronic), 2025. Verfasst von Robert J. Mislevy.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Computational Thinking is an emerging expectation within STEM education in K-12 contexts, yet there are inconsistencies across the professional-development literature regarding its alignment of teacher learning with classroom implementation and outcomes on students. In this study, the claim strength that can be demonstrated from a record of 76 studies of Computational Thinking professional development for classroom integration in K-12 settings is evaluated. The corpus consists of 4,600 gross search records, 3,203 unique records, 242 screened full-texts, and 76 coded studies. Sequential Readiness Mapping is used for ordering evidence along the way from retrieval to goals, supports, and evaluation. The retained figures are further analyzed using the tools of Corpus Compression Audit, Focus-Coupling Ledger, Temporal Exposure Contrast, and Endpoint-Proximity Gradient. The results show that 1.65% of gross records and 2.37% of unique records were coded in the end. Conference proceedings make up 60.5% of the coded studies and journal articles represent 36.8%. Pedagogical focus can be found in 73.7% of studies and Computational Thinking goals in 59.2%, yet complete Computational Thinking-pedagogy-tool coupling occurs in only 14.5%. Five-day or shorter programs are 4.86 times more frequent than programs lasting the entire school year or years. Endpoint evidence is mostly clustered around teacher reaction, attitude, perception, content knowledge, and skill/application; 14.5% of coded studies mention impact on students. In response to the paper’s research question, the answer is that the record better supports claims on teacher exposure, pedagogical focus, and applied teacher learning than sustained classroom transfer and student impact.
Zitieren
APA
Mislevy, R. J. (2025). Claim Strength, Evidence Quality, and Research Boundaries in K–12 Computational Thinking Professional Development. Journal of Materials Education (Electronic). https://doi.org/10.71448/jme2025121
Vancouver
Mislevy RJ. Claim Strength, Evidence Quality, and Research Boundaries in K–12 Computational Thinking Professional Development. Journal of Materials Education (Electronic). 2025. doi:10.71448/jme2025121
BibTeX
@article{Mislevy2025,
author = {Mislevy, Robert J.},
title = {Claim Strength, Evidence Quality, and Research Boundaries in K–12 Computational Thinking Professional Development},
journal = {Journal of Materials Education (Electronic)},
year = {2025},
doi = {10.71448/jme2025121}
}
EUVIMED