Endoscopic Vacuum Therapy Versus Self-Expanding Metal Stents for Upper Gastrointestinal Transmural Defects: A Narrative Review with Meta-Analytic Overlap Analysis, with Focus on Esophageal Anastomotic Leak and Perforation
ASIDE Gastroenterology · 09.06.2026 · 2 (3) · 13-23
DOI: 10.71079/aside.gi.060926794 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift ASIDE Gastroenterology, online erschienen am 09.06.2026. Verfasst von Rowan Bandaranaike und 4 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Background
Upper gastrointestinal transmural defects carry mortality rates exceeding 20%. Endoscopic vacuum therapy (EVT) has emerged as a promising alternative to self-expanding metal stents (SEMS), yet optimal patient selection, timing, and technique remain uncertain.
Methods
Relevant literature was identified through a narrative search of PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Library through January 2026. Corrected covered area (CCA) analysis quantified primary study overlap across meta-analyses comparing EVT to SEMS. This review was reported in accordance with the SANRA checklist.
Results
Five meta-analyses were identified, with all comparative evidence derived from esophageal anastomotic leak and iatrogenic perforation populations. CCA analysis demonstrated very high overlap (CCA = 95.0%), confirming convergent re-analyses of the same evidence base rather than independent replication. No randomized controlled trials have been completed. Within this low-certainty observational evidence, EVT was associated with higher defect closure rates (85% vs 64%), lower mortality (risk difference [RD] -0.12), shorter treatment duration (14-day reduction), and fewer adverse events (RD -0.24) compared with SEMS; all effect measures are EVT minus SEMS and should not be interpreted causally. Recent 2023-2025 data showed significantly fewer patient-level complications with EVT (8.3% vs 50%; P = .001). Critical predictors of failure include delayed initiation beyond 7 days, neoadjuvant chemoradiation, and intraluminal sponge placement.
Conclusions
EVT was associated with favorable outcomes compared with SEMS across convergent analyses, primarily in esophageal leak and perforation populations; these hypothesis-generating findings should not be extrapolated to other indications without dedicated evidence. Prospective randomized trials, FDA device pathway development, and standardized protocols remain priorities.
Zitieren
APA
Bandaranaike, R., Hewitt, B., Black, T., Lamb, P., & Rutland, T. (2026). Endoscopic Vacuum Therapy Versus Self-Expanding Metal Stents for Upper Gastrointestinal Transmural Defects: A Narrative Review with Meta-Analytic Overlap Analysis, with Focus on Esophageal Anastomotic Leak and Perforation. ASIDE Gastroenterology, 2(3), 13-23. https://doi.org/10.71079/aside.gi.060926794
Vancouver
Bandaranaike R, Hewitt B, Black T, Lamb P, Rutland T. Endoscopic Vacuum Therapy Versus Self-Expanding Metal Stents for Upper Gastrointestinal Transmural Defects: A Narrative Review with Meta-Analytic Overlap Analysis, with Focus on Esophageal Anastomotic Leak and Perforation. ASIDE Gastroenterology. 2026;2(3):13-23. doi:10.71079/aside.gi.060926794
BibTeX
@article{Bandaranaike2026,
author = {Bandaranaike, Rowan and Hewitt, Benjamin and Black, Tyler and Lamb, Paul and Rutland, Travis},
title = {Endoscopic Vacuum Therapy Versus Self-Expanding Metal Stents for Upper Gastrointestinal Transmural Defects: A Narrative Review with Meta-Analytic Overlap Analysis, with Focus on Esophageal Anastomotic Leak and Perforation},
journal = {ASIDE Gastroenterology},
year = {2026},
volume = {2},
number = {3},
pages = {13--23},
doi = {10.71079/aside.gi.060926794}
}
EUVIMED