Applying Hood's NATO framework to quantitative text analysis in policy studies: Theory, methods, and empirical applications
Journal of Sustainable Built Environment · 2026
DOI: 10.70731/mvdej997 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Sustainable Built Environment, 2026. Verfasst von Daiki Yamamoto und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Hood’s “tools of government” framework conceptualizes governing as the deployment of four fundamental resource types: nodality (information and network position), authority (legal power), treasure (financial resources), and organization (direct provision and administrative capacity). Originating as a parsimonious typology for describing how governments act, the NATO framework has become influential in policy design and policy instrument research because it offers a stable “instrument language” that is portable across sectors and political systems. Meanwhile, the “text-as-data” turn in political science and public policy has enabled researchers to analyze policy documents at scale, shifting instrument research from small-N interpretive coding toward replicable measurement of instrument presence, design features, and policy mixes. This review synthesizes how NATO has been operationalized for quantitative text analysis and situates those practices within wider advances in policy instrumentation theory and computational methods. Building on systematic review principles, it organizes contributions along three linked research programs: (1) conceptual refinement of NATO and related policy tool taxonomies in policy design and policy mixes; (2) methodological foundations of automated content analysis, including dictionary methods, supervised learning, topic models, scaling models, and span-level annotation; and (3) empirical applications that code policy instruments from legal and policy texts, including emerging annotated corpora that enable model training and benchmarking. Across these streams, recurring methodological challenges include construct validity (“instrument” as intent versus effect), unit-of-analysis selection (document, section, sentence, clause, span), multi-label coding (co-occurring instruments), calibration and intensity measurement, cross-jurisdiction comparability, and reliability of human labels. The review concludes with a research agenda for NATO-based text measurement, emphasizing transparent codebooks, hierarchical and multi-task models, evaluation against human annotation with appropriate agreement metrics, and integration of instrument coding with causal and design-oriented policy evaluation.
Zitieren
APA
Yamamoto, D., & Fujita, A. (2026). Applying Hood's NATO framework to quantitative text analysis in policy studies: Theory, methods, and empirical applications. Journal of Sustainable Built Environment. https://doi.org/10.70731/mvdej997
Vancouver
Yamamoto D, Fujita A. Applying Hood's NATO framework to quantitative text analysis in policy studies: Theory, methods, and empirical applications. Journal of Sustainable Built Environment. 2026. doi:10.70731/mvdej997
BibTeX
@article{Yamamoto2026,
author = {Yamamoto, Daiki and Fujita, Ayaka},
title = {Applying Hood's NATO framework to quantitative text analysis in policy studies: Theory, methods, and empirical applications},
journal = {Journal of Sustainable Built Environment},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.70731/mvdej997}
}
EUVIMED