ChatGPT vs. Students: A Comparative Analysis of Reflective Portfolio Assignments in Periodontal Education – A Pilot Study
AI-Enhanced Learning · 2025
DOI: 10.70725/134427jmxrwk ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift AI-Enhanced Learning, 2025. Verfasst von Kavitha Parthasarathy und 3 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Introduction
Chat GPT, an advanced language model developed by OpenAI, is rapidly becoming a valuable tool in dental education. However, the implications of relying on such technology for assessments and educational applications raise important questions about the balance between traditional educational and evaluation methods.
Purpose
To evaluate the quality of ChatGPT generated content relative to the portfolio assignments submitted by students in periodontal education.
Method
Faculty members used a structured rubric to grade the assessment sections of both student-submitted and ChatGPT generated Periodontal Reflective Portfolio assignments. The rubric evaluated three key criteria: Assessment Thoroughness, Supporting Evidence and Writing Skills. The faculty graders were unaware of the authorship of the assessment.
Results
ChatGPT demonstrated a slightly overall better performance compared to the students. However, the difference was not substantial. ChatGPT assessments showed more consistency, with lower variability in scores compared to student assessments, indicating more uniform quality in AI-generated responses. Students demonstrated a wider range of performance, with their scores spanning a broader spectrum. In rubric-specific results, students outperformed ChatGPT in thoroughness of assessment, suggesting in-depth writing. Both students and ChatGPT were equally effective in providing supporting evidence. However, ChatGPT demonstrated better writing skills.
Conclusion
When comparing student and ChatGPT assessments, we observed distinct strengths for each. Students demonstrated superior thoroughness of assessment, while ChatGPT produced well-structured writing. Both performed similarly in supporting evidence, suggesting AI's ability to present factual evidence. However, ChatGPT's consistent scores might indicate a lack of adaptability, while students' varied responses reflect a broader range of ideas and insightful evaluation, essential for formative assessment. Key Words: Periodontal Reflective Portfolio, Chat GPT, AI, Student Assessment
Zitieren
APA
Parthasarathy, K., Knight, N., Huang, J., & Lundergan, W. (2025). ChatGPT vs. Students: A Comparative Analysis of Reflective Portfolio Assignments in Periodontal Education – A Pilot Study. AI-Enhanced Learning. https://doi.org/10.70725/134427jmxrwk
Vancouver
Parthasarathy K, Knight N, Huang J, Lundergan W. ChatGPT vs. Students: A Comparative Analysis of Reflective Portfolio Assignments in Periodontal Education – A Pilot Study. AI-Enhanced Learning. 2025. doi:10.70725/134427jmxrwk
BibTeX
@article{Parthasarathy2025,
author = {Parthasarathy, Kavitha and Knight, Navid and Huang, Josef and Lundergan, William},
title = {ChatGPT vs. Students: A Comparative Analysis of Reflective Portfolio Assignments in Periodontal Education – A Pilot Study},
journal = {AI-Enhanced Learning},
year = {2025},
doi = {10.70725/134427jmxrwk}
}
EUVIMED