ЕКСПЕРТИЗА ПРАКТИЧНОЇ РЕАЛІЗОВАИОСТІ ЗАКОНОПРОЄКТІВ: КРИТЕРІЇ ТА ЗВ’ЯЗОК ІЗ ПОДАЛЬШОЮ ОЦІНКОЮ ЕФЕКТИВНОСТІ
Європейські перспективи · 26.05.2026 · (2-1) · 638-644
DOI: 10.71404/ep.2026.2-1.82 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Європейські перспективи, online erschienen am 26.05.2026. Verfasst von Вадим Олексійович Бутенко. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The article substantiates the need to distinguish expertise of the practical implementability of draft laws as a prospective form of ex ante quality control. The article aims to define the concept and scope of the expert assessment of the practical feasibility of draft laws, distinguish it from related forms of evaluation, and formulate a system of criteria and a differentiated model for the expert opinion. The study employs a combination of methods: the praxeological method to identify the specific features of conducting the assessment; the specialized legal method to establish criteria for evaluating feasibility; and the prognostic method to determine the prospects for the practical implementation of the draft laws. Practical implementability is defined as the objectively substantiated capacity of a legal mechanism proposed in a bill to be brought into operation on time, consistently applied by competent authorities and complied with by its addressees, provided that the necessary procedural, normative, resource and temporal preconditions exist. Practical implementability is distinguished from legal certainty, prospective effectiveness and ex post evaluation of actual effectiveness. Formal compatibility and sound legislative technique do not by themselves ensure that a mechanism is functionally complete. A bill may be legally coherent yet impossible to launch because no competent authority, procedure, subordinate legislation, resources, transition period or realistic means of compliance have been provided. A five-block model is proposed, comprising subject-and-competence, procedural, normative-support, resource-and-time and addressee-oriented review. The subject of review, minimum evidence and typical implementation blockers are identified for each block. A crosscutting verification layer (an implementation passport) should record the objective, baseline, expected results, data sources, data owners and the date of subsequent evaluation. Four forms of expert conclusion are developed: implementability confirmed; confirmed subject to remediable reservations; not established because of insufficient evidence; and materially blocked by the bill’s design. Insufficient evidence should produce neither automatic approval nor an unsupported finding of impossibility. Ex ante implementability expertise should create the evidentiary baseline for legal monitoring and subsequent evaluation of the effectiveness of the enacted measure.
Zitieren
APA
Бутенко, В. О. (2026). ЕКСПЕРТИЗА ПРАКТИЧНОЇ РЕАЛІЗОВАИОСТІ ЗАКОНОПРОЄКТІВ: КРИТЕРІЇ ТА ЗВ’ЯЗОК ІЗ ПОДАЛЬШОЮ ОЦІНКОЮ ЕФЕКТИВНОСТІ. Європейські перспективи, 638-644. https://doi.org/10.71404/ep.2026.2-1.82
Vancouver
Бутенко ВО. ЕКСПЕРТИЗА ПРАКТИЧНОЇ РЕАЛІЗОВАИОСТІ ЗАКОНОПРОЄКТІВ: КРИТЕРІЇ ТА ЗВ’ЯЗОК ІЗ ПОДАЛЬШОЮ ОЦІНКОЮ ЕФЕКТИВНОСТІ. Європейські перспективи. 2026:638-644. doi:10.71404/ep.2026.2-1.82
BibTeX
@article{2026,
author = {Бутенко, Вадим Олексійович},
title = {ЕКСПЕРТИЗА ПРАКТИЧНОЇ РЕАЛІЗОВАИОСТІ ЗАКОНОПРОЄКТІВ: КРИТЕРІЇ ТА ЗВ’ЯЗОК ІЗ ПОДАЛЬШОЮ ОЦІНКОЮ ЕФЕКТИВНОСТІ},
journal = {Європейські перспективи},
year = {2026},
number = {2-1},
pages = {638--644},
doi = {10.71404/ep.2026.2-1.82}
}
EUVIMED