Rules Without Law: India’s Supreme Court and the Governance of Street Dogs
The Global Journal of Animal Law · 14.05.2026 · 14 (1) · 43-72
DOI: 10.71389/c9ms8344 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Global Journal of Animal Law, online erschienen am 14.05.2026. Verfasst von Siddhanth Prasad.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Between August and December 2025, the Supreme Court of India passed a series of suo motu orders seeking to fundamentally alter the manner in which street dogs in the country are governed. The most consequential of these orders mandated the permanent removal of all street dogs from public spaces into shelters, effectively displacing the framework established under the Animal Birth Control Rules 2023 (ABC Rules). Taken together, these orders are likely to have severe adverse consequences for both public health and the welfare of street dogs. They also raise significant questions about the legal status of street dogs, the statutory frameworks governing them, and the scope and limits of judicial power. In these respects, this article argues that the Supreme Court exceeded its jurisdiction by displacing the ABC Rules without declaring them unconstitutional and substituting them with its own preferred model of judicial governance. It further argues that this outcome is not an isolated instance of judicial excess, but the foreseeable consequence of a distinctive mode of constitutional adjudication in India, namely, public interest litigation, in which the adjudicatory process has beenprogressively stripped of the procedural safeguards that ordinarily constrain error, arbitrariness, and judicial overreach. Finally, the article contends that street dogs are particularly vulnerable to the negative effects of this form of judicial intervention because they occupy a liminal position within Indian law, being neither recognised as rights-bearing subjects nor accorded a stable legal status capable of anchoring judicial reasoning.
Zitieren
APA
Prasad, S. (2026). Rules Without Law: India’s Supreme Court and the Governance of Street Dogs. The Global Journal of Animal Law, 14(1), 43-72. https://doi.org/10.71389/c9ms8344
Vancouver
Prasad S. Rules Without Law: India’s Supreme Court and the Governance of Street Dogs. The Global Journal of Animal Law. 2026;14(1):43-72. doi:10.71389/c9ms8344
BibTeX
@article{Prasad2026,
author = {Prasad, Siddhanth},
title = {Rules Without Law: India’s Supreme Court and the Governance of Street Dogs},
journal = {The Global Journal of Animal Law},
year = {2026},
volume = {14},
number = {1},
pages = {43--72},
doi = {10.71389/c9ms8344}
}
EUVIMED