UNIFORM PROCEDURES FOR LEGISLATING TAX, DUTY AND FEES: RECONCEPTUALISING SECTION 59 OF THE NIGERIAN CONSTITUTION
Abuja Journal of Public Law · 01.07.2026 · 5 (1)
DOI: 10.70118/abjpl.202605010.36 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Abuja Journal of Public Law, online erschienen am 01.07.2026. Verfasst von RUKAYYA DANLADI UMAR und 2 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In recent years, Nigeria has witnessed a steady increase in the fees charged by government institutions and regulatory agencies for the provision of public services. These increases, often justified by prevailing economic realities and administrative necessities, have raised some constitutional concerns regarding the legality of executive and administrative bodies imposing or varying fees without legislative approval. Section 59 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 places taxes, duties and fees within the same legislative framework governing money bills, thereby suggesting that the imposition, increase, reduction or withdrawal of fees requires approval by the National Assembly. Notwithstanding this constitutional position, the practice of administrative agencies prescribing and reviewing fees through delegated legislation (and sometimes not) has continued unabated, creating a disconnect between constitutional theory and administrative reality. This has generated uncertainty regarding the proper constitutional treatment of fees, the scope of legislative control over their imposition and how that control may be exercised. The primary objective of this research was, therefore, to examine the constitutional framework governing the imposition and alteration of fees under section 59 of the Constitution with a view to determining whether the inclusion of fees within the provision requiring legislative approval in relation to taxes and duties is conceptually, constitutionally and practically justifiable. The research distinguished the concepts of taxes, duties and fees. It further examined the implications of delegated legislation in relation to fees, and evaluated comparative constitutional practices in selected jurisdictions. To achieve these objectives, the doctrinal methodology of legal research was adopted through a critical analysis of constitutional provisions, statutes, judicial authorities, academic literature and relevant comparative materials from other jurisdictions including but not limited to the United Kingdom and the United States. The research found that the constitutional inclusion of fees within section 59 resulted from a conceptual misapprehension of the distinction between taxes, duties and fees. It further found that, unlike taxes and duties, fees are service-based charges that require administrative flexibility and are ordinarily regulated through delegated legislation, thereby rendering the existing constitutional framework largely inconsistent with practical governance, the relevant conceptual jurisprudence and comparative constitutional practice. The research also found that the absence of clear standards governing the exercise of delegated authority to prescribe fees has contributed to legal uncertainty and the arbitrary exercise of administrative powers. Consequently, the research recommended the amendment of section 59(1)(b) of the Constitution by deleting the words “or fees” from its provisions and substituting the word “or” for the comma after the word “tax”, the establishment of clear statutory standards governing the exercise of any delegated powers relating to fees, and the adoption of conceptual jurisprudential analysis in constitutional and legislative drafting to enhance legislative coherence. The research concluded that the continued treatment of fees as money bills under section 59 is both conceptually unsound and practically unworkable. Unless appropriate constitutional and legislative reforms are undertaken, the disconnect between constitutional provisions and administrative practice will persist, thereby undermining constitutional certainty, legislative coherence and the effective administration of public services
Zitieren
APA
UMAR, R. D., ETUDAIYE, M., & ETUDAIYE, M. (2026). UNIFORM PROCEDURES FOR LEGISLATING TAX, DUTY AND FEES: RECONCEPTUALISING SECTION 59 OF THE NIGERIAN CONSTITUTION. Abuja Journal of Public Law, 5(1). https://doi.org/10.70118/abjpl.202605010.36
Vancouver
UMAR RD, ETUDAIYE M, ETUDAIYE M. UNIFORM PROCEDURES FOR LEGISLATING TAX, DUTY AND FEES: RECONCEPTUALISING SECTION 59 OF THE NIGERIAN CONSTITUTION. Abuja Journal of Public Law. 2026;5(1). doi:10.70118/abjpl.202605010.36
BibTeX
@article{UMAR2026,
author = {UMAR, RUKAYYA DANLADI and ETUDAIYE, MUHTAR and ETUDAIYE, MOHAMMED},
title = {UNIFORM PROCEDURES FOR LEGISLATING TAX, DUTY AND FEES: RECONCEPTUALISING SECTION 59 OF THE NIGERIAN CONSTITUTION},
journal = {Abuja Journal of Public Law},
year = {2026},
volume = {5},
number = {1},
doi = {10.70118/abjpl.202605010.36}
}
EUVIMED